PoetAnatolia

Rumi

The jurist who found that love, not learning, leads home

4 works · 9,713 passages grounded

Lifespan
1207–1273
School
Sufism
Also known as
Jalal al-Din Rumi · Mevlana · Mawlana
Wikipedia

The mind

In 1231 a college of religious learning in Konya, in central Anatolia, passed from a father, who had just died, to his son. The father, Baha al-Din Walad, was a preacher and jurist. Around 1216 he had brought his family west out of Central Asia, shortly before the Mongols invaded; by 1229 he had settled in Konya at the invitation of the Seljuk sultan, Ala al-Din Kayqubad. He left behind the Ma'arif, a book of his own mystical teaching. The son was Rumi, and he was raised for a learned career. Burhan al-Din Tirmidhi, a former disciple of his father's, arrived in 1232 and taught him for about nine years. Rumi studied further in Aleppo and Damascus, and by the early 1240s he was a jurist of the Hanafi school, issuing legal opinions and preaching in the town.

In November 1244 a wandering dervish, Shams of Tabriz, came to Konya, and Rumi, then thirty-seven, attached himself to the stranger so completely that his own disciples resented it. With Shams came sama, worship through music and dance, which many jurists disapproved of; Sultan Walad, Rumi's elder son, later wrote that his father never stopped listening to music and dancing. Shams left for Syria in 1246. While he was away, Rumi wrote lyric poems to call him back, though he later said that where he came from nothing was more shameful than being a poet. Sultan Walad went to Damascus and brought Shams home the next year. Late in 1247 or in 1248 Shams disappeared for good. Some accounts say he was murdered, with suspicion falling on Rumi's younger son, Ala al-Din; whether he was killed or simply left is not known. Rumi went to Damascus to look for him and did not find him.

The claim his poetry makes is what the jurist learned in those years: love, and not learning, is how a human soul finds its way back to God. Every soul, in Rumi's account, has been cut off from the source it came from and lives in longing to return, and that longing is the surest guide it has. Knowledge that leaves its holder unchanged is no guide at all; the arguer who trusts only proof walks, in one of his images, on wooden legs. Love for one human being can open the way, because it takes apart the learned, respected self that stands in the way. Rumi signed about a third of his ghazals, short rhymed love lyrics, with Shams's name instead of his own. None of this took him outside Islam: he remained a Muslim teacher who argued from the Qur'an and the sayings of the Prophet, and later readers called his longest poem the Qur'an in Persian.

That poem, the Masnavi, is his best known. Around 1260 Husam al-Din Chalabi, the disciple who became his scribe, asked him for a teaching poem, and Rumi spent his remaining years composing it aloud while Husam wrote it down: six books of stories and teaching in some 25,000 couplets, the last left unfinished.

Rumi died in Konya on 17 December 1273. By the account of Aflaki, a later biographer of the Mevlevi order, Christians and Jews joined the crowd that mourned him. Husam led his followers first; Sultan Walad then organised them into that order, built around sama and its whirling dance. In 1898 the Cambridge scholar Reynold Nicholson published a selection of the lyrics in English. From 1976 Coleman Barks, an American poet who read no Persian, reworked such scholarly translations into books that made Rumi a best-selling poet in the United States; critics have faulted those versions for removing the Islam from the poems. In Konya his tomb is now a museum, and on each 17 December Mevlevi dervishes mark the day of his death by turning.

Key concepts

Why does Rumi say love, not learning, leads the soul to God?

Because learning can inform the self while leaving it intact, and the self is what stands between the soul and God. Rumi, a trained jurist, grants proof a real but limited reach: it brings a person to the edge of the truth. Love goes further because it acts on the lover, taking apart the respected, knowing self. Knowledge worth the name, for him, is knowledge that changes its holder.

What does separation mean in Rumi's thought?

