LawgiverIndia

Manu

The legendary first lawgiver of a society ranked by birth

1 work · 348 passages grounded

Lifespan
~200 BCE – ~200 CE
School
Mimamsa
Wikipedia

The mind

In Sanskrit a human being is a mānava or a manuṣya, words that mean "of Manu": early Indian texts make Manu the first man, the ancestor from whom humankind descends. He has a page here because a Sanskrit law code, composed many centuries after those texts, speaks in his name. That code, the Manusmṛti, was long ranked the most authoritative of the Hindu law books.

The story told most often about him is the flood. Its earliest surviving version stands in the Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa, a Vedic prose text on the sacrifice. As Manu washes one morning, a fish comes into his hands and asks him to rear it, promising to save him from a flood that will carry away every creature. He keeps it in a jar, then in a pit, then takes it down to the sea. When the water rises he ties his ship to the fish's horn and is drawn up to a northern mountain, and he alone survives. He pours butter and curds into the waters as an offering; a year later a woman, Iḍā, rises from them and calls herself his daughter, and through her he begets the human race. In the Mahābhārata the fish reveals itself as the god Brahmā, and in the Purāṇas, the later mythological compendia, as Vishnu.

The law code gives Manu a different origin. In its first chapter he tells the sages that the Self-existent creator divided his own body into male and female, that the female half brought forth Virāj, and that Virāj produced him. Manu then created ten great seers, Bhṛgu among them. Six more Manus follow in his line, the last of them the son of Vivasvat, the sun; the Purāṇas make that seventh Manu the hero of the flood and the ruler of the present age. The creator taught the law to the first Manu, and he in turn taught it to the seers. When they come to ask him for it, he hands the telling to Bhṛgu, and from there on the book reports what "Manu declared".

Historians read that frame as the work of the book's real authors: an anonymous Brahmin writer, or several, in the centuries around the beginning of the common era. Patrick Olivelle, who produced the first fully critical edition in 2005, reads the code's tight design as one author's plan and places it around the second century CE. Others date it earlier or see a text that grew over time. The years on this page mark that window of composition, not a lifetime.

The voice of Manu teaches a single order for the whole of life. Dharma, the duty and law binding each person, is rooted in the Veda; the Veda is revelation and the law books are remembered tradition, and neither is to be called into question. If a twice-born man, a member of the three upper classes initiated into Vedic study, scorns these two by leaning on the science of reasoning, he is to be cast out as a denier of the Veda. Near its end the same book allows reasoning that does not contradict the Veda. Within that order each of the four classes has its work — the brahmin priests, the kṣatriya warriors, the vaiśya traders and the śūdra servants — and there is no fifth. A woman is guarded by her father, her husband and her sons and never stands on her own. The king rules through punishment, which the code calls the true king.

William Jones, a British judge in Calcutta, translated the code in 1794 as Institutes of Hindu Law; or the Ordinances of Menu. B. R. Ambedkar, who later chaired the committee that drafted India's constitution, led the movement against untouchability; on 25 December 1927, at Mahad, it burned a copy of the law code in public.

Key concepts

What is the difference between śruti and smṛti?

Śruti, "what was heard", is the Veda, taken as revelation that no human composed. Smṛti, "what is remembered", is the tradition handed down by those who knew the Veda, above all the law books such as this one. The code puts both beyond question, since dharma shone forth from them, but ranks them: for anyone seeking to know dharma, the Veda is the highest authority.

What are the four yugas, the ages of the world?

They are four ages that repeat in a cycle: Kṛta, Tretā, Dvāpara and Kali. In the first, dharma stands whole on four feet, people are free of sickness and live four hundred years. In each later age dharma loses a foot and life grows shorter. Each age has its own highest practice: austerity, then knowledge, then sacrifice, and in the Kali age giving alone.

What is a manvantara, the period of a Manu?

A manvantara is the stretch of cosmic time over which one Manu presides: seventy-one cycles of the four ages, each cycle lasting twelve thousand years of the gods. The code names seven Manus, from the Self-born first to the son of Vivasvat, the sun, each of whom brought forth the moving and unmoving world in his own period. Such periods are countless, as creation and dissolution return again and again.

What does the code mean by the mixing of classes?

Mixing, varṇasaṃkara, is the birth of children from unions across the four classes. The code fears it: adultery is punished hard because the mixing it causes breeds a wrong that cuts at the root of everything. The children form named groups, each with its trade. Unions of a lower man with a higher woman produce the most despised, and the Caṇḍāla, son of a Śūdra father and a Brahmin mother, is called the lowest of men.

What is the difference between engaged and disengaged action?

The code divides Vedic action in two. Engaged action, pravṛtta, is done for a reward in this world or the next, and it raises a person to equality with the gods. Disengaged action, nivṛtta, is done without desire and guided by knowledge, and it carries a person beyond the five elements. What separates them is not the rite but whether the person performing it wants something back.

Why is knowledge of the self called the highest knowledge?

