PoetIndia

Tiruvaḷḷuvar

The poet of a goodness that needs no robe

1 work · 120 passages grounded

Lifespan
~450–~500
School
Jainism
Also known as
Thiruvalluvar · Valluvar
Wikipedia

The mind

One couplet of the Tirukkuṟaḷ sets aside the two outward marks of the holy life, the ascetic's matted hair and the monk's shaven head: a person who shuns what the world condemns, it says, needs neither. The book's 1,330 couplets make the same case at length. Goodness, for the poet whom tradition calls Tiruvaḷḷuvar, does not require leaving home. A householder who lives rightly and helps others keep their vows is, in another couplet, holier than those who practise austerities. And the first rule of that goodness is not to kill, ranked above truthfulness itself.

The book is built on three aims, taken in order: aṟam, virtue; poruḷ, wealth and the running of a state; and iṉpam, love. Virtue comes first and governs the rest. The second part advises a king on choosing ministers and setting spies, and it calls farming the chief of all work, since in the end everyone depends on the plough for food. The third part gives its voice to lovers. This is an ethics for people with families, fields and offices.

The book draws on two literatures. According to Kamil Zvelebil, the Czech scholar of Tamil literature, the poet knew the classical Tamil poems well, and some of his verses on statecraft translate into Tamil lines from Sanskrit treatises such as the Arthaśāstra, the old Indian manual of government.

Of the man himself nothing is on record. The book names no author, and neither his real name nor the work's original title can be fixed. The name Tiruvaḷḷuvar, "the holy Vaḷḷuvar", first appears in the Tiruvaḷḷuva Mālai, an undated Śaiva collection of verses in praise of the book, and written accounts of his life were printed only from the early nineteenth century. In those accounts he was a weaver at Mylapore, now part of Chennai, married to a woman named Vāsuki. A poem that Zvelebil dates to the fifteenth century makes him the son of a Brahmin father and a low-caste mother. Tradition also has the book win the approval of the third Sangam, the legendary assembly of poets at Madurai. A shrine at Mylapore has honoured him since the early sixteenth century, and Śaiva communities there and elsewhere worship him as the sixty-fourth of the Nāyaṉmār, their poet-saints.

Historians place the book, and so its author, around 500 CE. Zvelebil set it between 450 and 500, on two grounds: its grammar is newer than that of the older Sangam poems, and it has a larger stock of Sanskrit loanwords. The tradition places him much earlier, and some Tamil scholars date him to the last centuries BCE; the government of Tamil Nadu counts a Tiruvaḷḷuvar year from 31 BCE.

Which religion he held is the oldest quarrel about him. Zvelebil judged him most probably a learned Jain who drew on many sources: the chapters against eating meat and against killing match the Jain moral code. Yet no early Jain text mentions him, and the first Jain work to cite him as an authority dates from the sixteenth century. Parimēlaḻakar, a thirteenth-century Vaishnava Brahmin whose commentary became the standard one, read the three parts as the three classical Sanskrit aims of life: duty, prosperity and pleasure. Couplets name Vishnu and Lakshmi; Śaivas have set his image in their temples; and Iyothee Thass, a Tamil Dalit activist who had become a Buddhist, claimed him for Buddhism. The couplets never say which religion their author held, and scholars have not settled it.

The book kept its readers through all of this. In 1708 Bartholomäus Ziegenbalg, a German missionary in South India, reported that the Tamils he lived among learned it by heart and quoted it to prove their arguments. Tolstoy drew on it in 1908 in "A Letter to a Hindu", and that letter brought it to Gandhi. On 1 January 2000 a 133-foot statue of Tiruvaḷḷuvar was unveiled at Kanyakumari, the southern tip of India, one foot for each chapter of the book.

Key concepts

What is the 'treasure of the ear' in the Kural?

It is what a person gains by listening to good instruction, and the Kural ranks it above every other kind of wealth. Learning, on this view, does not need books: someone who cannot read can still grow wise by hearing the wise. The image is a meal served in order: only when there is nothing more for the ear should the stomach be offered food. An ear never trained by good words, another couplet says, is deaf though it hears.

How does the Kural measure a kindness someone has received?

By the receiver's sense of it, never by its size. A benefit as small as a millet seed looks, to a just person, as large as a palmyra palm, and a kindness done with no thought of return is called mightier than the ocean. Gratitude, one couplet says, is bounded not by the help given but only by the nobility of the one who receives it.

Does the Kural believe evil deeds come back to the doer?

