ScribeJudea

Ben Sira

The scribe who gave wandering Wisdom a home

1 work · 119 passages grounded

Lifespan
~230–~170 BCE
Wikipedia

The mind

In one passage of his book, the ploughman, the smith and the potter keep a city standing, and none of them is called to the council or sits in the judge's seat. Wisdom, the passage goes on, needs leisure. It belongs to the man free to study the law of the Most High, to travel among foreign peoples and to serve before rulers. That man was the author's ideal and, as far as his book shows, his own life. Ben Sira was a scribe in Jerusalem who taught young men in what he called his house of learning, and near the end of his book he wrote his name into it. The Greek gives it as Jesus son of Sirach of Jerusalem; in the Hebrew he is Yeshua son of Eleazar son of Sira, though the surviving copies give the family line in different forms.

Almost everything known of him comes from that book. He says he travelled, saw more than he could put into words, and was often in danger of death, without saying where. Historians place the writing between about 190 and 175 BCE, in a Jerusalem that the Seleucid kings of Syria had taken from Egypt's Ptolemies. He praised the high priest, Simon son of Onias, for repairing the Temple and fortifying the city's walls. Foreign, Greek-speaking influence was rising in the city, and the book urges its readers to keep God's commandments against it. Within a generation the Seleucid king Antiochus IV moved against Jewish worship itself; the book shows no sign of that persecution.

His answer to the pull of Greek learning was to claim wisdom for Israel. Earlier wisdom books, Proverbs among them, had taught a good life from what the elders handed down and what anyone could see, with little said of Israel's own history or law. Ben Sira identified wisdom outright with that law, the Torah. In chapter 24 Wisdom speaks for herself: she came from the mouth of the Most High, looked for a resting place among all the peoples, and was told by her Creator to settle in Jacob. All of this, he adds, is the book of the covenant, the law that Moses commanded. The beginning of that wisdom is the fear of the Lord, and its limit is plain: do not search out what is too hard for you, but think about what you have been commanded.

He would not let anyone blame God for sin. God set fire and water before each person, he wrote, and each stretches out a hand to whichever they choose. Reward and punishment come in this life, in a good name and in children, because the dead in Sheol, the shadowy underworld, no longer praise God. He speaks of neither resurrection nor an immortal soul. Within that frame he is practical. He tells his pupils to honour a doctor, because the Lord created medicines from the earth and the wise do not despise them, and to care for a father whose mind is failing. His warnings about wives and daughters run long and suspicious, and one verse traces sin and death to the first woman.

His grandson carried the book to Egypt, arriving in 132 BCE, and translated it into Greek for the Jews there. The rabbis left it out of their Bible, and a saying attributed to Rabbi Akiva, the second-century sage, counts its readers among those who lose the world to come. The Talmud quotes it all the same, citing his warning against searching out hidden things as a limit on speculation about God's throne. The churches read it in Greek and Latin as Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach, and the Council of Trent declared it Scripture in 1546. His Hebrew was lost for centuries, until a manuscript leaf from the Cairo Genizah, a synagogue's storeroom for worn-out texts, reached Solomon Schechter at Cambridge in 1896. A scroll found at Masada in 1964 confirmed that the Genizah Hebrew descends from what Ben Sira wrote.

Key concepts

What does 'the fear of the Lord' actually mean here?

It means a reverence for God that shows itself in keeping his commandments, and it is where wisdom starts rather than an extra added to it. The fear is not terror: it brings gladness, honour and a long life. It also outranks intelligence, since someone of small understanding who fears God is better than someone very learned who breaks the law. Wisdom, on this view, is first a way of acting.

Where does Ben Sira draw the limit of human inquiry?

At whatever lies beyond one's strength: do not seek out things too hard, he says, but think about what has been commanded. More has already been shown than people understand, and many have been misled by their own opinion. The limit is not hostility to learning, since the ideal scribe studies the ancients and travels widely. It is a rule about where to spend a mind: on what can be lived, not on God's hidden things.

What does it mean that God left people 'in the hand of their counsel'?

It means each person is responsible for their own choices. God made human beings and left them to their own decision, setting before them fire and water, life and death, good and evil, so that each reaches out for one. That rules out the excuse that God made someone sin, since God commanded nobody to do wickedly. Keeping the commandments is therefore always possible: 'if thou wilt' is the condition.

