Chan masterChina

Yuanwu Keqin

The great commentator who kept warning against explanation

3 works · 1,351 passages grounded

Lifespan
1063–1135
Also known as
Engo Kokugon
Wikipedia

The mind

A grave illness, his biographers say, turned Yuanwu Keqin away from the scriptures. He was born in 1063 at Pengzhou, near Chengdu in Sichuan, to a family schooled in the Confucian classics, and he entered the Miaoji monastery there as a boy and studied monastic discipline and the sutras with teachers of doctrine. The sickness convinced him that reading and reciting texts would not carry him through death, and he went looking for Chan masters instead. For the rest of his life he taught on one question: where words help and where they get in the way.

The teacher who settled it was Wuzu Fayan, a master in the Yangqi branch of the Linji line; historians note that Yuanwu was in his forties when he finished his training with Wuzu, who died in 1104. The tradition tells that their first meeting went badly, that Wuzu sent him off with the advice to remember him when he lay in a fever, and that he fell ill at Jinshan and returned to him. It tells too how the breakthrough came: Wuzu raised a love poem in which a young woman calls her maid again and again for no reason except that her lover should hear her voice, and soon afterwards Yuanwu heard a rooster crow and understood. The poem is the point of the story. Its words carry no message of their own; they are there to make someone recognise a voice.

That is how he read the old cases, the remembered exchanges between earlier masters that Chan teachers set before their students. In the 1110s, at Jiashan in Hunan, he lectured on a hundred of them, each capped by a verse of Xuedou Chongxian, the eleventh-century master of the Yunmen house, and the lectures became The Blue Cliff Record. The verses are Xuedou's; the commentary is Yuanwu's, and it explains the cases, the poems and their allusions line by line. Yet the commentary keeps saying that the explanation is not the thing. One of his letters puts the distinction in the old Chan terms of a living phrase and a dead one: understand through the living phrase and you never forget it; understand through the dead one and you cannot even save yourself. A case grasped as a story with a meaning is a dead phrase. Ding-hwa Hsieh, a historian of Song Chan, reads his teaching as the bridge between the literary study of cases and the practice of concentrating on a single phrase of a case.

The practice belongs to his heir. Dahui Zonggao came to Yuanwu at the Tianning monastery in Kaifeng, the Northern Song capital, where Yuanwu had become abbot in 1124, and broke through there in 1125. Dahui later taught students to fix the mind on one word of a case until the doubt it raised gave way, and Chan tradition says that he burned the printing blocks of his teacher's book, alarmed at monks who talked too cleverly about the cases. Kaifeng fell to the Jurchen armies of the Jin in 1127. Yuanwu moved south with the dynasty, taught at Jinshan and at Yunju in Jiangxi, and received the name Yuanwu from Gaozong, the first Southern Song emperor. He went home to Zhaojue monastery in Chengdu and died there in 1135.

His other heir, Huqiu Shaolong, carried a different inheritance. Yuanwu wrote out a certificate of transmission for him in 1124. Its first half is now kept in the Tokyo National Museum as a National Treasure, the Nagare Engo or "drifting Yuanwu", named after a story that it reached the coast of Satsuma in a wooden tube. Most Japanese Rinzai teachers trace their line through Shaolong, and in Japan The Blue Cliff Record, reprinted around 1300 from surviving copies, became the foremost book of the school.

Key concepts

What is a kōan, and why give one to a student?

A kōan is a remembered exchange between earlier Chan masters, set before a student as something to see into rather than solve. One of Yuanwu's hundred has Zhaozhou ask Touzi what happens when someone who has died the great death comes back to life; Touzi replies that travelling by night is not allowed, one must arrive by daylight. Yuanwu warns that a reply like that is no riddle with a hidden answer: reasoning it out is exactly what misses it.

What does sudden awakening mean in Chan?

That seeing the truth happens all at once, not in stages. Yuanwu compares it to a spark struck from flint or a flash of lightning. Yet he does not make it the end of the road. His formula is that in principle awakening must be sudden, while in the business of living cultivation is gradual: the mind is held level, without liking and disliking, for twenty or thirty years, until it no longer wavers at the hour of death.

What is buddha-nature?

The mind that every person already has complete, able to awaken because it was never anything else. Yuanwu writes that this mind has been pure and unstained since before time began, clinging to nothing. It goes astray only because a single deluded thought stirs and a whole world of opinions follows. Awakening adds nothing to it: it is seeing what was there, and once truly seen, he says, it is gained for good.

What are skillful means?

The devices a teacher invents to free a particular student, judged by whether they work rather than by whether they are true as stated. A blow, a shout, a story or a sermon all count. Yuanwu's image for their job is pulling out nails and knocking loose wedges, unsticking what clings and untying what binds. The same device can free one student and trap another, so a teacher must first see where this one is stuck.

What does 'see your nature and become a Buddha' mean?

It is the old Chan slogan that awakening comes from looking straight at one's own mind, not from learning a doctrine about it: point directly at the mind, see its nature, and that is Buddhahood. Yuanwu quotes it often and then turns on it. Put that way, he writes, it is still theory, words used to drive out words, a path laid down for beginners. When the real thing is handed over, no such roundabout talk is needed.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

A Tile to Knock at the Gate

The sutras are a finger pointing at the moon, and the masters' sayings a tile picked up to knock at a gate. What should become of the words once the gate has opened is the question under all his teaching.

