Zen masterJapan

Hakuin Ekaku

The restorer who made doubt the way into Zen

2 works · 447 passages grounded

Lifespan
1686–1769
School
Zen
Wikipedia

The mind

Every Rinzai Zen lineage in Japan today runs back through the heirs of Hakuin Ekaku, and the sequence of kōan, the riddling cases on which a Rinzai monk is examined, was put in order by his successors. When he began, the school had lost its rich patrons and was turning to lay people for support, and the Ōbaku school, newly arrived from China, was winning monks with a stricter communal training. Hakuin spent fifty years as priest of Shōin-ji, a small temple in Hara, a post town on the Tōkaidō road at the foot of Mount Fuji, and made it a place monks crossed the country to reach.

Most of what is known of his path comes from his own telling, above all Itsumadegusa ("Wild Ivy"), the autobiography he wrote in 1765, and from the chronological biography by his disciple Tōrei Enji. As a child, he writes, a Nichiren preacher's sermon on the hot hells terrified him, and he became a monk at fifteen to escape them. At nineteen he read that Yantou, a great Chinese master, had been murdered by bandits, and he despaired of what Zen could do. At twenty-four, after seven days of sitting shut away at Eigen-ji, he heard a temple bell and took himself to be awakened. Shōju Rōjin (Dōkyō Etan), a hermit teacher with whom he then studied for eight months, mocked the claim and gave him harder cases. Hakuin pressed on so hard that his health broke. In Idle Talk on a Night Boat, printed in 1757 and in print ever since, he told how a hermit in the hills outside Kyoto taught him the breathing that cured him.

From his mid-twenties, he says, one sentence troubled him: that sages and holy monks who lack bodhicitta, the mind set on awakening, all fall among the demons. In his early forties, reading the Lotus Sutra, he came to the chapter of parables and understood the sentence at last. Bodhicitta, he concluded, is doing good: teaching others and benefiting them. This is the claim at the centre of his Zen. Awakening is not a calm to rest in; the real work is the practice that comes after it, and it is done for others.

Everything he taught follows from that. He wanted beginners driven into what he called the great doubt, holding a single question until it gave way, and for them he devised his own first case, the sound of one hand, which he judged far better than the traditional first kōan. He attacked teachers who equated a quiet empty mind with enlightenment. In 1749 he lectured on the sermons of Daitō, the fourteenth-century founder of Daitoku-ji, and his commentary, Kaian kokugo, turns Daitō's hardest words against monks who sat all day and called the calm awakening.

He spent his last fifteen years writing, much of it in plain Japanese and popular verse that commoners could read, and he took up painting at almost sixty. His ink portraits of Bodhidharma and his calligraphy, made for lay people who often could not read, now hang in museums. He died at Shōin-ji, in the village where he was born, in 1769, at eighty-three.

His closest disciple, Tōrei, received his robe, but today's lineages descend through Gasan Jitō and Gasan's students Inzan Ien and Takuju Kosen, and scholars doubt that Gasan was formally Hakuin's heir at all. Hakuin himself never received a formal transmission from Shōju or anyone else. All fourteen branches of the Rinzai school count him as their restorer, and their monks recite his Zazen wasan, a hymn in praise of sitting, when they sit.

Key concepts

What is the great doubt in Hakuin's Zen?

The great doubt is the all-consuming questioning Hakuin makes the entrance to Zen. A student takes up one teaching story and presses on it until doubt fills body and mind and nothing else is left; then it breaks. His own doubt held for years before the sound of a temple bell broke it one night. In his remedy for monks sick with false views, doubt is the largest ingredient.

What is a huatou, the phrase a Zen student holds?

A huatou, literally the head of the words, is the decisive phrase of an old teaching story: the point where the story stops making sense. The student does not analyse it or recite it but carries it through every hour, so that it gathers the doubt. Hakuin scorns monks who leave it unstudied and put chanting the Buddha's name, reciting sutras and bowing in its place.

What does seeing one's nature, kenshō, mean for Hakuin?

Kenshō is the breakthrough in which a person sees their own nature directly, not as an idea about it. Hakuin describes what comes after long, hard effort: one day everything suddenly opens, and all things, inside and out, fine and coarse, become one great Way. Only someone who has seen this way, he says, can grasp the old saying that nothing exists in the three worlds, so where would one look for mind?

What does "refined gold does not change colour" mean?

It is an old Chan saying Hakuin uses for what awakening finds: nothing new. After each breakthrough he looked for what he had gained and found not a speck; his eyes were level and his nose straight, as before. Gold that has been refined stays what it always was. But the saying is also a trap. Whoever takes it as the end of the matter, he warns, stops exactly where the work begins.

What are the four great vows Hakuin keeps returning to?

