WorkBen Sira

Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach

Proverbs from a Jerusalem school under foreign kings, arguing that the wisdom every nation seeks is the Law of Moses.

by Ben Sira119 passages held

  • English, a translation held here, and your language
Original title
ספר בן סירא
First published
180 BCE(aged 50)
Original language
Hebrew

Report a rights issue

Overview

Around 180 BCE a scribe who ran a school in Jerusalem gathered his teaching into one book; near the end, Ben Sira names himself and his city. The book is wisdom literature in the line of Proverbs, short sayings grouped by subject — honouring an ageing father, lending money, choosing friends, behaving at a feast, calling the doctor — and through all of them it argues one thing. Wisdom comes from God and begins with the fear of him, and the wisdom other peoples search for has made its home in Israel as the law God gave to Moses. In chapter 24 Wisdom herself tells how she looked for a resting place among the nations and was sent to live in Jacob; the book identifies her outright with the Torah. He wrote in a Jerusalem ruled by the Seleucid kings of Syria, as foreign influence rose in the city. To those who blame God for their own failings he answers that God set fire and water before each person, and the hand that reaches out is the person's own. Seven closing chapters praise Israel's ancestors from Enoch to Simon son of Onias, a high priest of the author's lifetime, shown in his robes at the altar. About fifty years later the author's grandson took the book to Egypt and put it into Greek. The Greek survived and the Hebrew was lost. The rabbis kept the book out of their Bible, and a saying attributed to Rabbi Akiva, the second-century sage, counts its readers among those who lose the world to come, yet the Talmud still quotes it. The Latin churches called it Ecclesiasticus, the church book, and the Council of Trent declared it Scripture in 1546; Protestant Bibles that print it set it among the Apocrypha. In 1896 two sisters, Agnes Lewis and Margaret Gibson, brought a manuscript leaf back from the East, and Solomon Schechter at Cambridge recognised it as Ben Sira's Hebrew. About two-thirds of the Hebrew has since been recovered from the Cairo Genizah, a synagogue's storeroom for worn-out texts, and a scroll found at Masada in 1964 showed that the medieval Genizah copies descend from the original. The English here is the King James Version of 1611, translated from the grandson's Greek, without his preface; the verse numbers are the King James's.

Key concepts

Who is the woman called Wisdom in this book?

She is God's wisdom pictured as a woman who speaks for herself, and the book then names her outright as the law of Moses. She was created before all things and poured out on all God's works. In her own speech she wanders through every nation seeking rest until her Creator settles her in Jacob, where she grows like a cedar and a palm. Studying the commandments is, on this picture, keeping company with her.

What are the two kinds of shame the book talks about?

One shame leads into sin and another brings honour, and a wise person learns to tell them apart. The bad kind keeps someone silent when speaking would help, or stops them defending a friend or admitting the truth. The good kind is the blush before wrongdoing: the book lists things to be ashamed of, such as lying before a ruler, theft among neighbours or staring at another man's wife, so that shame works as a guard.

Is being rich a sign of God's favour in Sirach?

Not by itself: poverty and riches both come from the Lord, and either can be lived well or badly. Wealth is good where no sin comes with it, and blessed is the rich man found without blemish, who has not chased after gold. Yet sleepless worry over riches wastes the body, and the rich devour the poor as the lion devours the wild ass. What counts is how the money was gained and whether the poor are fed from it.

Whose advice should a person trust most, according to the book?

One's own heart, once it has been formed by the fear of God, and then a godly adviser who keeps the commandments. Every counsellor praises his own counsel, the book warns, but some advise for their own gain, so it pays to learn what an adviser wants before listening. A person's own mind, it says in a memorable image, can see more than seven watchmen sitting in a high tower, and above all of them stands prayer.

Who are the 'famous men' the closing chapters praise?

They are Israel's ancestors, praised in a long poem that runs from Enoch to Simon son of Onias, a high priest of the author's lifetime. Noah, Abraham, Moses, Aaron, David, Elijah and others each get a portrait, with their faults kept in: Solomon is wise and then led astray by women. The point is a nation's memory. Their bodies are buried in peace, but their name lives on, while others have no memorial at all.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Wisdom Finds a Home

Where does the wisdom every people looks for actually live? The book lets Wisdom answer in her own voice, and her answer is a single address.

At the book's centre Wisdom speaks for herself: she came from the mouth of the Most High, covered the earth like a cloud, walked among every people looking for rest, and was told by her Creator to pitch her tent in Jacob. The book then names her outright as the book of the covenant, the law Moses commanded. She stays larger than any reader all the same: whoever eats her is still hungry, the first man never knew her fully, and the last will not find her out.

  • wisdom
  • religion
  • creation
  • prophecy

Counsel for the House and the Market

How does a careful person lend, speak, choose friends and call the doctor without losing either goods or conscience? Every ordinary choice turns out to be a test of the fear of God.

Most of the book is advice, grouped by subject as a teacher would give it: try a friend before trusting him, since some sit at the table only in good days; lose money for a brother, but never vouch for a debt beyond one's means; keep quiet where elders talk; honour the physician, because the Lord created medicines from the earth. Prudence here is never mere self-interest. Bread withheld from the poor is called bloodshed, and an offering bought with their goods is like killing a son before his father's eyes.

  • prudence
  • friendship
  • speech
  • speech ethics
  • generosity
  • charity
  • poverty
  • wealth
  • health
  • marriage
  • self-control
  • honesty
  • shame

Praise of the Fathers

Who deserves to be remembered, and what is remembering worth when the dead cannot know it? The closing chapters sing first of God's works in the sky, then of the people who served him.

Before the ancestors comes a hymn to creation: sun and moon, snow and lightning, everything made in pairs, one against another, and nothing made imperfect. Then a long roll of the fathers runs from Enoch through Abraham, Moses, Aaron, David, Solomon and Elijah, and ends with Simon son of Onias, a high priest of the author's own day, who repaired the Temple and is shown robed at the altar like the morning star. Beside the famous stand others with no memorial, perished as though they had never been.

  • leadership
  • prophecy
  • creation
  • mortality

Within this work

passages held
119
distinct concepts
237
by passages held, corpus-wide
#470

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “religion” and “wisdom”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 19 pairings. 86 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
religionwisdom10
prudencetrust5
justicewisdom3
mortalitywisdom3
prudencespeech3
justiceleadership2
leadershipwisdom2
speechwisdom2
justicemortality1
justicereligion1
leadershipmortality1
leadershipspeech1
mortalityreligion1
mortalityspeech1
mortalitytrust1
prudencewisdom1
religionspeech1
speechtrust1
trustwisdom1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. -180 Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach (ספר בן סירא) you are here EN
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works