He put it to students who prized the old cases as rarities. A master's half-phrase mattered only because it made someone see the great matter directly, and once inside the gate no one carries the tile about as a marvel. Teachers set a case, he wrote, to tie down racing thoughts until the mind rests on one point and suddenly finds that it was never got from outside. Kept after that, the case is one more possession, and a lifetime of commenting on cases was his way of handing them over and taking them back.

  • koan
  • language
  • interpretation
  • conceptual thought
  • nonconceptuality
  • ineffability
  • scripture
  • understanding

Die the Great Death, Then Live

Anyone still leaning on a teaching, an insight or a reason has not let go, and nothing short of letting go will do. What has to die before a person comes back to life is what his talk of awakening turns on.

His teacher Wuzu said of the half-awakened monk that his life-root was not yet cut, and Yuanwu repeats it: one must die the great death once, and only then come back to life. An old saying he quotes gives the image of a cliff: let go of the handhold, take it on oneself, die and revive, and no one can deceive you again. When it comes, it is sudden, like the bottom falling out of a bucket. Yet the moment is not the end. What comes back acts again, and fittingly, seeing no buddhas above and no beings below.

  • awakening
  • sudden awakening
  • direct realization
  • realization
  • liberation
  • death
  • birth and death
  • enlightenment
  • nonattachment

The Ordinary Mind and Its Counterfeits

If eating when hungry and sleeping when tired is already the Way, nothing seems left to do. Why that is true and also the most dangerous thing to believe is where his letters press hardest.

He quotes Nanquan's saying that the ordinary mind is the Way and adds at once that the moment a thought aims at being ordinary, it has missed. Around the ordinary he maps its counterfeits. One monk makes a living in a ghost cave, turning clever talk of the mysterious into a doctrine. Another sits with eyes shut, guarding his idleness, and goes under in dead water. A third has seen that mountains are mountains and monks are monks, and settles into the shell of having nothing to do. Each has taken a picture of the ordinary for the thing.

  • ordinary mind
  • buddha-nature
  • original nature
  • everyday life
  • ordinary activity
  • no-mind
  • delusion
  • mind
  • nonduality

Grandmotherly Kindness

Blows, shouts and a teacher's refusal to explain look like the opposite of care. Whether that harshness can be the kindest thing a teacher does is what he argues case after case.

Linji, struck by Huangbo each time he asked, went to the hermit Dayu wanting to know his fault, and was told that Huangbo had been as kind as a grandmother, wearing himself out for his sake. Linji woke on the spot. Yuanwu reads the tradition that way: Deshan's staff and Linji's shout had already stepped into the mud out of kindness, and the Buddha's lifetime of sermons was a yellow leaf offered as gold to stop a child crying. When the crying stops, the leaf is not gold. Binding students to the device as a fixed truth, he warns new teachers, is the one thing never to do.

  • compassion
  • skillful means
  • teaching methods
  • teaching
  • teacher-student relationship
  • spiritual guidance
  • zen teaching

By the numbers

works held
3
passages traced
1,351
concepts traced
551
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “language” and “zen buddhism”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 27 pairings. 75 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
languagezen buddhism118
chan buddhismnonduality109
languagenonduality82
awakeningchan buddhism67
awakeningnonduality59
chan buddhismnonattachment55
nondualityzen buddhism55
chan buddhismdirect realization51
chan buddhismlanguage51
awakeningnonattachment46
chan buddhismspiritual practice45
direct realizationlanguage43
direct realizationnonduality39
awakeningzen buddhism34
nonattachmentnonduality34
nonattachmentspiritual practice34
awakeninglanguage29
direct realizationnonattachment28
languagenonattachment28
nonattachmentzen buddhism27
nondualityspiritual practice25
spiritual practicezen buddhism25
languagespiritual practice21
awakeningspiritual practice20
direct realizationzen buddhism14
direct realizationspiritual practice12
awakeningdirect realization7

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: zen buddhism in The Blue Cliff Record, 52.1%.

Density 0% 52.1%

Concept density per work, chronological 3 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 60 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearchan buddhismnondualitylanguagenonattachmentzen buddhismawakeningdirect realizationspiritual practice
佛果克勤禪師心要28.7%23.5%9.6%33.9%0%16.7%27.9%13.5%
圓悟佛果禪師語錄45.6%36.1%15.7%15%4.3%22.7%11.4%10.7%
The Blue Cliff Record5.9%20.1%37%9.4%52.1%12.6%4.6%8.5%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. The Blue Cliff Record (碧巖錄)

    The book he is known for, though only part of it is his: Xuedou's cases and verses, framed by Yuanwu's introductions, interjections and commentary.

    ZH
  2. lit. Essentials of Mind of Chan Master Foguo Keqin 佛果克勤禪師心要

    Letters, not lectures: the one book on his shelf in his own hand, written to named monks and laymen and gathered by his heir Ziwen.

    ZH
  3. lit. Recorded Sayings of Chan Master Yuanwu Foguo 圓悟佛果禪師語錄

    Where the Blue Cliff Record gives one long course of lectures, this gives the rest of his teaching across twenty fascicles, gathered by his disciples.

    ZH
Begin a dialogue with Yuanwu Keqin

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.