Independence leaderIndia

Mahatma Gandhi

The resister who made accepted punishment a political force

2 works · 381 passages grounded

Lifespan
1869–1948
Also known as
Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi
Wikipedia

The mind

Holding firmly to truth is the literal sense of satyagraha, the word Mohandas Gandhi settled on in South Africa for the method he spent the rest of his life testing. Its rules are simple to state and hard to keep: break an unjust law openly, refuse violence of any kind, and accept the penalty, so that suffering is taken on rather than inflicted. The name came out of a reader competition in his weekly Indian Opinion. A relative proposed sadagraha, firmness in a good cause, and Gandhi changed it to make the meaning plainer. For years he called it passive resistance in English, then dropped the phrase because others, the suffragettes among them, had used it for campaigns that allowed violence.

Nothing in his early life pointed this way. He trained as a barrister at the Inner Temple in London and was called to the bar in June 1891, at twenty-one, then failed to make a practice in Bombay because he could not bring himself to cross-examine a witness. In 1893 he took a legal job in South Africa. At Pietermaritzburg station he was put out of a first-class compartment, for which he held a ticket, because he was not white, and he spent the night in the waiting room. He later wrote that running back to India would have been cowardice, and that he resolved to try to root out the disease of colour prejudice and to suffer hardships in the process. In 1904 a friend, Henry Polak, gave him John Ruskin's Unto This Last for a train journey from Johannesburg to Durban; Gandhi did not sleep that night and decided to change his life according to the book. That year he moved his paper to the Phoenix Settlement, a farm fourteen miles from Durban. He later rendered the book into Gujarati as Sarvodaya, "the welfare of all".

The method first appeared as a vow. In 1906 the Transvaal drafted an ordinance requiring every Indian over the age of eight to register and give fingerprints, and on 11 September some three thousand Indians met at the Empire Theatre in Johannesburg and resolved to go to prison rather than submit. Gandhi dated satyagraha from that meeting. Three years later his book Hind Swaraj gave it a theory: India's real master was modern civilisation, not the English, and self-rule began as rule over oneself. Means and ends, he argued, cannot be separated; a watch taken by force, bought, or received as a gift becomes in each case a different thing.

He came home in 1915, at forty-five, and two years later won concessions for indigo farmers in Champaran, in Bihar. Non-co-operation followed in 1920, and in 1930 he walked with volunteers for more than three weeks, from Ahmedabad to Dandi on the Gujarat coast, to make salt in defiance of the salt laws. Martin Luther King Jr. said he was particularly moved by the Salt March and the fasts, and he used Gandhi's methods in the Montgomery bus boycott of 1955–56.

The sharpest objections came from Indians. In 1921 Rabindranath Tagore, the Bengali poet, argued that bonfires of foreign cloth burned what the poor needed to wear, and later that the spinning wheel had become a cult that asked no one to think. In 1934 Gandhi called the Bihar earthquake a divine chastisement for untouchability, and Tagore protested that the view was unscientific. B. R. Ambedkar, the leader of the untouchable castes, held that the Hindu scriptures themselves sustained caste. In 1932 Gandhi fasted in prison against separate electorates for untouchables, and Ambedkar, who had demanded them, signed the Poona Pact that took their place. When Ambedkar's Annihilation of Caste appeared in 1936, Gandhi answered it in his weekly Harijan with "A Vindication of Caste".

Gandhi had begun by saying that God is Truth and later reversed it: Truth is God. He spent Independence Day 1947 in Calcutta, fasting and spinning, while the country was partitioned. On 30 January 1948 Nathuram Godse, a Hindu nationalist from Pune, shot him at a prayer meeting in Delhi.

Key concepts

What does ahimsa mean for Gandhi?

Ahimsa, usually translated non-violence, is for Gandhi an active love that does good even to the wrongdoer, not merely a refusal to harm. He grounds it in a simple claim: people cannot create life, so they have no right to destroy even the smallest creature. Love of this kind never tolerates the wrong. It resists by withdrawing every form of help from the one who does it, while wishing him well.

What does truth mean in Gandhi's 'truth-force'?

Truth, for Gandhi, is what a person's deliberate judgment shows them to be right, held to whatever it costs. He does not claim certainty for it: nobody can be sure they are right, he writes, only that a thing is wrong for them while they judge so. That is why truth-force works by the resister's own suffering. If the judgment proves mistaken, only the person who acted on it pays.

Why does supporting an unjust government make someone responsible for its wrongs?

Because, on Gandhi's account, every wrong a government does runs on the help of ordinary people. A system based finally on the sword survives only while people serve it, so whoever sustains it shares its violence: 'We are violent when we sustain a government whose creed is violence.' Withdrawing support therefore ends a person's part in the wrong, and, if enough people withdraw, it removes what the wrong stands on.

Is non-violence a creed or a policy?

