WorkBaron d'Holbach

Good Sense

Holbach's *System of Nature* stripped of its philosophical machinery — the same godless argument cut down to a book a plain reader could finish.

by Baron d'Holbach227 passages held

English, a translation held here, and your language

Original title: Le Bon-Sens
First published: 1772(aged 49)
Original language: French

Report a rights issue

Overview

Two years after the System of Nature drew refutations from Voltaire and a Prussian king, its author boiled it down to a book an ordinary reader could get through in an evening. Good Sense keeps the argument of the larger work — that there is no God, that nature needs no author, that religion is fear worked up into a system — and throws out the apparatus: the citations, the technical proofs, the philosophical scaffolding, leaving the case in short plain sentences. It came out in 1772 behind a "London" imprint that deceived no one, anonymous like everything Holbach wrote against religion, and the Parlement de Paris burned it as it had burned its parent. Made light and cheap on purpose, it travelled where the heavier book could not, and it outlived Holbach in a strange disguise: in the next century printers reissued it as Le Bon Sens du curé Jean Meslier, fathering it on a village priest, dead since 1729, who had left behind a secret testament of his own unbelief. So the abridgement of a baron's atheism spent decades in print under a country curate's name.

Key concepts

How does Good Sense relate to the System of Nature?

It is the popular abridgement of it. Two years after the System of Nature drew refutations from Voltaire and a Prussian king, Holbach boiled it down: the same godless argument, that there is no God and nature needs no author, cut to short plain sentences with the citations and technical proofs thrown out. Light and cheap on purpose, it carried the case to readers who would never open the larger book.

What does 'religion is fear' mean?

Holbach's compressed account of religion's origin. Ignorance of nature breeds terror of death and the unknown; terror invents unseen powers to placate; priests organize the terror into doctrine and ritual. Religion is therefore fear worked up into a system rather than knowledge of anything real. Strip away the fear, he argues, and the whole structure loses its hold, since dread was the foundation all along.

Why is the book called 'Good Sense'?

Because its claim is that ordinary good sense, plain reason available to anyone, is enough to see through religion. No specialist philosophy is needed. The title stakes the whole strategy: Holbach sets the reader's own judgment against inherited authority and insists the case requires only honest thinking, not the apparatus of the larger work. Common sense, not erudition, is offered as the path to unbelief.

What does Holbach mean by prejudice?

Belief absorbed from upbringing and authority rather than reached by reason, religious belief above all. For Holbach prejudice is what education and habit install before judgment can weigh anything, which is why it feels natural and goes unexamined. Good Sense sets itself against prejudice in this exact sense, asking the reader to reopen what was settled for them in childhood and decide it for themselves.

Why was it later credited to a curate named Meslier?

As cover, and it stuck for decades. In the next century printers reissued the book as Le Bon Sens du cure Jean Meslier, fathering it on a village priest dead since 1729 who had left a secret testament of his own unbelief. So the abridgement of a baron's atheism spent years in print under a country curate's name, one more instance of the borrowed dead name that carried this circle's work.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Religion as fear made into a system

Where does religion come from, at bottom? Holbach's blunt answer, cut down for any reader, is fear: dread of death and the unknown, worked up, organized and handed to priests to administer.

Stripped of the larger book's citations and proofs, the argument stands out in a single line: religion is fear worked up into a system. Ignorance of nature breeds terror, terror invents unseen powers, and priests give the terror doctrine and permanence. The cruelties charged to God, eternal punishment, the suffering of the innocent, are exhibited as contradictions no good and all-powerful being could allow. Made light and cheap on purpose, Good Sense carried this indictment where the heavier System of Nature could not, and the Paris parlement burned it as it had burned its parent. It later travelled for decades disguised under a dead village priest's name.

religion
theodicy
fear
superstition
psychology
divine justice
divine attributes
problem of evil

Enter a dialogue

Atheism a plain reader can reach

Do you need philosophy to see through religion, or only common sense? Holbach's wager here is the latter: the case against God needs no technical proofs, just honest reasoning anyone can follow.

Good Sense is the System of Nature with the philosophical machinery thrown out, and that is its argument as much as its form. Holbach's claim is that plain reason, the good sense of the title, is enough to reject religion; the scaffolding was never load-bearing. He sets ordinary judgment against inherited authority and asks the reader to trust what they can see and think over what they were told to believe. Written to be finished in an evening, it aimed at people who would never open the larger book, and it is the one of his works that reached furthest, precisely because it demanded so little of its reader.

reason
epistemology
logic
authority
prejudice
education
contradiction
materialism

Enter a dialogue

Within this work

passages held: 227
distinct concepts: 351
by passages held, corpus-wide: #321

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “reason” and “religion”.

Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 25 pairings. 83 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
Concept	Paired concept	Shared passages
reason	religion	12
divine justice	problem of evil	9
religion	theology	7
human nature	morality	6
morality	religion	6
human nature	theology	5
morality	religious authority	5
reason	religious authority	5
reason	theology	5
religious authority	theology	5
morality	reason	4
divine justice	religion	3
human nature	problem of evil	3
human nature	reason	3
human nature	religion	3
problem of evil	religion	3
religion	religious authority	3
divine justice	theology	2
morality	theology	2
problem of evil	theology	2
divine justice	human nature	1
divine justice	morality	1
divine justice	religious authority	1
human nature	religious authority	1
problem of evil	religious authority	1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

1766 Christianity Unveiled: Being an Examination of the Principles and Effects of the Christian Religion (Le Christianisme dévoilé)
The opening work in the run of anonymous antireligious books Holbach produced with his circle; the System of Nature and Good Sense that followed would build the philosophy out, where this one simply indicts the religion.
EN
1768 Letters to Eugenia; Or, A Preservative Against Religious Prejudices (Lettres à Eugénie)
Cast as letters to a young woman rather than as a treatise, this is Holbach turning his irreligion toward a single ordinary believer's formation; quieter and more intimate than the systematic books, and aimed at readers they were not.
EN
1770 Ecce Homo! Or, A Critical Inquiry into the History of Jesus of Nazareth: Being a Rational Analysis of the Gospels (Histoire critique de Jésus-Christ)
Where Christianity Unveiled indicts the religion and the System of Nature builds the philosophy, this one goes at the source texts, applying to the Gospels the historical scrutiny Holbach's circle applied to everything held sacred.
EN
1770 The System of Nature, or, the Laws of the Moral and Physical World (Système de la nature)
The centrepiece of Holbach's output and the fullest statement Enlightenment atheism produced: where the shorter books indict religion, this one lays down the whole materialist system — no God, no design, only matter in motion — that the rest assume.
EN
1772 Good Sense (Le Bon-Sens) you are here EN

— or open another of their works