Human, All Too Human

The book that finished his friendship with Wagner and remade Nietzsche as a "free spirit" — aphorisms that give morality, religion and art a merely human history.

by Friedrich Nietzsche648 passages held

German, the original language

Original title: Menschliches Allzumenschliches Ein Buch Fuer Freie Geister
Original language: German

Report a rights issue

Overview

The break with Richard Wagner is written into every page. Nietzsche had been the composer's disciple and evangelist; by 1876 he was pulling away, and that autumn he sat in Sorrento with Paul Rée, whose cool, naturalistic account of the origins of morality pointed the road he now took. Gone is the grand metaphysics of his first book. In its place come short aphorisms and a chemist's method applied to the "higher" things — morality, religion, metaphysics, art — asking not whether they are true but how they came to be, and finding ordinary, low, human origins where tradition had seen the eternal. He dedicated the book to the memory of Voltaire, timed to the hundredth anniversary of Voltaire's death, a flag planted in the Enlightenment camp. The gesture toward Wagner was the reverse: Nietzsche sent him the book at about the moment Wagner sent him the libretto of Parsifal, and the two never spoke again. It did not sell — a thousand copies printed, roughly a hundred and twenty gone. Yet this is the hinge of his whole career: the philologist and Wagnerian disciple walks out of the book an independent analyst of everything he had once revered, and the aphoristic voice of the great later works is here for the first time.

Key concepts

What does Nietzsche mean by a free spirit?

A free spirit is Nietzsche's name for a mind that has cut itself loose from every inherited faith, master and metaphysical comfort, and can now examine morality, religion and art coldly, owing nothing to anyone. The subtitle calls the whole book one for free spirits. It is less a doctrine than a temperament: intellectual honesty carried to the point where no cherished belief is spared.

What is the chemistry of concepts method?

It is the naturalistic method this book introduces: treat the higher things — morality, religion, metaphysics, art — the way a chemist treats compounds, asking what lowly ingredients they arose from rather than whether they are eternally true. Following Paul Rée, Nietzsche finds vanity, fear and habit where tradition saw the divine. The result is a human history for everything once thought superhuman.

Why is this book called the turning point of his career?

Because he walks in as Wagner's disciple and a metaphysician in the style of his first book, and walks out an independent, cool-eyed analyst of everything he once revered. The grand Schopenhauerian metaphysics is gone. The short aphorism — the voice of all the great later works — is heard here for the first time, in Nietzsche's own register.

Why did he dedicate it to Voltaire?

Nietzsche dedicated the book to the memory of Voltaire and timed it to the hundredth anniversary of Voltaire's death — a deliberate flag planted in the Enlightenment camp. It announces his new allegiance to sceptical, disenchanting reason against Romantic and Wagnerian metaphysics. The gesture mirrors his simultaneous break with Wagner, who received the book just as he sent Nietzsche the Parsifal libretto.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

A Human History of Morality and Art

Not whether morality, religion and art are true, but how they came to be, and the answer finds low, ordinary origins where tradition saw the eternal. Applied like a chemist's method, the question dissolves the aura around everything the age most revered.

In place of his first book's grand metaphysics, Nietzsche adopts Paul Ree's cool, naturalistic account of morality's descent and turns it on the higher things at large. Short aphorisms trace religion, morals and art back to vanity, self-deception and the small mechanics of social life, asking after origin rather than truth. The aim is deflation: what looked eternal turns out to have a merely human genealogy. Dedicated to Voltaire on the centenary of his death, the method plants a flag in the Enlightenment camp and sets loose the suspicion the later books would harden into a system.

psychology
human nature
morality
ethics
self-deception
vanity
social psychology
cultural evolution
secularism
resentment

Enter a dialogue

The Free Spirit Finds His Voice

What does it cost to walk out on everything one revered? The book stages the making of a mind that owes nothing to master or metaphysics, the disciple of Wagner leaving as an independent analyst who thinks against his own former reverence.