For Gandhi it was a creed, part of his religion, but he accepted allies for whom it was a policy. A creed binds whatever happens. A policy is adopted because it works and may be dropped if it stops working. Most of the Muslims and many of the Hindus in his campaign held it as policy, and he argued that even they had reason to keep it, since violence only strengthened the bonds it meant to break.

How does Gandhi decide what a scripture really teaches?

By its spirit, not its letter, and never against reason and truth. Scriptures, he wrote, are meant to purify reason and illuminate truth, so they cannot override either, and the devil has always been able to quote them. The spirit of the Vedas, as he reads it, is purity, truth, humility, simplicity and forgiveness. Any custom that contradicts that spirit, such as untouchability, belongs to custom and not to the religion.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Courage Without a Weapon

Is refusing to strike back the choice of people too weak to fight? Gandhi answers that it takes more courage than any battle, and his whole method stands or falls on that claim.

Ahimsa, non-violence, was for him never mere harmlessness. Non-co-operation, he wrote, is an intensely active state, more active than violence, and he called the English phrase 'passive resistance' a misnomer. He set this against the young revolutionaries of 1909, who hoped to free India by assassination, and against the reader who took passive resistance for a weapon of the weak. What follows is severe. The resister breaks the unjust law openly and accepts the penalty, and violence on his own side, not the government's repression, is what halts the campaign.

  • nonviolence
  • civil resistance
  • civil disobedience
  • political violence
  • political resistance
  • collective action

Against the Rule, Never the Ruler

Can someone fight a government with everything they have and still wish its officers well? For Gandhi the answer decides whether a struggle ends in freedom or in a new hatred.

To regard anyone as an enemy was, he said, against his religion. He called himself a determined enemy of English rule and counted many Englishmen as friends, and he would refuse to help General Dyer fire on a crowd but nurse him back to health. Love does not mean tolerating the wrong. A father may withdraw all support from a son living in shame. The opponent is someone to be won over, never beaten, and only a people strong enough to punish is free to forgive.

  • justice
  • political justice
  • moral responsibility
  • colonialism

A Religion That Will Not Stay Private

Does faith belong in prayer and politics somewhere else? Gandhi refused the split, and then had to explain how a country of many faiths could share one struggle.

Jesus was, in his phrase, a prince among politicians, and people of faith must take a religious interest in what their governors do. He read the Gita's battlefield as the duel that goes on in every heart, against a learned critic who found in it a licence for violence in a good cause. Religion, as he used the word, meant the one that underlies all the particular faiths. Religions are different roads to one point, and Hindus and Muslims are bound together best when each stays true to their own faith.

  • religion
  • religious pluralism
  • religious freedom
  • nationalism

The Resister's Discipline

What does it ask of a person to break a law in good conscience? Gandhi's answer is a whole way of life, because a method that runs on suffering is only as good as the people who carry it.

The passive resister, he wrote in 1909, must keep chastity, accept poverty, follow truth at any cost and fear nothing, whether loss of property, honour, family or life. The demands rest on humility about being right. Nobody can be sure of it, so whoever breaks a law must bear the penalty alone. Facing trial in 1922, he took the blame for riots he had never ordered and asked the judge either to resign or to impose the severest sentence the law allowed.

  • self-sacrifice
  • conscience
  • political accountability
  • political responsibility
  • political obligation

By the numbers

works held
2
passages traced
381
concepts traced
531
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “non-cooperation” and “nonviolence”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 25 pairings. 82 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
non-cooperationnonviolence27
civil disobediencenonviolence18
non-cooperationself-government13
colonialismeducation9
colonialismjustice8
justicenonviolence8
justicenon-cooperation7
civil disobediencenon-cooperation6
colonialismnon-cooperation6
colonialismnonviolence6
educationnon-cooperation6
nonviolenceself-government6
nonviolenceself-rule6
civil disobediencejustice5
colonialismself-government5
civil disobedienceeducation3
colonialismself-rule3
educationnonviolence3
justiceself-government2
justiceself-rule2
civil disobediencecolonialism1
civil disobedienceself-rule1
educationjustice1
educationself-government1
non-cooperationself-rule1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: non-cooperation in Freedom's Battle, 29.2%.

Density 0% 29.2%

Concept density per work, chronological 2 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 63 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearnonviolencecolonialismnon-cooperationjusticeself-rulecivil disobedienceself-governmenteducation
Hind Swaraj or Indian Home Rule19.6%22.7%1%2.1%12.4%6.2%7.2%9.3%
Freedom's Battle28.5%16.2%29.2%14.8%3.9%9.9%8.1%4.9%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 1909 Hind Swaraj or Indian Home Rule (Hind Swaraj)

    Written in Gujarati in 1909 and put into English by Gandhi himself, the book states the politics he qualified in 1921 and still defended at the end of his life.

    EN
  2. 1922 Freedom's Battle

    An anthology assembled by its Madras publishers, with C. Rajagopalachari's help, rather than by Gandhi himself, gathering his Young India writings and speeches from the launch of non-co-operation; the 1922 edition closes on his statement at trial.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Mahatma Gandhi

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.