PhilosopherIndia

Patañjali

The sage who defined yoga as the stilled mind

1 work · 195 passages grounded

Lifespan
~360–~420
School
Yoga
Wikipedia

The mind

Schools of modern yoga, among them Iyengar Yoga and Ashtanga Vinyasa Yoga, honour Patañjali with invocations and shrines, and teacher trainings set his Yoga Sūtras as required reading. Of the text's 195 sūtras, three concern posture, and the first of them asks only that a posture be steady and comfortable. Most of the rest is about the mind. The second sūtra defines yoga as the stilling of the mind's fluctuations; the third says what remains when they are stilled: the one who sees rests in its own nature.

Patañjali did not invent yoga; the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes him as gathering existing traditions into the text that became their standard. His work stands between two neighbours. From Sāṃkhya, the school that divides the conscious self from active, unconscious nature, the sūtras take their picture of what a person is. The fourth chapter replies to Buddhist thinkers, arguing against the view that an object exists only within a single mind. Philipp Maas, an Indologist, reads that passage as a reply to the idealism of Vasubandhu and therefore places the work in the late fourth or early fifth century. Most scholars, according to Edwin Bryant, a scholar of yoga, date the text earlier, to the first or second century CE. The years on this page follow Maas and are an estimate; nothing about the author's life is on record.

Who he was is disputed. A Patañjali of the second century BCE wrote the Mahābhāṣya, the great commentary on Pāṇini's grammar of Sanskrit, and from the eleventh century, beginning with the commentary of King Bhoja, tradition has treated the two as one man. No known text before Bhoja does so. The scholar Louis Renou showed significant differences of language, grammar and vocabulary between the two works. Most scholars now treat the authors as two people, though James Haughton Woods and Surendranath Dasgupta argued that one author remained possible. The tradition also honours Patañjali as an incarnation of Ādiśeṣa, the serpent on whom Vishnu rests, and praises him in a verse as the sage who cleansed the mind by yoga, speech by grammar and the body by medicine.

For most of their history the sūtras were read through the commentary ascribed to the legendary sage Vyāsa, which, in Maas's argument, was composed together with them as a single book. In the early eleventh century the scholar al-Bīrūnī translated the work into Arabic. According to David Gordon White, a historian of religion, the text then fell into relative obscurity for nearly seven hundred years, until Swami Vivekananda built his Raja Yoga of 1896 around a translation of it.

The method is a path of eight limbs: restraints in conduct and daily observances, posture, breath control, withdrawal of the senses, concentration, meditation and absorption, samādhi. The sūtras name the afflictions that keep the mind's fluctuations going, ignorance first among them. Unlike the Sāṃkhya verses, they name a God, a special self untouched by affliction or action, the teacher even of the ancient teachers, and devotion to him is one of several routes to absorption. The goal is kaivalya, "isolation": the conscious self standing apart from the nature it had taken for itself.

Key concepts

What are the seer and the seen in Patañjali's yoga?

The seer, purusha, is pure awareness: it only sees, and it never changes. The seen is everything else, the body, the senses and the mind too, which exists for the seer's sake. The mind is therefore not the self but an instrument, coloured both by the one who sees and by what it shows, like a clear crystal taking the colour of what lies beside it. Bondage is the seer mistaking that instrument's movements for its own.

What are the three gunas, the strands of nature?

They are the three qualities that everything in nature is woven from: brightness, activity and inertia. A stone, a sense organ and a thought are the same three strands in different proportions, so even the mind belongs to nature and not to the self. The strands never stop shifting and pulling against one another, so nothing made of them, a mood or a body, stays as it is.

What are samskaras, the latent impressions of yoga?

They are the traces every experience and act leaves in the mind, which later return as memories, habits and urges. Memory and impression share one form, so a tendency can lie dormant across years, places and even lives and come back unchanged. Yoga does not erase them by force. It lays down impressions of stillness that grow strong enough to block the old ones, until even those are let go.

Who is Ishvara, the God of the Yoga Sūtras?

Ishvara is a special self, one never touched by the afflictions, by action or by its results. In kind he is a seer like any other, but he was never bound, so the seed of all knowing is unsurpassed in him and he is the teacher even of the most ancient teachers. The sūtras do not make him the goal: devotion to him is one route to absorption, beside the others.

How is Yoga different from Sāṃkhya?

