EsotericistGermany

Rudolf Steiner

The philosopher of freedom who claimed to see the spirit

11 works · 2,879 passages grounded

The mind

In 1882 Joseph Kürschner, the editor of a large popular series of German classics, needed someone to edit Goethe's writings on natural science, and on the advice of Karl Julius Schröer, the professor of German literature at the Vienna Technische Hochschule, gave the job to a student of twenty-one. Rudolf Steiner, the son of a railway telegraphist, had come to Vienna on a scholarship to study mathematics and the sciences, and left in 1883 without a degree. The Goethe work held him for fifteen years, from 1890 inside the Goethe Archive at Weimar, and handed him his question. Goethe had looked for the idea inside the plant itself; when he sketched his archetypal plant for Schiller, Schiller told him it was an idea, not something he had seen. Steiner sided with Goethe, and the claim he spent his life defending grew from that choice: thinking, watched closely, is not a screen between us and the world but the place where we meet it.

The universities taught the opposite. Kant's followers held that the mind knows only its own representations, never the world behind them. Steiner answered them in his doctoral thesis, Die Grundfrage der Erkenntnistheorie, which passed at Rostock in 1891 with the lowest grade: in thinking we produce the content ourselves and can follow it to the end, so there at least we know something from the inside. The Philosophy of Freedom (1894) built an ethics on that ground. An act is free, it argues, when it grows out of an idea the person has grasped for themselves, not out of a command, a duty in Kant's sense, or a drive. Eduard von Hartmann, the philosopher of the unconscious, sent his copy back covered in objections, and Robert von Zimmermann, whose lectures Steiner had attended in Vienna, called it a theoretical anarchism outdoing Nietzsche. Of a thousand copies, about four hundred had sold by 1907.

Through the 1890s Steiner wrote as a freethinker, invoking Stirner, Nietzsche and the Darwinist Ernst Haeckel. He published a book in Nietzsche's praise in 1895. In Berlin from 1897 he edited the Magazin für Literatur, which lost readers when he backed Zola in the Dreyfus affair, and from 1899 he taught at a workers' school run by the socialists.

The turn came in 1900, when Count and Countess von Brockdorff invited him to lecture at their Theosophical Library in Berlin, first on Nietzsche, then on the mystics. In 1902 he became General Secretary of the German Section of the Theosophical Society. His autobiography, left unfinished at his death, calls the 1890s a testing of his soul and says his development around 1900 rested on an inward encounter with Christ's death and resurrection, which he called the Mystery of Golgotha. He now held that a trained mind could perceive a spiritual world as exactly as the senses perceive the physical one, and named the result spiritual science. Theosophy (1904) described the human being passing through repeated lives, How to Know Higher Worlds printed the exercises, and An Outline of Occult Science (1910) set out a history of the cosmos. Steiner called The Philosophy of Freedom the philosophical basis of all of it. Scholars still disagree whether the turn was a break or a continuation of his earlier thought; the historian of religion Helmut Zander stresses continuity. No scientific body has accepted the spiritual findings.

When Annie Besant, the Theosophical Society's president, promoted the young Jiddu Krishnamurti as the vehicle of a coming world teacher, Steiner refused, and the society dissolved its German Section in March 1913. His followers had already founded the Anthroposophical Society, taking the word from a book by Zimmermann. At Dornach, near Basel, they built the first Goetheanum in wood.

After the war came the most durable work. In September 1919 a school opened in Stuttgart for the children of workers at Emil Molt's Waldorf-Astoria cigarette factory, and Steiner's lectures founded anthroposophical medicine and, in 1924, biodynamic farming. Adolf Hitler attacked him in print in 1921, and in 1922 people rushed the stage at his Munich lecture. On New Year's Eve 1922 the Goetheanum burned, and police reports pointed to arson. He died in Dornach on 30 March 1925, having given some six thousand lectures.

Those lectures carry his most contested legacy. They contain passages on race. In 2000 a commission set up by the Anthroposophical Society in the Netherlands reported that sixteen such passages, in some 89,000 printed pages, would be called discriminatory today, though it found no racial theory in the work. The historian Peter Staudenmaier, a critic of the movement, finds antisemitic and philosemitic views in Steiner side by side. Academic philosophers still rarely discuss The Philosophy of Freedom.

Key concepts

What does Steiner mean by spiritual science?

A knowledge of a spiritual world that, he held, is gained by observation as exact as the natural sciences use, not by belief or revelation. Its instrument is a trained mind whose sleeping faculties have been developed by exercise. He wanted the method, not his own authority, to carry the claims, and he rooted it in the theory of knowledge of the 1890s: if thinking can be observed, perception can be extended.

Why does everything in Steiner start from observing one's own thinking?

Because thinking is the one thing we both produce and can watch, so it is the one place where knower and known are not separated. Every other object arrives from outside; thinking is known from within. That single case carries both halves of his work: it answers Kant's limits in the theory of knowledge, and it becomes the model for the exact inner observation his later spiritual science claimed to extend.

Is ethical individualism just doing whatever one pleases?

