Chan masterChina

Hongzhi Zhengjue

The master of silent illumination on Mount Tiantong

1 work · 628 passages grounded

Lifespan
1091–1157
Also known as
Wanshi Shogaku
Wikipedia

The mind

At eighteen, Hongzhi Zhengjue went to study with Kumu Facheng, a teacher of the Caodong line of Chan whose sitting was so still that his name, Kumu, means "dry wood". The young monk, born in Xizhou in today's Shanxi, had left home at eleven. He kept Kumu's way of sitting, upright and unmoving, for the rest of his life, and he built a teaching on it. It was called mozhao, silent illumination: sitting without an object and without a goal. Thinking settles, and the mind's own clarity shows itself, because awakening is already present in everyone and needs to be lived out rather than acquired. His short "Inscription on Silent Illumination" insists that the two halves need each other: stillness without illumination turns murky, and illumination without stillness turns aggressive.

The line he joined had nearly died out a few generations earlier. Both Kumu and Hongzhi's next teacher, Danxia Zichun, were disciples of Furong Daokai, who had revived the Caodong school and set strict rules for its monasteries. Furong refused honours from the emperor as unfit for a monk and was exiled, though pardoned the next year; Hongzhi wrote a poem in his praise. Hongzhi received Danxia's seal of transmission before Danxia died in 1119, and he also spent time with Yuanwu Keqin, the Linji master who compiled the Blue Cliff Record. Morten Schlütter, a historian of Song Chan, has argued that silent illumination itself was a product of this revived Caodong line in the early twelfth century.

In 1129 Hongzhi became abbot of the Jingde monastery on Mount Tiantong, near the coast of today's Zhejiang. The monastery was small and in disrepair; under him it was rebuilt to hold twelve hundred monks, and he refused every invitation to leave. These were years of war after the Jin conquest of the north, and of hunger. He ate nothing after noon, and more than once he gave the monastery's food to the villages around it. Dōgen, the founder of Japanese Sōtō Zen, later told how a steward begged Hongzhi to send away the hundreds of monks the stores could not feed, and was told that each of them had his own mouth and it was not the steward's concern.

Dahui Zonggao, the leading master of the rival Linji line, campaigned against what he called the heretical Chan of silent illumination, whose teachers, he said, told troubled officials to make their minds cold ash and dead wood. Dahui told them instead to hold one phrase from an old kōan with all their doubt. Later partisans of both schools turned this into a feud between the two men, and historians still dispute whether Dahui meant Hongzhi at all. They were colleagues. Hongzhi never answered the criticism, sent food to Dahui's monastery when it ran short, and recommended him as abbot of another great monastery. In the autumn of 1157 he came down the mountain for the first time in nearly thirty years to thank his patrons. Back on the mountain, before he died, he wrote asking Dahui to take charge of Tiantong.

His disciples gathered his sermons, verses and instructions into the nine volumes of the Hongzhi chanshi guanglu, his "extensive record", and his hundred verses on old kōans became the core of the Book of Serenity, printed in 1224. Three years later Dōgen received transmission at the same Tiantong monastery. Dōgen quotes Hongzhi more than any other Chan master.

Key concepts

What are the "upright" and the "inclined" in Hongzhi's teaching?

They are a pair of terms from his Caodong line for two sides of every moment. The upright is the undivided source, empty of any distinction; the inclined is the world of separate things, this mountain, that sound. Hongzhi insists they never come apart: the upright, though upright, leans toward things, and the inclined, though inclined, is whole. Seeing only the empty source, or only the things, misses both.

What does it mean that the mind is "originally complete"?

It means nothing has to be added to a person for awakening to be there. One of Hongzhi's sermons says the mind has lacked nothing through countless ages, was never cultivated and never stained, with not a hair too little or too much. Practice therefore builds nothing; it stops covering what is already whole. Only when that light breaks through, he says, does a person come to trust it.

What does "stepping back" mean in Hongzhi's practice?

Stepping back is his name for turning away from the chase after objects and states. Most effort reaches forward, toward a calm or an insight; Hongzhi tells his monks instead to step back and look, and calls what follows returning home, like a son coming back to his father. Nothing new is reached by it. The seeker simply stops leaving the place where he already is.

What does Hongzhi mean when he tells monks to "rest" and "cease"?

