Chan masterChina

Wansong Xingxiu

The Caodong master who read China's classics toward mind

1 work · 431 passages grounded

Lifespan
~1166–~1246
Also known as
Bansho Gyoshu
Wikipedia

The mind

Confucians and Daoists, Wansong Xingxiu wrote in the first chapter of his best-known book, trace all things back to one primal breath, qi; Buddhists trace them to the one mind. Then he takes a side. He cites Zongmi, a ninth-century scholar-monk, for the view that the primal breath is itself something the mind produces. The verse he is explaining at that moment is not his own, and neither is most of what the book contains. Wansong built his reputation on other men's words: a remembered exchange between earlier masters, a poem on it by Hongzhi Zhengjue (1091–1157), the great master of his own Caodong line of Chan, and around them a commentary that reaches into the Confucian classics, the histories and the Daoist books. His claim is that the old cases of Chan do not stand against the learning of China; read with all of it, they still point past it, to the mind that every teaching rests on.

He lived his whole life under rulers who were not Chinese. Born in 1166 into the Cai family of Hezhong, in today's Shanxi, he grew up in a north China ruled by the Jurchen Jin dynasty. At fifteen he became a monk at Xingzhou, studied under Xueyan Huiman, a Caodong master at Cizhou, and returned to a hall called Wansong, "ten thousand pines", which gave him his name. In 1193 Emperor Zhangzong of Jin called him to court to expound the teaching and gave him a brocade robe. From 1197 he lived at the Bao'en monastery west of the capital, Zhongdu, today's Beijing, in a hermitage named Congrong, "serenity".

The Mongols took Zhongdu in 1215, and the Jin court fled south to Kaifeng. Wansong stayed. That year Yelü Chucai, a Khitan official of the Jin who had lived through the siege, became his pupil and studied with him for three years, until Genghis Khan summoned him in 1218. Wansong had once lectured on Hongzhi's hundred verses on old cases, but the work had lapsed in the wars. At the end of 1222 a letter from Yelü reached him insisting that he finish it, and in 1223 he sent the commentary to Almaliq in Central Asia, where Yelü was then in Genghis Khan's service. His covering letter says that his eyes were failing, that he mostly dictated while his disciples wrote, and that he had followed the Blue Cliff Record, Yuanwu Keqin's commentary on the verses of Xuedou Chongxian, in giving every case an introduction. In the same letter he says the book transmits rather than invents, borrowing the phrase Confucius used of himself.

The Book of Serenity is the result. It explains one of Hongzhi's verses through the Tang essayist Han Yu's mock biography of a writing brush and another through the Daoist book Liezi's story of a sheep lost where the road forks. He wrote a second commentary on Hongzhi's prose remarks on old cases, became abbot of the Wanshou monastery in 1230, and died in 1246. His disciples built a brick pagoda for his remains in what is now central Beijing; it was enclosed in a larger pagoda in 1753 and found intact inside it in 1986.

The book's reception came later and further east. In Japan the Sōtō school of Zen, heir to the Caodong line, came to hold the Book of Serenity in the place the Rinzai school gives the Blue Cliff Record, and Thomas Cleary's complete English translation appeared in 1990.

Key concepts

What is the one mind that every teaching rests on?

It is the awareness in which everything appears, and for Wansong it is the root beneath every teaching, deeper than the primal breath of Confucians and Daoists. A sutra he cites gives it three senses: it keeps the Buddha hidden within it; it holds every being and every land; and it gives rise to the path. It is not a thing in the world but where the world is met.

What does "before the empty eon" mean in Caodong Chan?

It names what is there before anything begins. Buddhist cosmology has an empty age before each world forms, and before any Buddha comes to teach; the Caodong line uses the phrase for the ground beneath every moment. Nanquan says he tells his monks to take it up before the empty eon and understand it before any Buddha appeared. Wansong adds that it is never cut off from now: it must be met here.

What is one's "own lot" in Chan?

It is each thing being fully what it already is, the matter a person was never apart from. Wansong says the old masters called it that only because some name was needed. He reaches for village songs and festival drinking, everyone at peace in their place, the moon white and the wind clear. Awakening, on this view, is not becoming something else; it is ceasing to stretch or cut what one is.

What are host and guest in a Chan exchange?

They are the two roles in an encounter: the host holds the ground and the guest comes to test it. A good exchange needs both, and the roles can change hands in a single line. When a monk circles a master's seat three times and plants his staff, Wansong calls it a meeting of host and guest that has both light and use, both a head and a tail.

What are the four propositions and the hundred negations?

