WorkEpicurus

Letter to Menoeceus

A short letter on how to live: Epicurus's argument that death is nothing to us and the gods no threat, distilled by his followers into a four-part cure.

by Epicurus11 passages held

  • English, a translation held here, and your language
First published
300 BCE(aged 41)
Original language
Ancient Greek

Report a rights issue

Overview

Where the letter to Herodotus treats nature, this one treats living: a short letter of moral advice to a young man named Menoeceus, and the most concentrated statement of Epicurus's ethics we possess. Like the other surviving letters, it reaches us only because Diogenes Laertius quoted it in full. The argument works to remove fears. Death, first: it is nothing to us, since while we exist it is not present, and when it comes we no longer exist to meet it — so a wise person neither dreads dying nor clings to life. The gods, next: they exist, blessed and untroubled, and take no interest in punishing or rewarding us, so there is nothing to appease. Then pleasure, which Epicurus names the goal while stripping out the vice later fastened to his name — he means not indulgence but the absence of bodily pain and mental disturbance, reached by wanting little and choosing well. The same fears recur in the four-part remedy later Epicureans distilled from the opening Principal Doctrines, the tetrapharmakos: the gods hold no threat, death no danger, what is good is easy to get, what is terrible easy to endure. From a philosophy that named pleasure the highest good, no shorter or more misread prescription for a calm life has come down to us.

Key concepts

What is the Letter to Menoeceus about?

It is Epicurus's short letter of moral advice to a young man, the most concentrated statement of his ethics that survives. Where the Letter to Herodotus treats nature, this one treats living. It argues away the fear of death and of the gods, then explains what pleasure rightly understood is and how, by wanting little and choosing well, a person reaches a calm and happy life. Diogenes Laertius preserved it in full.

What is the tetrapharmakos?

The four-part remedy, a summary later Epicureans distilled from the opening Principal Doctrines and echoed in this letter: the gods hold no threat, death holds no danger, what is good is easy to get, and what is terrible is easy to endure. Four short lines against the four great sources of anxiety. It functioned as a memorable creed, a portable cure a follower could recite to steady the mind.

What does Epicurus mean by pleasure?

Not indulgence but the absence of bodily pain and mental disturbance. The highest pleasure is a settled tranquillity, not a stream of intense sensations, which is why plain food can satisfy as fully as a feast. Epicurus distinguishes such static pleasure from the passing kind, and holds that once pain is gone pleasure cannot be increased, only varied, so more is not better.

How does Epicurus classify desires?

Into three kinds. Some are natural and necessary, like food, shelter, and freedom from fear; some are natural but unnecessary, like rich meals or luxury; and some are empty or groundless, like the hunger for fame, wealth or power, which have no natural limit. The route to contentment is to satisfy the first, take the second sparingly, and see through the third, which can never be filled.

Why does Epicurus make prudence the chief virtue?

Because living pleasantly depends on choosing well, and that is prudence's work: the sober calculation of which pleasures to pursue and which to decline, which pains to accept now for a greater calm later. Epicurus goes further, holding that one cannot live pleasantly without living wisely, honourably and justly, nor live wisely without living pleasantly, so the virtues and the good life come as one.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Why death and the gods are nothing to fear

The two great terrors, dying and divine punishment, poison a life before they ever arrive. Epicurus argues both away so the mind can be at rest.

Two terrors are worked loose. Death first: it is nothing to us, since while we exist it is not present, and when it comes we no longer exist to meet it, so a wise person neither dreads dying nor clings to life. The gods next: they exist, blessed and untroubled, and take no interest in punishing or rewarding us, so there is nothing to appease. Both fears rest on a confusion, imagining ourselves present at our own absence and projecting human anger onto the divine. Clearing them leaves ataraxia, a mind no longer spending the present in dread of what cannot touch it.

  • death
  • fear
  • tranquility
  • theology
  • chance
  • divine nature
  • fate

Pleasure, stripped of the vice pinned to it

If pleasure is the goal of life, is the good life a life of indulgence? Epicurus means the opposite: the absence of pain, reached by wanting little and choosing well.

Epicurus names pleasure the goal while stripping out the debauchery later fastened to his name. The pleasure he means is negative, the absence of bodily pain and mental disturbance, not a heaping-up of sensation. Desires he sorts: some natural and necessary, some natural but unnecessary, some empty; the settled life meets the first and quiets the rest, so that bread and water can content a person as much as a feast. Prudence is the chief virtue, the sober weighing of which pleasures to take and which pains to accept for a greater calm. One cannot live pleasantly without living wisely and justly, nor the reverse.

  • pleasure
  • desire
  • prudence
  • happiness
  • simplicity
  • choice
  • ataraxia
  • free will

Within this work

passages held
11
distinct concepts
26
by passages held, corpus-wide
#287

What this book thinks together

Every arc around the wheel is one concept in this book. A ribbon joins two the text reaches for together, and its width is how many of its passages hold both. Strongest: desire with ethics.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 4 concepts, joined by 3 pairings. 6 shared passages in all.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
desireethics2
desirepleasure2
pleasureprudence2

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. -300 Letter to Herodotus

    The physics epitome of Epicurus's system, addressed to a pupil and preserved whole by Diogenes Laertius; it condenses the lost thirty-seven books of On Nature into a single letter.

    GRCEN
  2. -300 Letter to Menoeceus you are here GRCEN
  3. Fragments

    Not a single work but the gleanings of a lost body of writing: sayings from a medieval Vatican manuscript, quotations left by hostile authors, and text still emerging from the burned papyri of Herculaneum.

    GRCEN
  4. Principal Doctrines

    Forty numbered sayings, most no longer than a sentence, that condense Epicurus's ethics into a form his followers could memorize and a scattered school could carry and share.

    GRCEN
Sign in or subscribe to discuss this work

— or open another of their works