Resting means letting the mind's grasping stop, not falling asleep. In one sermon he says: rest, cease, cut off words and thoughts, lean on nothing, dwell nowhere, and then names what follows, a mind that turns vividly and walks on with steps that never break off. Resting is the ground of acting, and the stillness he asks for is meant to keep moving.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Sitting With Nothing to Hold

Most ways of meditating hand the mind something to grip. What is left to do when it is given nothing at all, and why that is harder than it sounds, is where his teaching begins.

His inscription on seated meditation says the mind knows without touching things and shines without meeting conditions, like clear water where fish swim slowly all the way down. Nothing is produced or added. Yet the method has two halves that must stay together: silence that loses its brightness turns murky, and brightness that loses its silence turns aggressive. Dōgen, who rewrote that inscription in Japan a century later, judged it the only one of its kind that truly said what sitting is.

  • meditation
  • silence
  • stillness
  • awareness
  • nonconceptuality
  • nonconceptual awareness
  • equanimity
  • no-mind
  • Chan practice

Nothing Missing, Nothing Extra

Awakening, on his account, is already whole in every person. What that leaves a seeker to do, and why a gift nobody lacks still goes unnoticed, is the question underneath every sermon.

Through countless ages, one sermon says, the mind has been complete, never cultivated and never stained, not a hair too little and not a hair too much. Hongzhi treats this less as comfort than as correction: the seeker's mistake is the seeking, like the fire-boy in an old story he retells who comes asking for fire. The Sixth Patriarch's mirror, his verse says, was never polished. Practice does not make the mind brighter. It stops the search that hides what was there all along.

  • original nature
  • buddha-nature
  • original mind
  • awakening
  • realization
  • direct realization
  • enlightenment

The Upright and the Inclined

Emptiness is easily mistaken for a void that swallows the world. How one undivided source and the countless separate things belong together is what his school's oldest pair of terms is for.

His line spoke of the upright, the undivided emptiness, and the inclined, the many particular things. Hongzhi will not let either stand alone: the upright, though upright, leans; the inclined, though inclined, is whole; and neither ever leaves its own place. Awakening therefore does not dissolve the world. In his inscription on silent illumination the myriad forms give off light and preach, each confirming the others, question and answer fitting exactly. Emptiness is what lets things be seen, not what removes them.

  • nonduality
  • emptiness
  • interdependence
  • suchness
  • appearance and reality
  • perception
  • ordinary experience

Putting Down Both Loads

People carry what they have and what they lack as though both were theirs to keep. What freedom from birth and death would be, if it is not an escape from living, is what his talk of resting keeps circling.

Rest, cease, he tells his monks: bring nothing in if it is there, carry nothing off if it is not. The free person is a porter whose loads have slipped from both ends of the pole and who then throws the pole away as well; whoever keeps it stays a porter. Birth and death leave endless traces, a sermon says, while the true illumination stays undimmed, and an eye that opens here sees right through them. Freedom is the end of carrying, not a flight from life.

  • nonattachment
  • attachment
  • freedom
  • liberation
  • birth and death
  • death
  • impermanence

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
628
concepts traced
367
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “chan buddhism” and “nonduality”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 28 pairings. 74 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
chan buddhismnonduality89
awarenessnonduality83
emptinessnonduality60
meditationnonduality49
awakeningnonduality38
chan buddhismmeditation38
awarenessnonattachment37
awarenessemptiness36
nonattachmentnonduality34
chan buddhismnonattachment33
languagenonduality33
chan buddhismemptiness32
awarenessmeditation28
emptinessnonattachment28
awarenesschan buddhism27
meditationnonattachment25
awakeningchan buddhism24
emptinessmeditation19
awakeninglanguage16
awakeningnonattachment14
languagenonattachment13
awarenesslanguage12
awakeningemptiness11
chan buddhismlanguage11
awakeningmeditation10
emptinesslanguage8
awakeningawareness6
languagemeditation6

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: nonduality in 宏智禪師廣錄, 49.7%.

Density 0% 49.7%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 62 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearnondualitychan buddhismnonattachmentawarenessemptinessmeditationawakeninglanguage
宏智禪師廣錄49.7%29.5%24.2%22.3%18.2%16.4%12.9%12.6%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 1166 lit. Extensive Record of Chan Master Hongzhi 宏智禪師廣錄

    A nine-volume collection his disciples made of his teaching; the verses on a hundred old cases inside it later became the Book of Serenity, and his meditation instructions, among them the "Inscription on Silent Illumination", are gathered here too.

    ZH
Begin a dialogue with Hongzhi Zhengjue

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.