Separation is the soul's condition in this life: cut off from God, the source it came from, and unable to rest in anything less. Rumi does not treat it as a mere misfortune. It is what makes love possible, since only what is apart can long, and the longing it produces is the soul's surest guide home. Union, in his vocabulary, ends the separation, not the love.

What is sama, and why does it matter to Rumi?

Sama is worship through listening to music and, often, through dance. It came into Rumi's life with Shams of Tabriz, and he kept to it although many jurists disapproved. For him music reaches the soul beneath argument and stirs the longing for its origin that words can only describe; the Masnavi opens on a reed flute's lament. After his death the Mevlevi order made sama, with its turning dance, its centre.

Why does a seeker need a spiritual guide in Rumi's view?

Because the self cannot see through its own disguises, and a guide is someone who has already made the journey the seeker is beginning. Rumi's lower self hides as piety, learning and zeal, and it is cleverest when it judges its own progress. The guide supplies the outside eye and the discipline a seeker cannot give himself. That is why love for a teacher can be the start of the way rather than a detour from it.

Does Rumi's path of love leave Islamic law behind?

No. Rumi remained a Muslim teacher who argued from the Qur'an and the sayings of the Prophet, and later readers called the Masnavi the Qur'an in Persian. His distinction is between the outward form of the law and its inward meaning: the rites are real and binding, and they point past themselves. What he attacks is observance or learning that stops at the form and leaves the person unchanged.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Love That Knows What Learning Cannot

Can a person reach the truth that matters most by study and proof, or only by being changed? A jurist trained in the law of his day came to answer that love, not learning, is how the soul finds its way back to God.

Rumi never despised learning. He had issued legal opinions as a Hanafi jurist, and he went on arguing from the Qur'an and the sayings of the Prophet. His quarrel was with knowledge that leaves its holder unchanged: proof can bring a person to the edge of the truth and no further, and the arguer who trusts only proof walks on wooden legs. Love goes further because it is not a view the self holds but something done to the self, and what it takes apart is the learned, respected person standing in the way.

  • love
  • divine love
  • mystical love
  • reason
  • knowledge
  • spiritual knowledge
  • devotion
  • ecstasy
  • mysticism

Cut From the Source, Aching to Return

Is the ache of being far from home a flaw in the human condition, or the one reliable sign of where home lies? Rumi builds his whole account of the soul on the second answer.

Every soul, on Rumi's account, came from God and has been cut off from that origin, as the reed at the Masnavi's opening was cut from its reed bed. It does not follow that separation is only a misfortune to be ended as quickly as possible. The longing it produces is the surest guide a soul has, because nothing less than what was lost can quiet it. So restlessness, homesickness and grief are read as directions rather than symptoms, and a person who has stopped aching has, for Rumi, stopped moving.

  • longing
  • spiritual longing
  • separation
  • desire
  • suffering
  • grief
  • unity
  • creation
  • mystical union

The Self That Stands in the Way

What if the chief obstacle between a person and God is the person, the self that wants, fears and wants to be admired? Rumi asks what remains once that self is taken apart, and whether anything worth keeping is lost.

The grasping, self-regarding part of a person is, for Rumi, the lower self, and his stories keep catching it in disguise: as piety, as learning, as righteous anger. It cannot be argued away, since arguing is one of its disguises. It is undone by love, by humility and by the discipline of a guide, until the person passes away from themselves, self-annihilation in the Sufi term. Rumi does not count that passing as the loss of the person. In the Seven Sermons, Hamza fighting without armour is a man walking toward life.

  • ego
  • self-annihilation
  • selfhood
  • surrender
  • humility
  • self-transcendence
  • spiritual transformation
  • transformation
  • spiritual guidance
  • death

Form, Meaning and the Limits of Words

How can a person see what is really there, when the senses report only surfaces and the self is glad to be deceived? Rumi's answer turns on the difference between the form of a thing and its meaning, and it ends in silence.

