A World Sorted into Kinds
What is there, and how many kinds of it? The sūtras answer with a short inventory and ask the reader to accept that the self and the mind belong in it beside earth and fire.
Everything real is a substance, a quality or a motion, bound together by inherence, the tie of a quality to its bearer. Earth, water, fire, air and ether stand beside time, direction, the self and a mind no larger than an atom. The self is not seen but inferred, from breath, blinking, desire and effort, and from the word 'I'. Darkness, by contrast, is no thing at all, only light's absence, and error comes from damaged senses.
- categories
- ontology
- qualities
- motion
- inherence
- elements
- ether
- space
- gravity
- atomism
- natural philosophy
- perception
- inference
- knowledge
- cognition
- memory
- mind
- self
- causation
- sound
- absence
Enter a dialogue
- Time, direction, the self and the mind stand in your list of nine substances beside earth and water. What makes them all things of the same sort?
- Your list of qualities puts pleasure and pain, desire and effort beside colour, taste and number. Can a feeling really be sorted like a colour?
- The word 'I', you argue, proves a self without anyone having to trust scripture for it. What does saying 'I' reveal that seeing a body does not?
- Darkness seems to fill a room like a thing, yet you deny it is a substance, a quality or a motion. What is darkness, then?
- Error comes from faulty senses and old impressions, and knowledge is what is free of such faults. How can anyone tell from inside which one they have?