Biblical figureJudea

Job

The upright man who would not lie for God

1 work · 64 passages grounded

Lifespan
~550–~450 BCE
Wikipedia

The mind

The prophet Ezekiel, writing in the sixth century BCE, names Job beside Noah and Daniel as three righteous men. Even if a doomed land held all three, he says, their righteousness would save their own lives and no one else's. Job's name, in other words, was already a byword for righteousness. The book that carries it is the work of an anonymous poet, an Israelite writing in Hebrew, most likely in the Persian period, between the sixth and the fourth century BCE. Job is the book's hero, not its author, and no record of him exists outside it and the legend it drew on. This page uses the name the book gives, and its years mark an estimate of when the book was written, not a lifetime.

The book opens as a prose tale. Job lives in the land of Uz, a rich man, perfect and upright, who fears God. The LORD praises him before the heavenly court, and the adversary, Satan in the King James Version, asks whether Job fears God for nothing. Permitted to find out, Satan takes Job's herds, his servants and his ten children in a single day, then covers him with sores. His wife tells him to curse God and die. Job answers that the LORD gave and the LORD has taken away, and in all this, the tale says, he did not sin.

Then the poem begins, and the patient man disappears. Job curses the day he was born. Three friends — Eliphaz, Bildad and Zophar — come to comfort him and end by accusing him, because their teaching leaves them no choice: God is just, so suffering is punishment, and a man this ruined must have earned it. Job refuses the confession they ask for. He will hold to his integrity until he dies, he says, and he swears an oath of innocence, item by item, then demands that God answer him as a defendant answers a charge. That refusal carries the claim the book is remembered for: suffering is not proof of guilt, and a defence of God that requires the innocent to lie about themselves is a false one.

God does answer, out of a whirlwind, and asks Job where he was when the foundations of the earth were laid. The speeches range over the sea, the stars, the wild animals and the monsters Behemoth and Leviathan; they say nothing of the test in heaven. Job's last reply is usually read as repentance, but the Hebrew is difficult, and another reading has him retract nothing. Scholars still disagree. In the closing prose the LORD tells Eliphaz that the friends spoke wrongly of God and Job spoke rightly, then gives Job twice what he had before.

Tradition kept asking who he was. The Talmud records rival opinions on when he lived, from the days of Jacob to the days of Ahasuerus, the Persian king. One teaching makes him a pious man from outside Israel; in the same discussion, a sage holds that he never existed and the story is a parable. The Greek Bible ends the book by making him Jobab, a king of Edom and a grandson of Esau. The Testament of Job, a Greek retelling from around the turn of the era, makes him a king whose patience defeats Satan, and the Letter of James holds up that patience as a model. The Qur'an names him Ayyub, a prophet who called on his Lord in his affliction.

Pope Gregory the Great began his long commentary on the book, the Moralia in Job, at the imperial court in Constantinople and finished it in Rome by 595. Kant, in an essay of 1791 on why every philosophical defence of God's justice fails, sided with Job's sincerity against his friends' reasoning. In Repetition, published in 1843 under a pseudonym, Søren Kierkegaard has a young man in crisis read the book aloud at night. Carl Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist, argued in Answer to Job in 1952 that Job had shown himself more moral and more conscious than the God who tormented him. Many Sephardic congregations read the book aloud on Tisha B'Av, the fast that mourns the destruction of the Temples in Jerusalem.

Key concepts

What is the difference between complaining to God and cursing him?

Cursing God means renouncing him, and complaint means holding him to account while still speaking to him. The adversary wagers that Job will curse God to his face, and Job's wife urges him to. He never does: he curses the day of his birth and pleads with God directly. That is why the book can say he did not sin with his lips, and why God later says Job spoke rightly.

What does righteousness mean to Job?

Righteousness for Job is active protection of the weak, not private purity. He describes it as clothing he put on each day: delivering the poor who cried out, the fatherless and anyone with none to help them, so that the man about to perish blessed him and the widow's heart sang. Its measure is what the vulnerable around him received, which is why his defence before God is a list of their names.