Everything in the world, for Rumi, has an outward form and an inward meaning, and the form is where most people stop. Words are forms, rites are forms, a beautiful face is a form; each is real and each points past itself. The error is to take the pointer for what it points at, which is the literal-minded scholar's mistake and the infatuated lover's alike. The remedy is not contempt for forms but a trained perception that reads through them. Where even words fail, the poems tell themselves to fall silent.

  • appearance and reality
  • perception
  • spiritual perception
  • deception
  • discernment
  • beauty
  • embodiment
  • language
  • silence
  • ineffability

Grace, Pain and the Seeker's Work

If mercy goes out before anyone asks, what is left for a seeker to do, and why does so much of the way run through pain? Rumi keeps both the gift and the labour, and asks suffering what it is for.

Rumi's God is generous before being asked, and mercy runs toward need rather than toward merit. That does not release the seeker from work. Prayer, repentance, patience and gratitude are how a person becomes able to receive what is already being given. Suffering belongs to the same account: loss and lack hollow a person out, and for Rumi the hollow is where mercy enters, since someone who feels no need asks for nothing. Rumi does not call pain good. He asks what it opens.

  • divine grace
  • grace
  • divine mercy
  • divine providence
  • suffering
  • patience
  • gratitude
  • repentance
  • prayer
  • faith
  • renewal
  • spiritual renewal

By the numbers

works held
4
passages traced
9,713
concepts traced
2,425
thematic clusters
4

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “divine love” and “mysticism”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 28 pairings. 87 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
divine lovemysticism306
devotiondivine love275
divine lovesuffering224
devotionlove145
lovesuffering137
lovemysticism94
devotionsuffering93
desiredivine love60
desirelove59
devotionmysticism43
knowledgemysticism38
devotiondivine grace36
divine gracelove34
mysticismsuffering33
knowledgelove32
divine gracedivine love27
divine gracemysticism25
divine loveknowledge25
desiresuffering21
divine gracesuffering21
desiredevotion19
desiremysticism15
desireknowledge12
desiredivine grace10
divine graceknowledge8
knowledgesuffering5
divine lovelove3
devotionknowledge2

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: divine love in Divani Shamsi Tabriz, 36.2%.

Density 0% 36.2%

Concept density per work, chronological 4 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 84 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYeardivine lovedesirelovemysticismknowledgedevotionsufferingdivine grace
Selection from Seven Sermons of Rumi6.7%7.8%3.2%6%4.3%4.3%3.5%3.9%
The Masnavi3.7%8.3%4%4.1%4.6%2.4%4.2%3.9%
Divani Shamsi Tabriz36.2%3.5%13.2%12.3%2.1%11.3%8.7%4.9%
Discourses of Rumi5%8%6.9%3.4%10%2.3%3.4%6.1%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

KONYA, ALEPPO & DAMASCUS — THE JURIST

  1. 1244 Selection from Seven Sermons of Rumi (مجالس سبعه)

    Seven addresses from the pulpit: Rumi's public preaching, each built from praise of God and a text of scripture, in contrast to the informal talks of Fihi Ma Fihi.

    FA

AFTER SHAMS — LYRICS & TEACHING

  1. 1260 The Masnavi (مثنوی معنوی)

    Rumi's best-known book and the work of his last dozen years: a long teaching poem in rhyming couplets, beside the lyrics he wrote in the name of Shams of Tabriz.

    FA

THE MASNAVI — DICTATED TO HUSAM AL-DIN

  1. 1273 Discourses of Rumi (فیه ما فیه)

    Where the Masnavi teaches in verse, these talks teach in conversation: the poem's ideas as Rumi put them in prose in Konya, to a mixed audience of disciples and officials.

    FA
  2. 1273 Divani Shamsi Tabriz (دیوان شمس)

    The lyric half of Rumi's work, set against the teaching verse of the Masnavi: the poems that came out of his friendship with Shams of Tabriz.

    FA
Begin a dialogue with Rumi

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.