WorkManu

The Laws of Manu

A law code in Sanskrit verse, ascribed to the first man, that fixed duty by birth and was burned in protest in 1927.

by Manu348 passages held

  • Sanskrit, the original language
Original title
Manusmṛti
Original language
Sanskrit

Report a rights issue

Overview

Great seers come to a man seated in meditation and ask him to set out, in order, the duties of every class of people: so the Manusmṛti, the "remembered tradition of Manu", begins. It is a dharmaśāstra, a treatise on dharma — the duties, rites and law that bind each person according to birth and stage of life — and it runs to some 2,700 verses. Tradition ascribes it to Manu, the first man and first lawgiver; inside the text Manu recounts the creation of the world, then hands the teaching to the sage Bhṛgu, who speaks the rest. Historians treat it as the work of an anonymous Brahmin author or authors. Patrick Olivelle, whose 2005 edition was the first fully critical one, reads its tight design as one author's plan and places it in the second century CE; others date it earlier or see a text that grew over time. The older law books, written in prose, had recorded the experts' debates and left them open. This one settled them, in verse. It names the roots of dharma: the Veda, the tradition and conduct of those who know it, the conduct of good people, and one's own contentment. It ranks the householder above the student, the forest hermit and the renouncer, since all three live on what he gives, and it forbids a man to seek liberation before he has studied the Veda, fathered sons and offered sacrifice. It fixes the four classes and their duties, places a woman under the guard of father, husband and son, and arms the king with punishment and eighteen headings of law. In 1794 William Jones, a British judge in Calcutta, published it in English. Nietzsche, reading an unreliable French version, held it up as a model of social rank. On 25 December 1927, at Mahad, B. R. Ambedkar's movement against untouchability burned a copy, and Dalit activists still mark the date.

Key concepts

What does dharma mean in the Laws of Manu?

Dharma is everything a person is bound to do: rites, moral duties and law, fitted to their class, stage of life and sex. The text names four marks by which it is known: the Veda, the remembered tradition of those who know the Veda, the conduct of good people, and what is pleasing to oneself. Beside the duties of each class it lists ten marks of dharma for everyone, among them patience, self-control, not stealing, truth and freedom from anger.

What are the four varṇas, or classes?

They are the four ranked groups into which the code sorts society by birth: Brahmins, who study, teach and perform sacrifices; Kṣatriyas, who protect the people; Vaiśyas, who keep cattle, trade, lend and farm; and Śūdras, whose one task is to serve the other three. The upper three are called twice-born, because initiation into Vedic study counts as a second birth. Below and outside the four stand mixed groups born of unions across classes.

What are the four stages of life, the āśramas?

They are four successive ways of living open to a twice-born man: the celibate student who learns the Veda from a teacher, the married householder, the hermit who withdraws to the forest, and the wandering renouncer who has given up home and fire. The code calls the householder the source of the other three, since they live on his gifts, and allows the last stage only once a man has studied, fathered sons and sacrificed.

What is daṇḍa, the rod?

Daṇḍa is punishment, pictured as the staff in the king's hand and treated as the real power behind his rule. It governs the people, protects them and stays awake while they sleep, and the wise, the text says, know it as dharma itself. The king must apply it after weighing the place, the time, the offender's means and learning: used with care it makes the people content, used rashly it ruins everything.

What is prāyaścitta, or penance?

Prāyaścitta is the rite that removes the stain of a wrong. The code grades it to the offence, from murmuring sacred verses to long fasts and vows. One standard fast runs twelve days: three eating only in the morning, three only in the evening, three on food not asked for, and three eating nothing. Public confession, remorse, austerity, study and gifts also free the wrongdoer, and a wrong once atoned for must not be repeated.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Duty Fixed by Birth

Before anyone acts, birth into one of four classes and a stage of life has already settled what they owe and to whom. At stake is whether a just order can be inherited rather than chosen.

