WorkĪśvarakṛṣṇa

Sāṅkhyakārikā

The oldest surviving textbook of the Sāṃkhya school: seventy-odd verses that set a silent, watching self against restless nature.

by Īśvarakṛṣṇa11 passages held

  • Sanskrit, the original language
Original title
Sāṃkhyakārikā
First published
(published posthumously)
Original language
Sanskrit

Report a rights issue

Overview

Every life is struck by suffering of three kinds, and the first verse of this short Sanskrit poem asks why anyone should look further than the obvious remedies. The second verse answers that the remedies of the Vedas, the sacrifices, are no better than ordinary ones: they are impure, they wear off, and they reward some more than others. Release comes only from telling three things apart — the world as it appears, the unseen source it unfolds from, and the one who knows them. That is the teaching of Sāṃkhya, one of the oldest schools of Indian philosophy, set out here in its earliest surviving textbook by Īśvarakṛṣṇa, whom many historians place around 350 CE, though some reference works put him earlier. The text here gives the verses alone, without a commentary. Everything that changes, the verses argue, is prakṛti, nature or matter, active but unconscious, unfolding through twenty-three products from the intellect down to the physical elements. Against it stands puruṣa, the conscious self: there are many such selves, and each does nothing but watch. Effects already exist in their causes before they appear. Nature works for the self's release the way milk flows for a calf without knowing why, and the two are joined like a lame man carried on the shoulders of a blind one; once the self has seen what nature is, nature stops, as a dancer leaves the stage after the performance. The verses neither affirm nor deny God. The closing verses trace the teaching from a supreme sage — Kapila, in the tradition — through Āsuri and Pañcaśikha, and claim to hold the whole substance of the Ṣaṣṭitantra, "the system of sixty topics", leaving out only its stories and its disputes with rivals. Paramārtha, an Indian Buddhist monk working in China, translated the poem with a commentary into Chinese between 557 and 569, and that translation is its oldest surviving version. In 1837 the Oriental Translation Fund printed the first English translation at Oxford, by Henry Thomas Colebrooke, together with Horace Hayman Wilson's translation of the commentary ascribed to Gauḍapāda.

Key concepts

What is puruṣa in Sāṃkhya?

Puruṣa is the conscious self, pure awareness that does nothing. It is not made of anything, does not change and takes no part in action: it is the witness, the onlooker. Everything that thinks, wills or feels belongs to nature instead, and only seems conscious because the self is near it, as the verses put it.

What is prakṛti, and what comes out of it?

Prakṛti is nature or matter: one unconscious source of everything that changes. Unmanifest at first, it unfolds in a fixed order, first the intellect, then the sense of 'I', then the mind, the ten senses and five subtle elements, and finally the five gross elements, earth, water, fire, air and space. Even thought belongs to this side.

What are the three guṇas?

The guṇas, 'qualities' or strands, are the three forces nature is woven from: sattva, light and illuminating; rajas, restless and driving; tamas, heavy and obstructing. They are felt as pleasure, pain and dullness. The verses compare them to a lamp: opposed as they are, they work together for one purpose.

What does it mean that the effect already exists in its cause?

It is the doctrine of satkārya: nothing comes from nothing, so an effect must already be present, hidden, in its material before it appears. The verses give reasons: what does not exist cannot be produced, a particular effect needs a particular material, and not everything arises from everything. This is why the whole world can unfold from nature without anything new being added.

What is the subtle body that passes from life to life?

The subtle body, liṅga, is the part of a person that moves from one birth to the next. It holds the intellect, the sense of 'I', mind, senses and subtle elements, and carries the dispositions a life has formed, but it cannot taste experience without a physical body. Like an actor, the verses say, it plays one role after another.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Suffering and the Knowledge That Ends It

Pain of three kinds strikes every life, and every ordinary cure wears off. The verses ask what kind of remedy could end it for good, and answer that only knowing can.

Neither medicine nor the sacrifices of the Vedas will do, Īśvarakṛṣṇa argues, since their relief is impure, passes and is unequally shared. Virtue raises a person to higher births, detachment without insight only sinks them back into nature, and power only removes obstacles. Release comes from one thing: telling apart the manifest world, its unmanifest source and the knower, until the insight 'I am not, nothing is mine' is complete. The body then runs on for a while, like a potter's wheel after the push.

  • suffering
  • liberation
  • discriminative knowledge
  • knowledge
  • bondage
  • epistemic error
  • karma
  • residual karma
  • embodiment
  • transmigration
  • spiritual attainment
  • dispositions

Nature at Work for a Watcher

Everything that changes is unconscious, and the one who is conscious never acts. The verses ask how two such opposites could ever be bound together, and what their joining is for.

Nature, prakṛti, unfolds from its unmanifest state through the intellect, the sense of 'I', the mind and the senses down to the physical elements, all woven from three qualities. The self, puruṣa, of which there are many, only watches. Their union is a partnership of the lame and the blind, and nature's labour serves the self's release without knowing it, as milk flows for a calf. Bondage, Īśvarakṛṣṇa concludes, belongs to nature alone, and when she has been seen she withdraws like a dancer after the performance.

  • puruṣa and prakṛti
  • puruṣa
  • prakṛti
  • consciousness
  • agency
  • three qualities
  • causation
  • manifest and unmanifest
  • cosmology
  • purpose
  • plurality
  • intellect
  • mind
  • elements
  • subtle body
  • faculties

Within this work

passages held
11
distinct concepts
37
by passages held, corpus-wide
#814

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 400 Sāṅkhyakārikā (Sāṃkhyakārikā) you are here SA
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works