WorkKarl Marx

On the Jewish Question

Marx's reply to Bruno Bauer: a state can grant Jews equal rights without truly freeing anyone, because real emancipation lies beneath politics, in economic life.

by Karl Marx68 passages held

German, the original language

Original title: Zur Judenfrage
First published: 1844(aged 26)
Original language: German

Report a rights issue

Overview

Bruno Bauer, Marx's former ally among the Young Hegelians, had told Prussia's Jews that they could not honestly ask the Christian state for equal rights while both sides kept their religion: emancipation required the Jew to stop being a Jew and the state to stop being Christian. Marx answered him in a two-part essay in the Deutsch-Französische Jahrbücher in Paris in 1844. Bauer, he argued, had confused two different things. Political emancipation — full civil equality — a state can grant without touching religion at all; the United States proved it, guaranteeing rights to citizens who stayed as devout as ever. What such a state does is push religion into private life, not abolish it, and it leaves untouched the deeper division Marx cared about: the split between the citizen who is nominally equal in public and the isolated, self-interested individual of everyday economic life. Genuine human emancipation would heal that split. Then came the second part, and with it the passage that has shadowed the work ever since: Marx identified practical Judaism with money, trade and self-interest, and made society's release from that spirit the real stake of emancipation. Readers have fought over those pages for a century and a half — some finding plain antisemitism, others a clumsy attack on capitalism reaching for the ugliest currency of its day — and the dispute shows no sign of closing. What is not in dispute is that Marx wrote in support of granting Jews their civil rights.

Key concepts

What was 'the Jewish Question' Marx was answering?

It was the debate over whether Prussia's Jews should receive equal civil rights, sharpened by Bruno Bauer's claim that they could not honestly demand emancipation while remaining religious. Bauer said the Jew must cease being a Jew and the state cease being Christian. Marx's essay answers Bauer, and, whatever its contested second part, argues in favour of granting Jews their rights.

What does Marx mean by 'civil society' here?

The sphere of everyday economic life, of work, trade and competing private interests, where each person acts as an isolated, self-interested individual rather than a citizen. The modern state, Marx argues, lifts equality into a political heaven while leaving this civil society untouched below, so a person can be free as a citizen and unfree as a private, egoistic man.

Why does Marx point to the United States?

America is his proof that a secular state does not abolish religion. The United States guaranteed full civil rights to citizens who stayed as devout as ever, which shows that political emancipation pushes religion into private life rather than ending it. For Marx this exposes the limit of merely political freedom: equal rights leave the deeper unfreedom of economic life in place.

Why does Marx link Judaism to money and trade?

In the essay's disputed second part he identifies practical, everyday Judaism with money, huckstering and self-interest, and makes society's release from that spirit the real content of emancipation. Readers have fought for over a century over whether this is antisemitism, a clumsy attack on capitalism reaching for the ugliest currency of its day, or both. The dispute remains open.

What does Marx mean by 'species-being'?

It is his term for the human being as a communal, social creature, whole and at one with others, the opposite of the isolated egoist of civil society. Political emancipation, Marx argues, splits a person in two: an abstract citizen in the political sphere and a private individual in the real one. Human emancipation would reunite them, restoring people to their species-life.

Themes of the book

What this book returns to, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of the text each one occupies.

Money and the Limits of Emancipation

Winning equal civil rights leaves untouched a deeper unfreedom — the self-interested, money-driven life the modern state pushes into private hands. What would free people, and not just citizens?

Answering Bruno Bauer, Marx separates political emancipation, which a secular state grants without abolishing religion, from the human emancipation that would heal the split between the public citizen and the private, egoistic individual. In the contested second part he ties the spirit of that private life to money, trade and huckstering, and makes society's release from it the real stake — a polemic later readers have taken as antisemitism, as a crude swipe at capitalism, or both. He nonetheless argued for granting Jews their civil rights.

money
critique
ideology
political emancipation
religion

Enter a dialogue

Within this work

passages held: 68
distinct concepts: 122
by passages held, corpus-wide: #592

What this book thinks together

The wheel takes this book’s leading concepts and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more of its passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “civil society” and “political emancipation”.

Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 25 pairings. 77 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
Concept	Paired concept	Shared passages
civil society	political emancipation	9
human emancipation	political emancipation	8
civil society	human rights	7
civil society	individualism	6
political emancipation	religion	6
human rights	individualism	5
human rights	religious freedom	5
civil society	religion	4
political emancipation	religious freedom	4
alienation	civil society	3
human rights	political emancipation	3
individualism	political emancipation	3
alienation	human emancipation	2
alienation	human rights	2
alienation	individualism	2
civil society	human emancipation	2
civil society	religious freedom	2
alienation	political emancipation	1
alienation	religion	1
human emancipation	individualism	1
human emancipation	religion	1
human emancipation	religious freedom	1
individualism	religion	1
individualism	religious freedom	1
religion	religious freedom	1

Works held

The author's work in order, this book marked in place. Your-language title first, the original beneath it where the two differ; side chips show which full texts are held.

1844 On the Jewish Question (Zur Judenfrage) you are here DE
1845 The Holy Family, or Critique of Critical Criticism (Die heilige Familie oder Kritik der kritischen Kritik)
Overwhelmingly Marx's despite the shared title page, and aimed squarely at Bruno Bauer's circle. It sits on the hinge between the Young Hegelian quarrels Marx was leaving and the historical materialism he was about to work out.
DE
1848 The Communist Manifesto (Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei)
Commissioned to a deadline as revolution gathered in 1848, and the most public thing Marx ever put his name to — the opposite pole from the manuscripts he left unfinished in drawers. It states in a few pages the view of history his longer works spent decades grounding.
DE
1849 Wage Labour and Capital (Lohnarbeit und Kapital)
An early, popular run at the economics Marx would spend the next twenty years perfecting. Engels reissued it in 1891 with the term "labour-power" set where Marx had written "labour" — repairing it with a concept that arrived only later.
DE
1852 The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (Der achtzehnte Brumaire des Louis Bonaparte)
Marx as historian and political analyst rather than economist or agitator: a close reading of a single French coup, written for a New York émigré paper in 1852. It handed later Marxism its theory of the state's independence from the classes beneath it.
DE
1867 Capital: A Critique of Political Economy (Das Kapital)
The work of Marx's maturity and the one book of his economics he saw into print. Volume one appeared in 1867; Engels assembled volumes two and three from the unfinished manuscripts after Marx died, in 1885 and 1894.
DE
1888 Theses on Feuerbach (Thesen über Feuerbach)
Eleven notebook jottings, not an argument built for readers but private markers Marx set down in 1845 and Engels rescued in 1888. They register the moment he broke with Feuerbach and put human practice at the centre of his thinking.
DE
1898 Value, Price and Profit (Lohn, Preis und Profit)
A pair of lectures rather than a book — Marx answering a fellow member at the General Council of the International in 1865, in English. His daughter Eleanor found the manuscript and published it in 1898, and it became the shortest way into the economics of Capital.
DE
1927 Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right (Zur Kritik der Hegelschen Rechtsphilosophie. Kritik des Hegelschen Staatsrechts)
His earliest sustained work, written at twenty-five before he had read a page of political economy: a reckoning with the German idealism he had been raised inside. Its published introduction announced the proletariat; the manuscript behind it waited eighty years for a reader.
DE
1939 Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Grundrisse der Kritik der politischen Ökonomie)
Written a decade before Capital and unknown for almost a century: the notebooks Marx filled to clarify his own thinking, rediscovered only after 1953 and central to the Marx revival that came with the New Left.
DE

— or open another of their works