No: it is the reverse of caprice. A deed done from mood or appetite is driven, and Steiner counts a drive as unfree as a command. A free deed grows out of an idea the person has grasped through their own thinking and so understands. What makes it individual is that no general rule dictated it; what keeps it from arbitrariness is that it is seen through.

What did Steiner take from Goethe's way of studying nature?

The conviction that the idea of a living thing lies in the thing and can be found there by watching it change. Goethe looked for the plant's law in the plant's own metamorphosis rather than in a separate realm of concepts. Steiner made that method the pattern for knowing in general and, against Schiller's objection, held that such an idea is genuinely perceived, not merely added by the mind.

What is the threefold social order?

Steiner's proposal, made public in 1919, that a society runs three different kinds of life and must not run them as one. Cultural life, meaning schools, universities and the arts, governs itself in freedom; rights belong to a democratic state where all are equal; the economy is run by associations of producers, traders and consumers bound by fraternity. Liberty, equality and fraternity each get a sphere of their own.

What does Steiner mean by the Mystery of Golgotha?

His name for the death and resurrection of Christ, taken as a real event and not a symbol. The ancient mysteries, on his account, staged a death and awakening in secret for a chosen few; at Golgotha that event happened once, openly, in history. He placed an inward encounter with it at the centre of his own development around 1900, which is why the turn of that year was, for him, more than a change of audience.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Thinking, where the world is met

Is the mind shut inside its own pictures, or is there one activity in which it knows the world from the inside? Everything Steiner later claimed rests on his answer that thinking, watched closely, is that place.

Kant's followers held that we know only our representations, never what stands behind them. Steiner's reply grants them the given: the world first arrives as a picture with no connections in it. The connections are supplied in thinking, an activity we produce ourselves and can follow to its end, and knowing is the act that joins the two halves. Knowledge therefore completes reality rather than copying it, and the idea Goethe looked for inside the plant is really there to be found. The Rostock thesis that first argued this passed with the lowest grade.

  • epistemology
  • perception
  • thinking
  • thought
  • concepts
  • observation
  • knowledge
  • idealism
  • experience
  • reason

Freedom as the individual's own deed

Can a person act freely at all, or is every deed driven by laws as fixed as nature's? Steiner ties the answer to knowing: a deed is free only when its reason has been seen through by the one who acts.

Most ethics hands the reason for action to something outside the agent, whether a command, a duty in Kant's sense or a drive. The Philosophy of Freedom refuses all three and calls what remains ethical individualism, in which a free act grows out of an idea the person has grasped for themselves. Its ground is the theory of knowledge, since thinking is the one activity we can follow to its end. Hartmann saw an unbridgeable gulf between the two halves, Zimmermann a theoretical anarchism outdoing Nietzsche; Steiner later called the book the philosophical basis of everything he taught.

  • freedom
  • free will
  • ethics
  • individuality
  • intuition
  • selfhood
  • self-consciousness
  • human nature

A science of the spirit

Can a trained mind perceive a spiritual world as exactly as the senses perceive a physical one? From around 1900 Steiner held that it can, and he asked to be judged as a scientist of that world rather than a believer in it.

Spiritual science, as Steiner named it, was meant to extend the method of the 1890s rather than abandon it: the same exact observation, turned on what he held the senses cannot reach. Theosophy describes the human being in nine members, and An Outline of Occult Science a history of the cosmos through states he calls Saturn, Sun and Moon. Readers objected that other sciences prove their claims while this one merely states them, and he rewrote the Outline's first chapter to answer them. Whether the turn broke with his philosophy or continued it is still disputed, and no scientific body has accepted its findings.

  • spiritual perception
  • spiritual knowledge
  • spiritual beings
  • cosmology
  • spirit
  • metaphysics
  • nature
  • consciousness

Schooling the one who knows

If higher knowledge depends on faculties now asleep, what must a person become before they can wake them? Steiner puts character ahead of vision, which makes his path a discipline before it is a doctrine.

The exercises Steiner printed for anyone to read begin with reverence, inner calm and the patient watching of things that grow and wither, and they set a rule: each step toward hidden truths is to be matched by three toward a better character. Occult schooling had always been kept for a few; he published it and answered the charge of hoarded knowledge by putting the method in every reader's hands. He also named its danger, a personality whose thinking, feeling and willing come apart, met at the threshold as a frightening being.

  • spiritual development
  • initiation
  • spiritual practice
  • self-knowledge
  • soul
  • desire
  • emotion
  • mysticism

One spirit through many lives

What makes a person this person, if heredity explains only the body? Steiner answers with repeated earthly lives, and he offered the answer as an argument drawn from biology rather than as consolation.

A body inherits its shape from its ancestors; a spirit, Steiner argues, is a species of its own, so its biography can be explained only by an earlier life of that same spirit. Theosophy follows the soul after death through a soul world and a spirit land and back to earth. The same frame governs his reading of Christianity: the ancient mysteries had staged a death and awakening in secret for a few, and in his account the life and death of Jesus brought that event into history once, openly. He called it the Mystery of Golgotha.