Why does everything in creation come in pairs?

Because God made the world as a set of opposites that explain each other: good set against evil, life against death, the godly against the sinner. Look at all the works of the Most High, he says, and they come two by two, one against another, and nothing has been made imperfect. Even troubling things have a place, since the same things that serve the good turn to evil for those who misuse them.

If there is no life after death, how are the good rewarded?

In this life, through a long and glad life, children, and a good name that outlasts the body. The dead no longer praise God, and nothing in his teaching promises a world to come, so justice has to be done before the grave. That is why he presses so hard on honouring parents, giving alms and turning back from sin without delay: the account is settled within the years a person has.

What exactly is a scribe, as Ben Sira describes the role?

A scribe is someone whose work is studying and teaching wisdom, and who therefore needs time free from other labour. He devotes himself to the law of the Most High, seeks out the wisdom of the ancients, prophecies and the hidden sense of proverbs, serves among great men and travels in foreign countries. He also prays, and what he learns he passes on in teaching, for a whole people to remember.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Reverence Before Cleverness

Can a clever mind reach wisdom on its own, or must it begin in reverence and obedience? Everything else he taught hangs on the answer.

Wisdom begins, for him, in the fear of the Lord, and that fear shows itself in keeping the commandments rather than in brilliance. A person of small understanding who fears God outranks a learned one who breaks the law, and knowing how to do wrong is no wisdom at all. Against minds eager for hidden things he set a limit: search out nothing too hard, think on what has been commanded, since more has already been shown than people understand.

  • wisdom
  • religion
  • humility
  • education
  • trust

The Scribe's Calling

Who has the time to become wise, and what does a city owe those who never get it? A teacher answers about his own trade.

Wisdom, he held, comes with leisure. The ploughman, the smith and the potter keep the world standing, yet none is sought for the council or the judge's seat. The scribe is free to study the law, seek out the sayings of the ancients, serve before rulers and travel through foreign countries, testing good and evil among people. He invited the unlearned into his house of learning and promised much rest for little labour under the yoke of instruction.

  • education
  • leadership
  • wisdom
  • prudence
  • speech

Fire and Water: Choice and Its Wages

If God made everything and rules everything, who answers for the wrong a person does? Nobody, he insists, may pass the blame upward.

God made human beings and left them in the hand of their own counsel, setting fire and water, life and death, before each one to reach for. No one may say God caused the fall, for he commanded nobody to do wickedly. Yet the same God sends poverty and riches, life and death, and has set good against evil throughout creation. Wages are paid in this life, mercy waits for whoever turns back without delay, and alms put out sin as water puts out fire.

  • sin
  • justice
  • divine providence
  • repentance
  • divine mercy
  • mercy
  • charity

Death Without a World to Come

What makes a life worth living well if the dead no longer praise God and nothing waits beyond the grave? He answers without promising another world.

The dead go down to the grave, where no one praises the Most High, and he speaks of neither resurrection nor an immortal soul. Death is bitter to someone at ease among possessions and welcome to the needy and worn out. Mourn bitterly for a while, he advises, then take comfort, since there is no turning back and grief only harms the living. What remains is the good day, not to be wasted, and gladness of heart, which lengthens a person's life.

  • mortality
  • health
  • religion
  • self-control

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
119
concepts traced
237
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “religion” and “wisdom”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 19 pairings. 86 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
religionwisdom10
prudencetrust5
justicewisdom3
mortalitywisdom3
prudencespeech3
justiceleadership2
leadershipwisdom2
speechwisdom2
justicemortality1
justicereligion1
leadershipmortality1
leadershipspeech1
mortalityreligion1
mortalityspeech1
mortalitytrust1
prudencewisdom1
religionspeech1
speechtrust1
trustwisdom1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: wisdom in Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach, 26.1%.

Density 0% 26.1%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 20 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearwisdomreligionprudencejusticetrustmortalityspeechleadership
Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach26.1%15.1%11.8%10.9%10.1%9.2%8.4%7.6%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. -180 Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach (ספר בן סירא)

    The whole of what survives of him: the teaching of his house of learning in Jerusalem, gathered into one book and signed with his name.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Ben Sira

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.