Because it is the foremost of all forms of knowledge, the code says, and through it immortality is reached. To know the self is to see the self in all beings and all beings in the self, and whoever sees that way gains rule over himself. Veda study, austerity and self-restraint lead towards it, and the best of Brahmins may even set prescribed rites aside to pursue it.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Where the Law Comes From

When the Veda is silent, or two of its texts disagree, who decides what is right? The answer settles whether reasoning may judge the law or only serve it.

Dharma rests on revelation, the Veda, and on remembered tradition, the law books, and neither may be called into question: a twice-born man who scorns them on the strength of the science of reasoning is to be cast out as a denier of the Veda. Yet room for judgement is left. Where two Vedic texts conflict, both count as law. Reasoning that does not contradict the Veda is welcome. Where no rule is given, an assembly of ten, or even three, learned Brahmins decides, and what one Brahmin who knows the Veda rules outweighs ten thousand who do not.

  • religious authority
  • scriptural authority
  • Vedic authority
  • authority
  • custom
  • law
  • scripture
  • legitimacy
  • religious knowledge
  • testimony

Creation and the Turning Ages

Why should a law code open with the birth of the world? The order it lays down claims to be as old as creation, and to wear thin as the ages turn.

The first chapter begins in darkness, unknowable and as if asleep. The Self-existent creator brings forth the waters and lays his seed in them; it becomes a golden egg, and Brahmā, born inside it, splits the egg into heaven and earth. Creation and dissolution then follow each other without end, as if the highest god were playing. In the first age dharma stands whole on four feet and people live four hundred years; in each later age it loses a foot to theft, lies and deceit, and the highest practice shifts from austerity to knowledge, to sacrifice, and at last to giving alone.

  • cosmogony
  • cosmology
  • creation
  • cosmic cycles
  • cosmic time
  • time

The Senses Held in Check

If getting what one wants only makes the wanting grow, what is a person to do with desire, and where does happiness actually lie?

Desire is never stilled by enjoying its objects; it grows like a fire fed with butter. So the senses are reined in like horses, and a single one that slips drains away a person's wisdom like water from a leaking skin. The master of his senses hears, touches, sees, eats and smells without elation or dismay. Happiness gets a one-line test: whatever depends on another is pain, whatever depends on oneself is joy. The discipline has a hard edge too. The senses are called strong enough to drag even a learned man astray, so he must not sit alone even with his mother, sister or daughter.

  • self-control
  • self-discipline
  • self-restraint
  • desire
  • happiness
  • suffering
  • moral psychology
  • austerity

Knowledge of the Self

A code of rites and duties ends by ranking one knowledge above all of them. What changes when a person acts without wanting the reward?

Near its close the code divides Vedic action in two. Action done for a reward, here or in heaven, raises a person to equality with the gods; action done without desire and guided by knowledge carries him beyond the five elements. Of every practice taught, knowledge of the self is called the highest, and the best of Brahmins may set even prescribed rites aside to pursue it. Whoever sees the self in all beings and all beings in the self gains rule over himself. The renouncer lives this out, welcoming neither death nor life and waiting for his time as a servant waits for his wages.

  • self-knowledge
  • liberation
  • renunciation
  • detachment
  • meditation
  • nonduality
  • asceticism
  • self

The Edges of Birth

A society sorted by birth must decide what to do with those born across its lines and beneath them. Can anyone move, and how far down does the order reach?

Children of unions across the classes form mixed groups, each assigned its trade, and at the bottom the Caṇḍālas live outside the village, wear the clothes of the dead and eat from broken dishes, with dogs and donkeys for their wealth. A Śūdra may not be given counsel or taught dharma, and even one who could may not amass wealth, lest he trouble Brahmins. Yet the line is not sealed. The child of a Brahmin and a Śūdra woman, if the line keeps marrying upward, reaches Brahmin rank by the seventh generation, and a Brahmin's line can sink the same way.

  • social exclusion
  • heredity
  • lineage
  • social status
  • occupation
  • livelihood
  • social order

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
348
concepts traced
455
thematic clusters
6

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “ritual purity” and “social hierarchy”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 20 pairings. 91 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
ritual puritysocial hierarchy11
ritualsocial hierarchy7
charityritual6
educationsocial hierarchy6
educationritual5
charitysocial hierarchy4
karmasocial hierarchy4
marriagesocial hierarchy4
charityritual purity3
karmaritual purity3
kingshipsocial hierarchy3
marriageritual3
charitykarma2
kingshipritual2
charityeducation1
charitykingship1
educationkingship1
educationmarriage1
karmaritual1
kingshipritual purity1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: social hierarchy in The Laws of Manu, 16.1%.

Density 0% 16.1%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 70 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearsocial hierarchyritualritual puritykingshipkarmamarriageeducationcharity
The Laws of Manu16.1%12.6%10.1%8.9%8%7.2%6%5.5%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. The Laws of Manu (Manusmṛti)

    The only text on Manu's shelf, and an anonymous one: a verse treatise that tradition puts in the mouths of Manu and Bhṛgu, long ranked the most authoritative of the Sanskrit law books.

    SA
Begin a dialogue with Manu

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.