At creation the four classes are given their work: the Brahmin studies, teaches and sacrifices, the Kṣatriya protects the people, the Vaiśya keeps cattle, trades and farms, and the Śūdra serves the other three. Better one's own duty done badly than another's done well, the rule runs. Yet the same code names virtues owed by all four alike, non-violence, truthfulness, not stealing, purity and self-restraint, and in hard times lets a Brahmin who cannot live by teaching take up a warrior's or a farmer's work.

  • social hierarchy
  • caste
  • caste hierarchy
  • dharma
  • duty
  • education
  • knowledge

The Householder's House

All other ways of life, the student's, the hermit's and the renouncer's, live on what the householder gives. What does his house owe its ancestors, its guests and its women, and what does it ask of them?

Marriage, sons and the monthly offerings to the dead keep a family line alive, and a man who seeks liberation before studying the Veda, fathering sons and offering sacrifice sinks down. Women stand at the centre and under guard: where women are honoured the gods rejoice, yet a woman is kept by her father, then her husband, then her sons, and is never fit for independence. A father may take no bride-price, and the levirate, a widow bearing a son by her husband's brother, is set out and then condemned.

  • marriage
  • family
  • gender
  • kinship
  • inheritance
  • property
  • ancestor worship
  • charity

The King and the Rod

Left without punishment, the strong would prey on the weak. What gives a king the right to wield that force, and what keeps it from turning on the people it guards?

Fashioned from portions of the gods, the king is set over the classes and stages of life to keep each in its own duty. His real instrument is daṇḍa, the rod of punishment, which rules the people, protects them and stays awake while they sleep, and which he must apply after weighing place and time. Courts sort disputes under eighteen heads, from unpaid debts to the duties of husband and wife, witnesses are told their own self watches them, and a king who oppresses his realm soon loses it.

  • kingship
  • statecraft
  • political authority
  • punishment
  • criminal justice
  • religious law
  • truthfulness

Purity, Pollution and Repair

A death in the family, a forbidden food or a wrong contact leaves a stain that only a rite can lift. Can a wrong once done be undone, and what does the undoing ask of the one who did it?

Daily life is threaded with rites: prayers at the two twilights, five great offerings each day for the householder, rules for food and for the ten days of impurity after a death. Some things never pollute by touch, flies, a cow, sunlight, wind. When a wrong is done, penance follows, fasts and vows graded to the sin, and the authorities disagree whether it reaches deliberate sins at all. Remorse frees the sinner, the text says, but only the resolve not to do it again makes him pure.

  • ritual
  • ritual purity
  • purification
  • atonement
  • ritual penance

Deeds and Rebirth

Every act of mind, speech and body bears fruit, and the fruit is the next birth. At stake is how a code that sanctions killing in sacrifice can still prize non-violence and praise abstaining from meat.

Consequences close the whole code. Three qualities, goodness, passion and darkness, colour every act: the good rise to the gods, the passionate return as humans, the dark fall into animal births. Sins of the body bring rebirth as a plant, of speech as a bird or beast, of the mind among the lowest humans. Eating meat is no fault, the code allows, yet abstaining bears great fruit, and killing ordained by the Veda is declared to be no killing at all.

  • karma
  • religious merit
  • nonviolence

Within this work

passages held
348
distinct concepts
455
by passages held, corpus-wide
#215

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “ritual purity” and “social hierarchy”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 20 pairings. 91 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
ritual puritysocial hierarchy11
ritualsocial hierarchy7
charityritual6
educationsocial hierarchy6
educationritual5
charitysocial hierarchy4
karmasocial hierarchy4
marriagesocial hierarchy4
charityritual purity3
karmaritual purity3
kingshipsocial hierarchy3
marriageritual3
charitykarma2
kingshipritual2
charityeducation1
charitykingship1
educationkingship1
educationmarriage1
karmaritual1
kingshipritual purity1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. The Laws of Manu (Manusmṛti) you are here SA
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works