Hindu monkIndia

Swami Vivekananda

The monk for whom serving the poor was worship

4 works · 982 passages grounded

Lifespan
1863–1902
Also known as
Narendranath Datta
Wikipedia

The mind

The Brahmo Samaj, the Hindu reform society founded in Calcutta by Rammohan Roy, worshipped one formless God and condemned the worship of images. It drew educated young Bengalis, and Narendranath Datta, the son of an attorney at the Calcutta High Court, joined it as a student. At the General Assembly's Institution, a Scottish mission college, he read Hume, Kant, Mill and Herbert Spencer, and the reading left him doubtful about religion of any kind. In 1881 he met Ramakrishna, a priest at the temple of the goddess Kali at Dakshineswar, north of the city, who worshipped her in an image and passed into states of ecstasy. The student was disturbed by the image worship and drawn by the man. It took him about four years to accept Ramakrishna as his teacher.

His father died in 1884 and left the family in debt and in lawsuits, and Narendranath gave up a plan to study law in England. After Ramakrishna's death in August 1886 he and a group of young disciples took monastic vows and lived together in a house at Baranagar. From 1890 he walked the length of India as a wandering monk, with a staff and a begging bowl, and what he saw of its poverty stayed in everything he later taught. He took the name Vivekananda in these years.

On 11 September 1893 he spoke at the World's Parliament of Religions in Chicago. In a paper eight days later he told the Parliament that Hinduism did not consist in believing a doctrine but in realising the truth, in experiencing it for oneself. The Parliament made him famous, and he stayed more than three years in the West, giving free classes in New York and lectures in London that a hired stenographer, Josiah Goodwin, took down. They became short books on four roads to freedom: work, devotion, knowledge, and the training of the mind. Each, he argued, leads to the same goal, and a person takes the one that fits their nature.

The goal is the one taught by Advaita Vedanta, the non-dual school: the real self of every person is the infinite itself. Vivekananda drew an ethical conclusion from it. If God is the self of every man and woman, then the poor and the hungry are God in the form nearest to hand, and serving them is worship, no less than prayer. He called this practical Vedanta, and he built an institution on it. On 1 May 1897, back in Calcutta, he founded the Ramakrishna Mission and required its monks to do seva, service to others, which he said Ramakrishna had intended. Its headquarters at Belur Math, on the Hooghly river, still trains monks, and the order runs centres in more than twenty countries outside India.

He died at Belur Math on 4 July 1902, at thirty-nine. Gandhi counted him among the reformers who had cut away the dead wood of Hindu tradition, and Aurobindo Ghose, the nationalist turned yogi, said he had heard Vivekananda's voice in a British jail. His appeal to experience became a rallying cry for Indian nationalism. Scholars have been less sure what he did to Vedanta. The German Indologist Paul Hacker called the modern Hinduism he taught Neo-Hinduism, as a term of reproach, holding it to be a new construction rather than a continuation of tradition. Others trace his reading of Advaita to its Western interpreters, Schopenhauer and his follower Paul Deussen, a German translator of the Upanishads, and ask whether Ramakrishna thought of himself as a Vedantin at all. Recent scholarship warns against overstating how new his teaching was. His birthday, 12 January, is kept in India as National Youth Day.

Key concepts

What does Vivekananda mean by realisation?

Realisation means perceiving the truths of religion directly, for oneself, rather than believing them on someone's word. Vivekananda held that religion is not in books or temples but in this perception, so a person who has only read and argued has not yet got it. He also insisted it can be reached in this life: people still living, he said, have seen the delusion vanish for good.

Why does he teach several yogas instead of one?

Because people differ, and he held that each kind of person can reach the same freedom by a road that suits them. Karma yoga is the road of work done without wanting its rewards, bhakti yoga of love for a personal God, raja yoga of training and concentrating the mind, and jnana yoga of knowledge, recognising that one's self is the infinite. None is a lower road. They differ in where they start, not in where they end.

What is a jivan mukta?

A jivan mukta is someone 'living free': freed while still in the body, not only after death. For Vivekananda this is the aim of the road of knowledge. Such a person goes on living and acting, but pleasure, pain and fear no longer bind them, because they know these for passing appearances. His image is the lotus leaf, which lies on the water and is never wet by it.

What does 'I am He' mean?

'I am He' affirms that the speaker's real self is the infinite itself, God, and not a small and helpless creature. Vivekananda wanted it said and thought day and night in place of 'I am a sinner' or 'I am weak', which he held to be self-hypnosis that rivets one more chain on. He tells of a man in a forest who repeated 'Shivoham', 'I am Shiva', day and night.

If not a devil, who is to blame for evil?

Human beings are, Vivekananda answers, and the verdict carries hope with it. Indian thought, he says, never invented a Satan to explain misery, because it did not believe that souls were created out of nothing. Each person has always been shaping their own future: what someone does today fixes what happens to them tomorrow. Whoever made their own bondage can also unmake it.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Weakness, Not Sin

What is wrong with people, if the self in each of them is the infinite? Vivekananda's answer is weakness, and he counts the habit of calling people sinners among its causes.