Yes, and no judge is needed. Evil deeds follow whoever did them the way a shadow follows a man wherever he goes, until they bring him down. One couplet puts the timing bluntly: injure a neighbour in the morning, and evil comes to you of its own accord by the afternoon. Evil is to be feared even more than fire, the couplets add, because evil gives birth to more evil.

Why does the Kural call freedom from desire the greatest wealth?

Because nothing the world offers matches it, and it ends grief at the root. Whoever has no desires has no grief, while ills pile on ills for the one who hankers after things. Those who have conquered desire are the truly free; the rest only look free and live in bondage. The single longing the Kural permits is the longing to be free from rebirth.

What makes a punishment just in the Kural?

Measure. A ruler should weigh the offender's guilt and punish just enough that the offence is not repeated, never more. The Kural's image is a rod raised smartly but laid on softly: the threat must be visible and the blow light. Punishment, on this account, exists to correct, and a punishment that goes past what correction needs has stopped being justice.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Worth Earned by How One Lives

What makes one person worth more than another, if everyone is born the same way? Conduct alone, and the couplets keep a stricter account of it than any rank does.

All people come into the world alike, one couplet says, and their names differ only because their lives do. Lineage proves nothing, so the test moves to what a person does each day. Ingratitude is the one crime with no redemption. A fortune in good hands is a fruit tree standing in the village square, while a miser who never gives is as good as dead. Shame counts too: without it a person only mimics life, like a puppet worked by strings.

  • virtue
  • integrity
  • social status
  • generosity

Anger and the Strength to Bear

When someone is wronged, what does strength look like, striking back or holding still? The couplets call holding still the harder strength, and the safer one.

Forbearance counts only in someone who could strike: in the powerless it is mere necessity. Anger is treated less as a sin against others than as harm to oneself. It kills the smile and the joy of the one who feels it, burns his family along with him, and should be kept off even when wrongs burn like many fires. The earth is the model, carrying even those who dig into her. To forgive an injury is good, and to forget it is better.

  • nonviolence
  • compassion
  • anger
  • self-control
  • conflict

Power That Keeps Its Friends

How does anyone hold power for long, and on whose work does it rest? Restraint keeps a ruler, the couplets answer, and the ploughman keeps everyone.

Seventy chapters advise a ruler and those who serve him, and their counsel is practical before it is pious. Spies are the king's eyes, yet one spy's report must be checked against another's. People are to be tested before they are trusted, then given the work they fit. A ruler who governs with a rod of iron ends without a friend, and his demand for money can sound like a highway robber's. Beneath it all lies labour: if the farmer folds his hands, even those who have renounced desire go hungry.

  • leadership
  • justice
  • wealth
  • labor
  • prudence
  • judgment
  • courage

Hearing Before Speaking

Where does wisdom come from for someone with no schooling? Through the ear first, and then through the discipline of saying only what is worth saying.

Learning in the Kural is not reserved for the lettered. Listening to instruction is called the most precious of treasures, and an ear never trained by good words is deaf though it hears. Wisdom is the power to separate true from false in anything said, whoever says it, so a speaker's standing settles nothing. Speech has its own duties: profitless words are not to be spoken, and whoever slanders another invites that person to expose the slanderer's own worst faults.

  • communication
  • education
  • knowledge
  • practical wisdom
  • trust
  • deception

Desire Conquered, Love Sung

How can the same couplets call desire a snare and still let lovers have the last word? The tension runs through the whole book, and it is never resolved by dropping either side.

The chapters on desire speak as sternly as any ascetic: desire is never filled, whoever has none has no grief, and only those who conquer it are free. Yet the closing part hands its voice to lovers, and there longing is not condemned. A lover's pain can be healed only by the one who caused it, rapture at a mere thought belongs to love and not to wine, and an embrace is compared to the householder's meal, eaten only after giving to others.

  • love
  • romantic love
  • desire
  • separation
  • longing
  • grief

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
120
concepts traced
251
thematic clusters
4

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “desire” and “love”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 11 pairings. 97 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
desirelove6
compassionnonviolence5
desireromantic love4
compassiongenerosity1
compassionlove1
compassionvirtue1
generositylove1
generositynonviolence1
loveromantic love1
lovevirtue1
prudencevirtue1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: love in The Kural, 13.3%.

Density 0% 13.3%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 19 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearloveromantic lovevirtuedesirecompassiongenerosityprudencenonviolence
The Kural13.3%10.8%10.8%10%9.2%8.3%8.3%7.5%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. The Kural (Tirukkuṟaḷ)

    The one work behind the name Tiruvaḷḷuvar; the medical and other poems later ascribed to him are dated by scholars to the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Tiruvaḷḷuvar

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.