Freedom in place of the fixed bench
Can a child held still at a desk be educated at all, or only kept quiet? Montessori stakes the whole method on the answer that order must come from free activity.
The school of her day, Montessori argues, still runs on the principle of slavery: fixed benches measured to hold the body motionless, prizes and punishments to hold the attention. A child silenced that way is annihilated, not disciplined. Discipline worth the name is active, the self-mastery of a child who moves, chooses and works. So the Children's Houses carry light furniture a child can upset, abolish prizes, and teach children to dress and wash themselves, because no one can be free who is not first independent.
- liberty
- discipline
- independence
- freedom
- rewards
- punishment
- school furniture
- movement
- self-control
Enter a dialogue
- You compare schoolchildren fastened to their desks to butterflies pinned in a case. What can a teacher still learn by studying a child held still?
- A parent dresses a four-year-old every morning because it is quicker. Why do you count that as the easier, lesser work rather than a kindness?
- A busy boy lets his prize, a silver cross, slip to the floor and looks at it with indifference. What did that tell you about rewards?
- Chairs light enough for children to knock over make a noisy school. Why should a child's clumsiness clatter to the floor rather than be prevented?
- In your lesson of silence, children hold perfectly still while they wait to be called. How does that fit a school built on freedom of movement?