The London lectures turn a claim about reality into a diagnosis. If the real self of every person is perfect, then lying, stealing and killing come from a self that has forgotten its strength, and the cure is to remember it. Against preachers who teach children from the start that they are weak and sinful, Vivekananda calls that teaching self-hypnosis, a chain riveted on by repetition. Fear of death goes the same way: it lifts when a person can say that wherever any life goes on, they live.

  • self
  • human nature
  • self-knowledge
  • soul
  • mind
  • freedom

Religion as Something Seen

Can religion be known the way anything else is known? Vivekananda insists that it must be, and that what has not been perceived has not yet been had.

Religion, he told his listeners, is not in books or temples but an actual perception, and only someone who has seen God and the soul for themselves has it. A churchman who can talk by the volume and has not seen is no further on than the materialist. The demand cuts both ways. He held religion and philosophy to answer to reason as science does, and turned the sceptics' logic back on them: whoever calls God a delusion and the world real has applied one argument only where it suits.

  • religion
  • perception
  • knowledge
  • epistemology
  • consciousness
  • metaphysics

One Freedom, Many Roads

If there is one goal, why do people reach for it in such different ways, and are the ways rivals? Vivekananda makes the difference a matter of human nature rather than of truth.

Work done without wanting its fruits, love of a personal God, the training of the mind in concentration, and the knowledge that the self is the infinite are, across his four books, four roads to the same freedom, and a person takes the one that suits them. Every religion, from the crudest myth to the most refined philosophy, is an attempt to get beyond nature, and saint and sinner alike are moving toward the goal. Yet the goal he names is the non-dual one, and religions that keep God apart from the soul are, he says, bound to quarrel.

  • religious pluralism
  • spiritual practice
  • devotion
  • karma
  • liberation
  • vedanta

The World Covered with God

Must someone give up the world to find God? Vivekananda answers that what has to go is a way of seeing the world, not the world itself.

He takes the opening verse of an old Upanishad, that whatever exists is to be covered with the Lord, as the meaning of renunciation. Wealth, family and a long life may all be kept. What is given up is the idea of owning them, and desire, which he names the cause of every misery, loses its sting once it is deified. He refused to call this optimism. The world holds real evil, the wicked see it as a hell, and seeing God in it is a change in the one who looks.

  • renunciation
  • desire
  • non-attachment
  • nonduality
  • suffering

Unselfishness Is God

Why be good, if no God with a rod stands ready to punish? Vivekananda grounds morality in the oneness of every self, and draws demands from it that his listeners found hard.

Morality built on fear, he argued, never grows, and the believer who needs a punishing God has misunderstood why anyone should be good. In Karma Yoga unselfishness simply is God, so that a king on a throne may be in God and a man in rags may not. If every person is oneself, helping the poor is worship and no cause for pride, and condemning the world only weakens it further. Utility cannot carry this weight, he held, because a morality drawn from society lasts only as long as that society.

  • ethics
  • selflessness
  • love
  • nondualism

By the numbers

works held
4
passages traced
982
concepts traced
889
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “liberation” and “self”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 23 pairings. 86 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
liberationself14
mindself14
knowledgeself10
devotionliberation9
liberationspiritual practice9
devotionspiritual practice7
knowledgeliberation7
devotionknowledge6
liberationnon-attachment6
devotionrenunciation5
knowledgespiritual practice5
liberationmind5
liberationrenunciation5
non-attachmentrenunciation5
devotionnon-attachment4
knowledgemind4
knowledgerenunciation3
non-attachmentself2
renunciationspiritual practice2
selfspiritual practice2
knowledgenon-attachment1
mindspiritual practice1
renunciationself1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: devotion in Bhakti-Yoga, 26.8%.

Density 0% 26.8%

Concept density per work, chronological 4 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 95 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearliberationdevotionnon-attachmentrenunciationmindselfspiritual practiceknowledge
Bhakti-Yoga18.6%26.8%2.1%9.3%1%1%11.3%7.2%
Karma-Yoga7.3%2.1%24%12.5%4.2%2.1%2.1%3.1%
Raja Yoga14.2%2.3%2.8%2.8%17.4%10.1%6.9%7.3%
Jnana-Yoga7.5%0.9%0.9%3.5%4.7%13.7%2.8%5.4%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. 1896 Bhakti-Yoga (Bhakti Yoga)

    The devotional counterpart to Karma Yoga, worked out in the same New York winter of classes.

    EN
  2. 1896 Karma-Yoga (Karma Yoga)

    Printed within weeks of the New York classes it records, and the earliest of Vivekananda's yoga books to appear; the later ones turned to devotion, to knowledge and to the training of the mind.

    EN
  3. 1896 Raja Yoga

    Among Vivekananda's four yoga books, this is the one built on a classical text: class lectures on the discipline of the mind, followed by his own translation of Patanjali's Yoga Sutras.

    EN
  4. 1899 Jnana-Yoga (Jnana Yoga)

    Two lecture courses gathered under one title: the London talks of 1896 on maya and practical Vedanta, and seven New York lectures on Sankhya and Vedanta printed only after his death.

    EN
Begin a dialogue with Swami Vivekananda

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.