Yoga takes over Sāṃkhya's picture of a person, a conscious self that only watches and an unconscious nature that does all the acting, and its goal of the self standing free. What it adds is a method: a graded discipline of conduct, body, breath and attention for stilling the mind. And unlike the classic Sāṃkhya verses of Īśvarakṛṣṇa, the Yoga Sūtras name a God and make devotion to him one way forward.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

The Watcher Behind the Mind

Who is it that notices a thought arriving? No thought at all, on Patañjali's account, and suffering begins when the watcher takes the mind's movements for itself.

From Sāṃkhya the sūtras take a split through the middle of a person. On one side stands the seer, pure seeing, which never changes. On the other stands everything seen: the body, the senses and the mind itself, all woven from nature's three strands and all existing for the seer's sake. The mind's movements are always known to the seer, the sūtras argue, precisely because the seer does not change. Egoism, the feeling 'I am this', is the two powers taken for one, and the joining of seer and seen is the cause of the pain still to come.

  • self
  • consciousness
  • seer and seen
  • self-awareness
  • identity
  • egoism
  • prakriti
  • misperception
  • suffering
  • awareness

What Every Act Leaves Behind

Why does a person go on doing what they have resolved to stop? Each act, the sūtras answer, leaves a deposit that ripens later as a birth, a span of life and its pleasures and pains.

Patañjali roots action in the afflictions and traces its residue forward. Latent impressions have no beginning, because the wish to go on existing has none. Memory and impression share one form, so a tendency can wait across births, places and times and come back intact, and even the learned cling to life. The remedy is not better karma: good deeds bring joy and bad ones pain, while a yogi's action is neither bright nor dark. Practice works by laying down impressions of stillness strong enough to overpower the old ones.

  • latent impressions
  • karma
  • rebirth
  • memory
  • causality
  • action
  • attachment
  • aversion
  • continuity
  • purification

Practice and Letting Go

Is freedom something a person works toward, or something they stop reaching for? The sūtras demand both at once and will not let either do the job alone.

Stilling, the twelfth sūtra says, comes by practice and dispassion together. Practice is the effort to stay steady; dispassion is mastery over the thirst for anything seen or merely heard of, and its highest form wants nothing even from nature's strands once the self is known. Progress depends on intensity, and absorption is near for those whose commitment burns hottest. Beside the effortful road runs another, surrender to God, which the sūtras list among the daily observances. When powers bring invitations from higher realms, the practitioner is told to meet them without attachment or pride.

  • practice
  • non-attachment
  • dispassion
  • effort
  • steadiness
  • discipline
  • devotion
  • surrender
  • divinity
  • obstacles

A Real World, Always Changing

If everything is in flux, is anything there at all? Change, Patañjali answers, happens to something real, and past and future are no less real than the present.

Against Buddhist thinkers for whom an object exists only within a single mind, the fourth chapter defends a world that is there whether or not anyone looks: the same thing is seen differently by different minds, so thing and mind go separate ways. Every object is nature's three strands in some arrangement, and its qualities rise, settle and wait within it. Past and future qualities exist in their own form, only in another phase of time. External causes do not make nature act; like a farmer opening a channel, they remove what blocks the flow.

  • change
  • transformation
  • time
  • sequence
  • nature
  • gunas
  • elements
  • objectivity
  • other minds
  • metaphysics

By the numbers

works held
1
passages traced
195
concepts traced
206
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “meditation” and “mind”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 24 pairings. 83 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
meditationmind9
meditationsamadhi9
knowledgemeditation6
meditationyoga6
mindperception6
consciousnessmeditation5
consciousnessmind5
knowledgeperception4
liberationmind4
meditationperception4
liberationmeditation3
consciousnessliberation2
consciousnessperception2
consciousnesssamadhi2
consciousnessyoga2
knowledgeliberation2
knowledgemind2
liberationsamadhi2
consciousnessknowledge1
knowledgesamadhi1
liberationyoga1
mindsamadhi1
mindyoga1
perceptionsamadhi1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: meditation in Yoga Sūtras, 31.3%.

Density 0% 31.3%

Concept density per work, chronological A single work. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 26 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearmeditationmindsamadhiliberationconsciousnessyogaknowledgeperception
Yoga Sūtras31.3%16.4%12.3%10.3%8.7%8.7%8.2%7.7%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. Yoga Sūtras (Yogasūtra)

    Four short chapters — on absorption, practice, extraordinary powers and final isolation — read for most of their history through the commentary ascribed to Vyāsa.

    SA
Begin a dialogue with Patañjali

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.