PhilosopherChina

Laozi

The Old Master of a Way that cannot be named

1 work · 81 passages grounded

Lifespan
~601–~531 BCE
School
Daoism
Also known as
Lao Tzu · Laotse · Lao-tse
Wikipedia

The mind

A tomb at Guodian, in the Chinese province of Hubei, yielded some eight hundred bamboo slips in late 1993. The tomb is dated to about 300 BCE, and about two thousand of the characters on the slips match the book now known as the Tao Te Ching. They are the oldest physical trace of Laozi, the Old Master, to whom the book is ascribed. Of the man himself, no record from his own time survives.

The account everyone repeats was set down in the early first century BCE by Sima Qian, court historian of the Han dynasty. He tells of a native of the southern state of Chu, family name Li, given name Er, also called Dan (early texts name him Lao Dan, Old Dan), who kept the archives at the royal court of Zhou. In this account Confucius came to consult him about ritual and praised him afterwards. When the archivist saw the royal house of Zhou decline, he left for the west. At the frontier the keeper of the pass, Yin Xi, asked him to write down what he taught. He wrote a book in two parts, some five thousand characters on the Way and on virtue, and went on; nobody knew where. Sima Qian then names two other men who may have been Laozi, and does not decide among them. The tradition dates the life to the sixth century BCE and makes Laozi an older contemporary of Confucius.

Historians divide over what, if anything, stands behind Sima Qian's account. Some conclude that there was never a historical Laozi. A. C. Graham, the British sinologist, argued in 1986 that several legends had been joined, the oldest of them a story of Confucius meeting Lao Dan that was current by the fourth century BCE. Other scholars accept the tradition that Laozi was an older contemporary of Confucius. On the book there is more agreement: many date the bulk of it to the fourth century BCE, and D. C. Lau, who translated it in 1963, read it as an anthology by many hands. Two silk copies found at Mawangdui, in a tomb sealed in 168 BCE, give its two halves in the reverse of the order known today.

The book makes one central claim. The Tao (the Way) is the source of everything, cannot be named, and brings things about without forcing them. A person or a ruler should therefore practise wuwei, non-action, which does not mean doing nothing: it means giving up action driven by self-serving desire. Other teachers of the age, the followers of Confucius among them, offered rulers programmes of moral effort built on benevolence and righteousness. The Zhuangzi, a Daoist book of the late fourth century BCE, shows Lao Dan in seventeen passages, nine of them in conversation with Confucius. Where the text known today tells the reader to discard benevolence and righteousness, the Guodian slips say to cut off artifice and deceit. Some scholars conclude that the quarrel with the Confucians sharpened as the sayings were handed down.

The figure grew as the book spread. Empress Dowager Dou, the mother of the Han emperor Jing, was a devoted student of it, and later sources add that Jing, who reigned from 157 to 141 BCE, officially made it a classic. In the second century CE the Han emperor Huan built a palace at Laozi's traditional birthplace, and an inscription of about 166 CE presents Laozi as an embodiment of the Tao. The Celestial Masters, the first organised Daoist community, revered him as a deity. The Tang emperors, whose family name was Li, traced their descent from him. Wang Bi, a philosopher who died in 249 CE at about twenty-three, wrote one of the two commentaries through which the text reached later readers. By one count, some seven hundred commentaries have been written on it.

Key concepts

What does Laozi mean by returning to the root?

Returning to the root means that whatever grows goes back to where it came from, and that this going back completes it. His example is a plant: it puts out its growth and then returns to its root. The state it reaches he calls stillness. A person who understands this rule becomes patient and generous toward all things, he says, while one who does not is driven into restless action that ends badly.

What is emptiness in Laozi's thought?

Emptiness is what makes a thing usable and keeps it from running out. Laozi likens the Tao (the Way), the source of all things, to an empty vessel that should never be filled to the top. The space between heaven and earth he compares to a bellows: it is empty, and the more it is worked, the more air it gives. In a person it means not being full of oneself.

Why do things turn into their opposites, according to Laozi?

Because the Tao (the Way), the course all things follow, moves by contraries: whatever goes far in one direction comes back. A point sharpened to the limit goes blunt, a person on tiptoe loses balance, and things that reach their full strength grow old. Happiness and misery lie side by side in the same way. Laozi therefore treats every peak as the start of a decline and advises stopping short of it.

What does not striving mean for Laozi?

Not striving means not competing with others for place, credit or the last word. The wise person, he says, does not display himself, push his own view or boast, and for that very reason his merit is recognised. Because he contends with no one, no one can contend with him. The model is heaven, which does not strive and still overcomes, and does not speak and still gets its answer.

What is the Way of Heaven in Laozi?

The Way of Heaven is Laozi's name for how nature itself acts, and he holds it up as the pattern for people. It takes from what has too much and adds to what has too little, as the two ends of a bow move when it is bent. It has no favourites, and it benefits without injuring. People, he says, do the reverse: they take from those with too little to give to those with too much.