The break with Wagner is written into every page: Nietzsche sent the composer the book at about the moment Wagner sent him the Parsifal libretto, and the two never spoke again. The free spirit it announces is a discipline of suspicion turned first upon oneself, prizing intellectual honesty over consolation and self-scrutiny over conformity, testing convictions rather than inheriting them. This is the hinge of his whole career: the aphoristic voice of the great later works speaks here for the first time, no longer beholden to the metaphysics of his youth.

autonomy
authenticity
intellectual honesty
critical thinking
conformity
perspective
rationality

Enter a dialogue

Within this work

passages held: 648
distinct concepts: 788
by passages held, corpus-wide: #40

What this book thinks together

Every arc around the wheel is one concept in this book. A ribbon joins two the text reaches for together, and its width is how many of its passages hold both. Strongest: human nature with psychology.

Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 13 pairings. 126 shared passages in all. 87 weaker pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
Concept	Paired concept	Shared passages
human nature	psychology	25
perception	psychology	15
morality	psychology	13
social psychology	vanity	12
psychology	vanity	10
communication	social psychology	9
human nature	morality	9
aesthetics	perception	8
human nature	social psychology	7
aesthetics	psychology	5
communication	vanity	5
aesthetics	human nature	4
communication	perception	4

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

1873 Aufsätze und Vorreden aus dem Nachlaß
Not a book he wrote but a volume his editors gathered from his early papers — prefaces to books he never actually wrote among them.
DE
1873 On Truth and Lies in a Nonmoral Sense (Über Wahrheit und Lüge im außermoralischen Sinne)
An essay he left in manuscript in 1873; its picture of truth as forgotten metaphor did its real work a century later.
DE
1881 The Dawn of Day (Morgenröte)
The book Nietzsche later marked as the start of his campaign against morality — the least read of the mature works, and the seed of the Genealogy.
DE
1882 The Joyful Wisdom (La Gaya Scienza)
Aphorism 125 gives us the madman and "God is dead"; aphorism 341, the eternal return — the most personal of the mature books.
DEEN
1883 Thus Spake Zarathustra (Also sprach Zarathustra: Ein Buch für Alle und Keinen)
His one work of fiction and his most famous, written across 1883–85; the fourth part he withheld from the public entirely.
DEEN
1889 Twilight of the Idols (Götzendämmerung)
A short, savage précis of his whole philosophy, written in a week in 1888 as his last lucid year ran out.
DE
Beyond Good and Evil (Jenseits Von Gut Und Böse)
The 1886 prelude to his late assault on morality, arguing in the open what Zarathustra had delivered in parable.
DE
Ecce Homo (Ecce Homo: Wie Man Wird Was Man Ist)
His last book, a self-portrait written weeks before the collapse and kept from print by his sister until 1908.
DE
Homer and Classical Philology (Homer Und Die Klassische Philologie)
His inaugural lecture at Basel, given at twenty-four — the philologist's public debut, and already the argument that would raise art above scholarship.
DE
Human, All Too Human (Menschliches Allzumenschliches Ein Buch Fuer Freie Geister) you are here DE
Nietzsche contra Wagner (Nietzsche Kontra Wagner)
A montage of passages taken from his own earlier books, put together at the very end to show he had judged Wagner rightly all along.
DE
The Antichrist (Der Antichrist)
Intended as the first book of the "revaluation of all values" he did not live to finish — his fiercest word on Christianity, held back until 1895.
DE
The Birth of Tragedy or Hellenism and Pessimism (Die Geburt Der Tragödie)
His first book, and the one that cost him his standing among classicists; its discursive prophecy he would spend the next decade outgrowing.
DEEN
The Case of Wagner (Der Fall Wagner)
His settling of accounts with the composer he had idolised, written in the same 1888 burst as Twilight of the Idols.
DE
The Genealogy of Morals (Zur Genealogie Der Moral)
Three treatises, written quickly in 1887 as a "supplement" to Beyond Good and Evil — his most sustained argument and his most studied book.
DEEN
The Will to Power (Der Wille Zur Macht)
The most notorious book under his name, and one he never assembled: his sister and Peter Gast made it from his notebooks after his collapse.
DE
We Philologists (Wir Philologen)
The scholar's turn against his own discipline: notes for an "untimely meditation" on philology that he abandoned around 1875.
DE

— or open another of their works