Get started

WorkMaria Montessori

Pedagogical Anthropology

Montessori's lectures on measuring schoolchildren's bodies, the early book her harshest critics now read as the key to all the rest.

by Maria Montessori711 passages held

  • English, a translation held here, and your language
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work See it in context
Original title
Antropologia pedagogica
First published
(aged 40)
Original language
Italian

Report a rights issue

Overview

Printed in Milan in 1910, this book did not appear in German until 2019, and five years later it stood at the centre of a public quarrel. Sabine Seichter, a professor of education at Salzburg, argued in a 2024 book that Maria Montessori's whole pedagogy grew from the race anthropology, eugenics and evolutionary theory laid out here; Heiner Barz, an education researcher at Düsseldorf, answered that the charges were mostly baseless and one-sided. The book began as lectures in anthropology that Montessori gave in the Pedagogic School of the University of Rome between 1904 and 1908, and runs to some six hundred pages. Its case is that a teacher must know the child's body before educating it. Stature, weight, skull, chest, pelvis, limbs and skin are measured and compared, so that a school can see which children are growing well and which are held back by poor food, illness or their surroundings, and every pupil is to have a biographical chart kept jointly by school and family. Her guides were Italian. Giuseppe Sergi, her former teacher, had urged since 1886 that pupils be studied by the methods of anthropology; Cesare Lombroso, the founder of criminal anthropology, had read crime and insanity in the shape of the body. The lectures take over much of that apparatus, including its sorting of people into superior and inferior types and its constant talk of race. They close on what Montessori called biological liberty: a hope that prevention and education would replace repressive justice and leave every person free to develop. Frederic Taber Cooper's English translation followed in 1913. Scholars still disagree about how much of her later method this book explains.

Key concepts

What is 'pedagogical anthropology' supposed to be?

It is the scientific study of the schoolchild's body, carried out so that education can be fitted to the real pupil. Montessori defines it by its method rather than its content: measure living children, compare the figures with normal values, and draw conclusions only from what the measurements show. A teacher trained in it would notice, for example, that a pupil is underweight for his age before calling him slow.

What goes into a school's 'biographical chart'?

It is a record kept for each pupil across the school years: measurements such as height, weight, head and chest, together with observations on health and development. Montessori wanted the school and the family to keep it jointly, so that the parents' efforts would complete the school's. She also thought the chart could show families facts about their child's health of which they had been unaware.

Who is the 'medial man' in these lectures?

He is an imaginary person built from the average of all the measurements taken in a population. Montessori takes the idea from Quetelet, who found that body measurements spread around their average like the outcomes of chance. She treats this average figure as the norm of perfect development, so that every real person can be described by how far, and in which direction, he deviates from it.

What are 'stigmata' in Montessori's anthropology?

They are bodily malformations, such as an oddly shaped skull, jaw or ear, which the anthropology of her day read as signs of degeneration. Lombroso, the founder of criminal anthropology, claimed that several of them together gave criminals a recognisable look. Montessori takes the idea over and shows how to look for such marks in schoolchildren, alongside their ordinary measurements.

What does the 'cephalic index' measure?

It expresses the shape of the skull as one number: its greatest width divided by its greatest length, times a hundred. A low figure marks a long head, a high figure a short, round one, and anthropologists used it to sort human races. Montessori explains the formula but warns that it cannot sum up a skull's form, since a skull far too small can still have a normal index.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Measuring the child before teaching it

Can a teacher educate a child whose body she has never looked at? These lectures answer that the schoolroom has to begin with the tape measure and the scales.

Schools, Montessori complains, teach an abstraction called 'the Child' and press every pupil toward it. Against that she sets the methods of anthropology, as her teacher Sergi had urged: measure stature, weight, skull, chest and limbs, compare them with normal values, and see who is held back by poor food, illness or surroundings. Rich and poor children of the same age fall on different curves of height. Every pupil is to have a biographical chart, kept by school and family together, so that the teacher can help repair what is wrong.

  • anthropometry
  • measurement
  • stature
  • weight
  • cranium
  • growth
  • school hygiene
  • biographical chart
  • environment

Enter a dialogue

The normal type and its deviations

What counts as a normal human being, and who decides? Montessori builds a standard out of averages and then sorts real people by how far they stray from it.

Following Quetelet and Viola, she reconstructs the 'medial man' from average measurements and treats him as the man of perfect development, from whom everyone actually living deviates. From Lombroso she takes the reading of crime and degeneration in bodily malformations, and the lectures classify criminals by build and speak constantly of superior and inferior types and races. Yet she rejects the claim that the powerful have bigger brains, asking whether a prime minister is really more intelligent than a door-keeper.

  • type
  • normal
  • medial man
  • degeneration
  • criminal anthropology
  • stigmata
  • race
  • intelligence
  • abnormality

Enter a dialogue

Biological liberty

What would a society look like if it no longer had to defend itself against its own members? The last pages of the lectures stake the purpose of all the measuring on that hope.

Montessori ends where a reader of skull tables might least expect, with freedom. She pictures humanity growing into a single social organism, its members as dependent on one another as cells in a body, yet each given the widest room for personal activity. Repressive justice would give way to prevention, wider education and better conditions of labour. This free and peaceful development of life, won through long struggles to defend it, is what she calls biological liberty, and she names it the very essence of the new pedagogy.

  • liberty
  • society
  • social organism
  • prevention
  • justice
  • education
  • peace
  • evolution
  • solidarity

Enter a dialogue

Within this work

passages held
711
distinct concepts
737
by passages held, corpus-wide
#96

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “child development” and “education”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 26 pairings. 85 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
child developmenteducation35
anthropometrymeasurement34
anthropometrychild development18
anthropometryhuman development18
classificationmeasurement16
anthropometryclassification13
anatomyanthropometry12
anatomyhuman development10
anthropometryeducation10
educationmeasurement9
anatomyclassification8
child developmentmeasurement8
educationhuman development8
human developmentmeasurement6
anatomymeasurement5
child developmentheredity4
educationheredity4
classificationeducation3
classificationheredity3
anatomyeducation2
anthropometryheredity2
heredityhuman development2
anatomyheredity1
child developmentclassification1
child developmenthuman development1
hereditymeasurement1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 1909 The Montessori Method (Il metodo della pedagogia scientifica applicato all’educazione infantile nelle Case dei Bambini)

    Her founding book, revised for the Italian editions of 1913, 1926 and 1935 and enlarged in 1948 into The Discovery of the Child.

     EN
  2. 1910 Pedagogical Anthropology (Antropologia pedagogica) you are here EN
  3. 1916 Spontaneous Activity in Education (L’autoeducazione nelle scuole elementari)

    Sequel to The Montessori Method, subtitled as its continuation in Italian and issued in English as the first half of The Advanced Montessori Method.

     EN
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works