Why does Laozi speak of the female and the mother?

They are his images for a strength that works through stillness and the lower place. He calls the source of all things a mother, and pictures it as a valley, low and open. The female, he says, overcomes the male by her stillness. His advice is to know one's own forcefulness and keep to the gentler side all the same, like a channel into which everything flows.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

The source, and the way back to it

Where does everything come from, and where does it go? Laozi names a single source, the Tao (the Way), which all things leave and to which they return, and he holds that whoever knows this has nothing to fear from an ending.

Things come out of the source as children come from a mother, and they do not stay away. Plants put out their growth, and each goes back to its root. That going back is what Laozi calls stillness, and to know it is what he calls being intelligent. Not to know it leads to wild movement and a bad end. Whoever knows the mother and guards what he has from her is out of danger for life. Heaven takes its law from the Tao, and the Tao has no law except being what it is.

  • tao
  • cosmology
  • ineffability
  • stillness

Why the weak outlast the strong

What happens to anything that reaches its full strength? Laozi holds that it turns toward its opposite, and so he trusts what bends, stays low and does not compete.

The Tao (the Way) moves by contraries. Whoever stands on tiptoe does not stand firm, a point sharpened again and again does not stay sharp, and things that have grown strong grow old. Misery sits beside happiness, and nobody knows which will come of which. From this Laozi draws a rule of conduct: hold back, take the lower place and do not strive, because no one can strive against a person who does not. The bow is his picture of it. When it is bent, the high end comes down and the low end goes up.

  • paradox
  • complementarity
  • non-action
  • non-contention
  • humility
  • restraint
  • prudence

Wanting less

How much does a person need? Laozi counts the wish to be getting as the greatest of faults, and he takes his measure from the belly, which can be filled, and not from the eye, which cannot.

Fame or life, life or wealth: he asks which is dearer, and answers that whoever clings to fame gives up something greater. A hall full of gold and jade cannot be kept safe. Favour is as much to be feared as disgrace, since whoever has it lives in fear of losing it. Even the wish to live can go too far, and those who strain to prolong their lives move toward death. His model is the infant, whose desires have not yet stirred. To know other people is to be discerning. To know oneself, he says, is the greater thing.

  • desire
  • moderation
  • contentment
  • simplicity
  • self-cultivation
  • self-knowledge

Against the teachers of virtue and learning

Do moral teaching and study make people better? Laozi answers that the highest goodness does not know itself as goodness, and that naming, teaching and displaying it come later, once it has begun to fail.

He sets what the teachers of his age prized on a ladder that leads down. First the Tao (the Way) is lost, then the power it gives a person, then benevolence, then righteousness, and last come the rules of propriety, which he calls the beginning of disorder. Learning fares no better. The widely learned do not know the Tao, fine words are not sincere, and to think one knows what one does not know is a disease. What he keeps is kindness without a doctrine: the sage casts no one away, and injury is to be repaid with kindness.

  • virtue
  • knowledge
  • sincerity
  • compassion

Power that is not felt

Who is fit to hold power over others? For Laozi it is the one who places himself below them, as rivers and seas lie lower than the streams that feed them.

A ruler who wants to stand above the people must speak as one below them, and then they do not feel his weight. The kingdom cannot be won by effort, and whoever grasps it loses it. Princes in fine robes whose granaries stand empty he calls robbers. He doubts the executioner too, since people who do not fear death are not governed by threats of it. Heaven takes from what has too much and adds to what has too little, and human rulers do the reverse. A good commander strikes his blow and stops, and a great state wins the small ones by lowering itself.

  • governance
  • leadership
  • political authority
  • political philosophy
  • political power
  • law
  • trust
  • war
  • nonviolence

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
81
concepts traced
163
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “humility” and “leadership”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 23 pairings. 51 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
humilityleadership9
political philosophythe way5
humilitytao4
desirepolitical philosophy3
governancetao3
humilitypolitical philosophy3
humilitythe way3
leadershippolitical philosophy3
governancepolitical philosophy2
humilitynon-action2
leadershipnon-action2
non-actionpolitical philosophy2
non-actiontao2
desiregovernance1
desirehumility1
desirenon-action1
desiretao1
governancehumility1
governanceleadership1
governancenon-action1
leadershipthe way1
non-actionthe way1
political philosophytao1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: humility in Tao Te Ching, 24.7%.

Density 0% 24.7%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 6 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearhumilitypolitical philosophytaonon-actionleadershipthe waygovernancedesire
Tao Te Ching24.7%22.2%21%14.8%13.6%13.6%12.3%11.1%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. -400 Tao Te Ching (道德經)

    The book handed down under Laozi's name is also known as the Daodejing, the Classic of the Way and Virtue. Its two parts are read here complete, in the English translation that James Legge, Oxford's first professor of Chinese, published in 1891.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Laozi

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.