A religion that harms, not merely errs
Grant that Christianity is false; is it also bad for those who hold it? Holbach's charge is that it is, training people to fear death and despise this life for a next one no one can show exists.
This was the first of Holbach's books to make the case plainly, and its target is not the truth of Christianity but its effect. The religion, he argues, is not merely mistaken but harmful: it teaches people to fear death, to hold this world cheap for a next one nobody can demonstrate, and so leaves them fearful, obedient and turned against their own happiness. Where the System of Nature would later build the whole materialist philosophy, this book simply indicts, laying out how a faith deforms the character of those raised in it. It went out under a dead engineer's name to keep its author out of prison.
- morality
- ethics
- superstition
- fanaticism
- social control
- religion
- theodicy
- credulity
- religious authority
Enter a dialogue
- Whether a religion is true matters less to you than what it does to people in this life. Why is that the fair test?
- Christians believe God became a man and died to appease his own wrath. What does a faith built on that teach people about justice?
- Christian humility asks a person to distrust their own virtues and refuse self-esteem, even when deserved. Why would that make people useless rather than good?
- The church holds celibacy higher than marriage. Why do you think that ideal harms society rather than serving those who choose it freely?
- A believer fasts and punishes their body, convinced God offers good things only to see them refused. What does that conviction do to a person's life?