WorkCarl von Clausewitz

Political Declaration

Written as Prussia bound itself to Napoleon in 1812: a Prussian major's credo of resistance, with a plan to arm every man from eighteen to sixty.

by Carl von Clausewitz122 passages held

  • German, the original language
Original title
Bekenntnisdenkschrift
First published
(aged 32)
Original language
German

Report a rights issue

Overview

Napoleon needed Prussian troops for his coming invasion of Russia, and in February 1812 Prussia was pressed into a treaty, signed in Paris on the 24th, that pledged 20,000 of them. Major Carl von Clausewitz wrote this memorandum in the same weeks to explain why he and the officers who agreed with him could not serve that alliance. It argues that a people owes nothing higher than the defence of its dignity and freedom, and that submission is both dishonourable and unsafe. He spoke for the men who had wanted to fight and were being called fools, revolutionaries and intriguers, or members of the Tugendbund, a patriotic "League of Virtue" whose supposed leaders, he says, could hardly vouch that it existed. It falls into three confessions. The first is a credo: he renounces the hope of rescue by chance and the hope of calming a tyrant by disarming. The second argues from the record that alliance with France had protected no one, as Spain, Holland, Italy and northern Germany showed. The third is a working plan for a Landsturm, a general levy of every man from eighteen to sixty not already in the army. Modelled on Tyrol, the levy would be called out by the church bells and armed with muskets or, failing those, pikes and scythes; a worked example covers the country around Berlin. That spring Clausewitz resigned and entered Russian service. In April 1813 King Friedrich Wilhelm III decreed a Landsturm of all men from fifteen to sixty, and weakened the decree that July. The memorandum itself, which carries pencilled comments by his fellow army reformer August Neidhardt von Gneisenau, was held back out of regard for the government. The historian Georg Heinrich Pertz printed it in 1869, in the third volume of his life of Gneisenau.

Key concepts

What is the Landsturm in Clausewitz's Political Declaration?

A general levy of every man from eighteen to sixty not already in the army, and the practical heart of the memorandum's third confession. Each man was to carry a musket, or failing that a pike or scythe, and the church bells would call them out. Clausewitz took Tyrol as his model and worked the plan through for the country around Berlin, so that a whole people, not only its army, would defend the state.

Which two hopes does Clausewitz renounce in his credo?

The hope of rescue by chance, and the hope of calming a tyrant by disarming. Both promise safety without resistance, and the credo refuses them together. Against them Clausewitz sets the conviction that a people owes nothing higher than the defence of its dignity and freedom. What that defence demands cannot be left to luck, and it cannot be bought by making oneself harmless.

Why does Clausewitz call submission unsafe as well as dishonourable?

Because the record showed that it protected no one. The second confession argues from experience rather than principle: the cases of Spain, Holland, Italy and northern Germany showed that alliance with France had kept none of them safe. Submission therefore fails on its own terms. It gives up honour for the sake of security and does not receive the security either.

What does it mean that every future war would be a national cause?

It is the memorandum's closing prediction: that wars to come would be fought as the cause of whole nations, rather than as the business of governments and their armies alone. The Landsturm plan is that prediction put to work, a people armed from eighteen to sixty. Clausewitz returned to the idea in the chapter of On War on arming the people.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Why Submission Buys No Safety

Is submitting to a conqueror ever the safe course? Clausewitz judged it dishonourable and, on the evidence of the states already allied to France, unsafe as well.

A people, he holds, owes nothing higher than the defence of its dignity and freedom. His credo renounces two comforts: the hope of rescue by chance, and the hope of calming a tyrant by disarming. Then comes the record: Spain, Holland, Italy and northern Germany showed what alliance with France was worth, since it had protected none of them. He wrote as a major speaking for officers called fools, revolutionaries and intriguers for wanting to fight, and that same spring he acted on it, resigning to enter Russian service.

  • honor
  • courage
  • political courage
  • patriotism
  • political resistance
  • resistance
  • political dissent
  • fear
  • alliances
  • diplomacy
  • political judgment
  • public opinion
  • national character

A Landsturm: Arming Every Man

What is left to a state that cannot match its enemy's army in the field? Clausewitz's answer was to arm the whole people and call it out by the church bells.

The third confession is a working plan rather than a hope. Every man from eighteen to sixty not already in the army would be armed with a musket, or failing that a pike or scythe, and called out by the church bells, on the model of Tyrol. Clausewitz worked the scheme through for the country around Berlin. In April 1813 the king decreed a Landsturm of all men from fifteen to sixty, then weakened the decree that July. The memorandum ends by predicting that every future war would be fought as a national cause.

  • militia
  • insurgency
  • popular resistance
  • irregular warfare
  • occupation
  • terrain
  • defense
  • warfare
  • military strategy

Within this work

passages held
122
distinct concepts
229
by passages held, corpus-wide
#463

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “defense” and “military strategy”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 11 pairings. 90 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
defensemilitary strategy12
military strategywarfare11
insurgencymilitary strategy6
couragepatriotism4
defensewarfare4
alliancesmilitary strategy3
military strategywar2
allianceswar1
couragemilitary strategy1
couragewar1
patriotismwar1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 1812 Political Declaration (Bekenntnisdenkschrift) you are here DE
  2. 1832 On War (Vom Kriege)

    A far larger successor to the principles he drafted for the Prussian Crown Prince in 1812, it fills the first three of the ten volumes of his posthumous works and is the book his reputation rests on.

    DEEN
  3. 1834 Principles of War (Die wichtigsten Grundsätze des Kriegführens)

    Written for a royal pupil at the end of two years of lessons, it states briefly ideas that On War later works out at length.

    DE
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works