They are every way of saying something about the ultimate: it is, it is not, both, neither, and all the denials that branch from these. A monk asks to be shown the meaning apart from all four. Wansong refuses the escape: without leaving the four propositions or cutting off the hundred negations, he says, the meaning is already plain. Truth is not found by stepping outside speech.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

One Mind Beneath Every Teaching

Confucians and Daoists trace the world to one primal breath, Buddhists to one mind. Whether the classics are rivals to the old cases or roads that run into them is what he has to decide.

Wansong opens his book by ranking the teachings by their root, and with the ninth-century scholar-monk Zongmi he makes the primal breath itself something the mind produces. Yet he never throws the classics out. Laozi's nameless thing older than the Lord on High becomes the Caodong time before any Buddha appeared, Confucius's trust that Heaven would not let a culture perish greets a master and his heir, and Zhuangzi's duck and crane explain a verse. China's learning stays, read as pointing at the mind.

  • mind
  • nonduality
  • scripture
  • scriptural interpretation
  • knowledge
  • wisdom
  • symbolism
  • appearance and reality

Before Any Buddha Appeared

The Caodong line points to what comes before the first world-age and the first Buddha. How a teacher shows what no word reaches, without falling silent or saying too much, is the question underneath.

His house, Wansong says, does not prize the stick and the shout delivered head-on; it sends word by a side road. So he reads every exchange for its two sides, lord and minister, host and guest, the hidden and the shown, and asks whether an answer turned at the right moment. Laozi's thread, barely there yet never broken, becomes his image for the oldest thing: it is not cut off from the present, and the old masters revealed it by meeting whatever lay in front of them.

  • emptiness
  • ineffability
  • nonconceptuality
  • language and silence
  • paradox
  • responsiveness
  • nonverbal communication
  • time

Everything in Its Own Place

Eyes see, ears hear, and the eyebrows sit on top doing nothing. Does awakening add anything to a life already in its place, or only let it be what it is?

Wansong calls it one's own lot, a name the old masters used only because they had to: pines straight, thorns crooked, the crane's legs long and the duck's short, and stretching or cutting either brings grief. Asked for the great meaning of the teaching, a master asked the price of rice; beside him Wansong sets a minister telling his emperor that peace has no image, and a farmer singing as he beats the ground. An old saying he quotes adds that the awakened are the same as before.

  • ordinary life
  • everyday life
  • naturalness
  • simplicity
  • realization
  • equanimity
  • embodiment
  • freedom

What a Lineage Hands On

A teaching survives a war only if someone carries it across. Whether the heir owes the master his words, his house's style or something no words carry decides what faithfulness means.

Wansong says he transmits and does not invent, in the words Confucius used of himself, and in the same letter that in his asides and his cuts he gave way to nobody when the moment called. That is his picture of a lineage. When Zhaozhou answers his teacher by putting his sandals on his head, Wansong quotes Confucius again: Heaven has not let this culture perish. The way lives on in an heir who answers in kind, never in one who copies a master's frown.

  • transmission
  • spiritual transmission
  • lineage
  • recognition
  • spiritual authority
  • judgment
  • discernment
  • authority

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
431
concepts traced
326
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “nonduality” and “zen buddhism”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 27 pairings. 77 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
nondualityzen buddhism40
languagezen buddhism26
languagenonduality24
skillful meanszen buddhism21
nonattachmentzen buddhism20
teachingzen buddhism19
awakeningzen buddhism18
awakeningnonduality17
chan buddhismskillful means16
chan buddhismteaching15
skillful meansteaching14
nondualityskillful means12
languageteaching11
awakeningchan buddhism9
chan buddhismnonduality9
nonattachmentnonduality9
chan buddhismnonattachment8
awakeningnonattachment7
awakeningteaching7
languageskillful means7
awakeningskillful means6
chan buddhismlanguage6
nonattachmentskillful means6
languagenonattachment3
nondualityteaching3
awakeninglanguage2
nonattachmentteaching2

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: zen buddhism in Book of Serenity, 40.4%.

Density 0% 40.4%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 63 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearzen buddhismnondualityawakeninglanguageteachingskillful meanschan buddhismnonattachment
Book of Serenity40.4%26%15.8%14.8%14.2%13%12.3%10.7%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. Book of Serenity (從容錄)

    Of Wansong's two commentaries on Hongzhi's poems, the one on the hundred verses: modelled on the Blue Cliff Record, and the form in which those verses are read today.

    ZH
Begin a dialogue with Wansong Xingxiu

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.