Who wrote the case against women
If every book calls women false, is that evidence about women or about who held the pen? Cupid's court hears the complaint the authors never had to answer.
Cupid receives a petition from women of every rank and rules on it like a judge. The men who swear love, leave and boast in taverns are one charge; the clerks who teach schoolboys from Ovid that women deceive are the other. Christine's reply is procedural: the books were written by one party pleading without an opponent, and often by men who had spent their lives chasing women. A whole sex cannot be condemned for some, any more than all angels for the fallen ones. The slanderers are banished from Love's court.
- gender
- deception
- slander
- misogyny
- justice
- generalization
- literary authority
- defamation
- blame
- moral responsibility
- loyalty
- love
- honor
- gender stereotypes
- betrayal
- virtue ethics
Enter a dialogue
- Your Cupid says the books would read differently had women written them. How should anyone read a case that only one side ever got to plead?
- Only honourable women are defended in your poem, and the others are left out of the count. Does that exception hand the slanderers the ground they need?
- Eve did not deceive Adam, you argue, because no one deceives without meaning to. How far does that defence reach beyond her?
- Men in your poem swear love, then boast in taverns of what they won. What does a person owe someone whose trust they were given in private?
- Women do not kill, burn towns or disinherit anyone, runs one defence in your poem. Is that proof of virtue, or only of how little power they hold?