Fate, and the freedom left inside it
Once climate, body, birth and history are counted, how much of a life is still a person's own? Emerson concedes nearly everything to fate and then claims thought back from it.
"Fate" begins by giving limitation its full weight. Circumstance, Emerson says, is half of every life, and it binds like the soft band that held the Norse wolf where steel had failed. His answer is not denial but understanding. Fate is only causes not yet seen into, and intellect annuls fate: so far as a person thinks, they are free. A sailor who learns to swim is carried by the wave that drowns another. Power follows the same law, which is why shallow men believe in luck and strong ones in cause and effect.
- fate
- determinism
- free will
- freedom
- causality
- natural law
- human agency
- adversity
- power
- moral responsibility
- human potential
- self-knowledge
Enter a dialogue
- The Norse gods bound their wolf not with steel but with a band softer than silk, which held tighter the more he struggled. Is fate like that?
- "So far as a man thinks, he is free," you write in your essay on fate. How can understanding the laws that bind someone set them free?
- The wave that drowns one sailor carries another who has learned to swim. What would learning to swim mean for someone crushed by circumstance?
- You ask your readers to build altars to the Beautiful Necessity. Why should anyone worship the very order that limits and sometimes crushes them?