The four great vows are the bodhisattva's promises: to save all beings, cut off every passion, learn every teaching and reach the Buddha's way. Hakuin makes them the measure of awakening. Someone who settles into a quiet emptiness for himself has only a small fruit, he says; the true bodhisattva keeps going and acts by these vows for the good of all. Even his book on healing urges readers to rouse them.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

The Great Doubt

A question held until it gives way: Hakuin makes doubt, not calm, the door into Zen. What has to break in a person before they see, and why there is no road around the breaking, is the claim his teaching rests on.

His own doubt held for years, until one night the sound of a temple bell broke it. When he writes out a remedy for monks sick with false views, faith gets one measure, vigorous effort two and great doubt three, the largest dose in the recipe. From there he turns on teachers who let students settle into stillness, and on monks who put chanting the Buddha's name, reciting sutras and bowing in place of the phrase from an old case they were given to hold.

  • koan
  • koan practice
  • awakening
  • realization
  • direct experience
  • discipline
  • spiritual practice
  • zen practice

Nothing Gained, No Place to Stop

After the bell he looked for what he had won and found nothing: eyes level, nose straight, as before. Why awakening adds nothing, and why it still may not be rested in, is where his Zen asks the most.

He counted more than ten great joys after the first, and each time, examined closely, not a speck had been gained; refined gold, in the old phrase, does not change colour. Yet whoever takes that phrase as enough is, in his word, a dullard. Against the solitary sage who wakes to the emptiness of self and guards that clear stillness for years, he sets the bodhisattva who keeps probing, sweeps away even the view of emptiness, and lives by the four great vows for the good of all beings.

  • enlightenment
  • nonattachment
  • emptiness
  • nirvana
  • compassion
  • skillful means
  • buddha-nature
  • nonduality

Living Words and Paper Heirs

Monks of his day said the truth lies beyond words, and some held a certificate of succession in place of insight. What makes a teaching, and a teacher, genuine is the question his scorn keeps putting.

To him the slogan that the Dharma stands apart from words and letters, so that any speech is already heresy, was the error of a frivolous late age; the masters of old said the opposite, and a single word of theirs works like a red-hot iron spike. He mocked counterfeit monks who inherit by paper and by whisk and receive an empty echo, and admitted that his own understanding was no better than his students' until his teacher Shōju's angry fists.

  • language
  • interpretation
  • teaching
  • teacher-student relationship
  • transmission
  • spiritual authority
  • authenticity
  • tradition
  • zen dialogue

Awakening Carried Into the Body

After his first awakening Hakuin danced for months, then found that stillness and movement in his days still would not fit together. Whether insight can be lived in a working, breathing body, or breaks it, he answered from his own collapse.

Pressing harder to close that gap wrecked his health, and the recovery taught him to send breath and vital energy down into the lower belly, where he stored what Mencius called the flood-like energy. He cites the instruction Dōgen received in China, to rest the mind on the palm of the left hand while sitting. And he praises the old masters who hauled stones and carried water every day, no work, no food, gaining strength in the midst of movement.

  • healing
  • qi
  • traditional medicine
  • health
  • longevity
  • mind-body
  • embodiment
  • ordinary life
  • practice
  • meditation

By the numbers

works held
2
passages traced
447
concepts traced
378
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “nonduality” and “zen buddhism”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 16 pairings. 93 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
nondualityzen buddhism45
meditationzen buddhism12
nondualityzen practice10
healingmeditation6
qitraditional medicine6
meditationzen practice5
qiself-cultivation5
meditationnonduality4
meditationself-cultivation4
self-cultivationtraditional medicine4
healingzen practice3
meditationtraditional medicine3
healingzen buddhism2
meditationqi2
healingnonduality1
self-cultivationzen buddhism1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: zen buddhism in 槐安國語, 40.8%.

Density 0% 40.8%

Concept density per work, chronological 2 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 64 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearmeditationzen buddhismhealingself-cultivationzen practiceqinondualitytraditional medicine
槐安國語5.3%40.8%0.7%0.2%10.1%0%25.7%0%
Idle Talk on a Night Boat40%0%36.7%26.7%16.7%26.7%0%23.3%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

LECTURES ON DAITŌ — THE PERILOUS ROAD

  1. 1749 lit. Words from the Land of Kaian 槐安國語

    A commentary on another master's record: lectures of 1749 on the sermons and verses of Daitō, the founder of Daitoku-ji, and Hakuin's major work in classical Chinese.

    LZH
  2. 1757 Idle Talk on a Night Boat (夜船閑話)

    Written in plain Japanese rather than the Chinese of his commentaries, for monks who had wrecked their health in training; it found its readers far outside the monasteries.

    JA
Begin a dialogue with Hakuin Ekaku

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.