What does Job think happens to a person after death?

He expects the grave, a land of darkness from which no one comes back. Whoever goes down there, he says, shall come up no more and his house shall know him no more. It is also a leveller: small and great lie there together, the prisoners no longer hear the oppressor. Against this background he asks whether a man who dies can live again, and leaves the question open.

Who is the witness in heaven that Job appeals to?

It is an advocate he hopes for on high, someone who will testify to his innocence even while God seems to be his accuser. In the same breath he cries, "O earth, cover not thou my blood," asking that his cry stay unburied like the blood of a murdered man. The book never names this witness; what matters is Job's conviction that the truth about him is recorded somewhere.

Why does Job think he cannot win an argument with God?

Because the two parties are not equal. God is not a man that Job could answer him, he says, and could ask a thousand questions Job could not answer once. Worse, terror would twist his own testimony: if he justified himself, his own mouth would condemn him. So he asks for two conditions of a fair hearing, that God withdraw his hand and that his dread not make Job afraid.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Faith That Argues Back

Must trust in God fall silent when God seems to have become the enemy? Job's answer is that trust may take the form of an argument, carried on to God's face.

Before the ruin his piety is scrupulous: he rises early to offer sacrifices in case his sons have cursed God in their hearts. After it, the same man says God has become cruel to him and begs not to be condemned without being shown why. "Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him," he says, and in the same verse vows to maintain his own ways before him. Complaint is addressed to God, never turned away from him, and that is the faith the book defends.

  • faith
  • hope
  • despair
  • fear
  • divine sovereignty
  • divine justice

Grief Spoken Aloud

What does a person in ruin owe the truth, and what do friends owe him? Job will not soften his pain to make it easier for anyone to hear.

Refusing to restrain his mouth, Job speaks in the anguish of his spirit. He wishes he had died at birth and gone where the weary are at rest and the servant is free from his master. He names what loss does to a body and a household: escaped with the skin of his teeth, his breath strange to his wife, young children despising him. Pity, he insists, is owed to the afflicted, and his friends failed him like streams that vanish in the heat.

  • suffering
  • grief
  • mortality
  • death
  • friendship
  • compassion
  • family

What an Upright Life Owes

What did a good man's goodness consist of before anything was taken from him? Job answers with a record of debts paid to the weakest, and stakes his innocence on it.

Righteousness, for Job, was something put on like a robe: he was eyes to the blind and feet to the lame, a father to the poor, and searched out the cause of strangers he did not know. His oath of innocence goes further. His servants could bring complaints against him, because one God made master and servant in the womb. He never made gold his hope, never rejoiced at an enemy's ruin and never let a traveller lodge in the street.

  • justice
  • oppression
  • wealth
  • prosperity
  • integrity
  • innocence
  • wickedness

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
64
concepts traced
113
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “divine justice” and “suffering”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 18 pairings. 52 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
divine justicesuffering8
divine justicewickedness7
divine justicemortality4
divine justicerepentance4
divine justiceretribution4
retributionwickedness4
justicesuffering3
mortalitysuffering3
mortalitywickedness3
repentanceretribution3
divine justicedivine power1
divine justicejustice1
divine powerjustice1
divine powersuffering1
justicemortality1
mortalityretribution1
repentancesuffering1
sufferingwickedness1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: divine justice in The Book of Job, 32.8%.

Density 0% 32.8%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 8 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYeardivine justicesufferingjusticemortalityrepentanceretributionwickednessdivine power
The Book of Job32.8%31.3%14.1%14.1%12.5%12.5%12.5%10.9%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. -450 The Book of Job (אִיּוֹב (Iyov))

    The only book behind this persona, cited here in the King James Version of 1611; the Dialogue speaks as Job the character who challenges divine justice, not as the book's anonymous poet.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Job

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.