  • reincarnation
  • afterlife
  • human development
  • embodiment
  • individuality
  • soul
  • religion
  • spirituality

By the numbers

works held
11
passages traced
2,879
concepts traced
1,782
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “epistemology” and “perception”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 28 pairings. 86 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
epistemologyperception97
consciousnessperception39
consciousnessepistemology32
epistemologyknowledge24
consciousnesscosmology21
cosmologyperception17
knowledgeperception17
consciousnessspiritual development16
knowledgemysticism16
perceptionsoul15
perceptionspiritual development15
epistemologyspiritual development14
epistemologymysticism13
consciousnesssoul12
cosmologyepistemology9
cosmologyknowledge8
mysticismspiritual development8
knowledgespiritual development7
consciousnessknowledge6
cosmologysoul6
cosmologyspiritual development6
soulspiritual development6
mysticismsoul5
consciousnessmysticism4
cosmologymysticism2
epistemologysoul2
knowledgesoul2
mysticismperception2

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: epistemology in Die Grundfrage der Erkenntnistheorie, 75.7%.

Density 0% 75.7%

Concept density per work, chronological 11 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 85 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearepistemologyperceptionknowledgemysticismspiritual developmentconsciousnesscosmologysoul
Die Grundfrage der Erkenntnistheorie75.7%14.6%13.6%0%0%9.7%0%0%
The Philosophy of Freedom24.9%28.8%7.3%0.3%0%7.1%0%0%
Friedrich Nietzsche, Fighter for Freedom11.9%2.5%6.3%0.6%0%1.3%0%0%
Goethe's World View18.7%18.3%3.6%2.4%0%0.4%0%0%
Mystics of the Renaissance and Their Relation to Modern Thought21.6%6.1%19.6%29.1%2%5.4%3.4%0.7%
Christianity as Mystical Fact6.9%1.1%9.8%27%8%1.1%5.7%14.9%
How to Know Higher Worlds5.8%9.9%6.8%1%26.4%6.5%0.7%1%
Theosophy13.3%15.8%7.5%0.4%8.2%5%0.7%24.4%
An Outline of Occult Science14.2%11.3%4.6%1.2%8.7%15.9%21.5%3.4%
The Spiritual Guidance of Man and of Mankind1.2%0%2.4%0%4.7%4.7%17.6%2.4%
The Threefold Commonwealth0.3%0%0.3%0%0%0.3%0%0%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

EARLY — GOETHE & THE THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE

  1. 1891 lit. The Fundamental Question of Epistemology, with Special Reference to Fichte's Wissenschaftslehre Die Grundfrage der Erkenntnistheorie (Die Grundfrage der Erkenntnistheorie mit besonderer Rücksicht auf Fichte's Wissenschaftslehre)

    A doctoral thesis and the groundwork for The Philosophy of Freedom, though most readers know it only through the 1892 book that absorbed it.

    DE

MIDDLE — FREEDOM & THE FREETHINKER

  1. 1894 The Philosophy of Freedom (Die Philosophie der Freiheit)

    The philosophical centre of Steiner's work, written in his Weimar years before any theosophy, and the book he kept sending later readers back to.

    DE
  2. 1895 Friedrich Nietzsche, Fighter for Freedom (Friedrich Nietzsche, ein Kämpfer gegen seine Zeit)

    Written between The Philosophy of Freedom and the Goethe book, while Steiner still counted himself among Nietzsche's allies and before his dealings with the Nietzsche Archive turned sour.

    DE
  3. 1897 Goethe's World View (Goethes Weltanschauung)

    The last book of Steiner's Weimar years and the summing-up of his work as Goethe's scientific editor; The Philosophy of Freedom supplied its theory of knowledge.

    DE

THEOSOPHICAL — SPIRITUAL SCIENCE & INITIATION

  1. 1901 Mystics of the Renaissance and Their Relation to Modern Thought (Die Mystik im Aufgange des neuzeitlichen Geisteslebens)

    The first book to come out of Steiner's lectures for the theosophists, still written in the voice of the naturalist philosopher of the 1890s; Christianity as Mystical Fact followed from the next course.

    EN
  2. 1902 Christianity as Mystical Fact (Das Christentum als mystische Tatsache und die Mysterien des Altertums)

    The book that marks Steiner's turn from philosophy to esoteric Christianity, given first as lectures to the Berlin theosophists in the months before he became their leader.

    EN
  3. 1904 How to Know Higher Worlds (Wie erlangt man Erkenntnisse der höheren Welten?)

    The practical companion to Theosophy: that book describes what the trained seer claims to see, this one the training that is meant to lead there.

    DE
  4. 1904 Theosophy (Theosophie)

    Begun two years after Steiner took charge of the German theosophists, and the systematic foundation that his later accounts of initiation and cosmic evolution build on.

    DE
  5. 1910 An Outline of Occult Science (Die Geheimwissenschaft im Umriß)

    The fullest single statement of Steiner's cosmology, begun inside the theosophical movement and revised under anthroposophy through four prefaces from 1909 to 1925.

    DE
  6. 1911 The Spiritual Guidance of Man and of Mankind (Die geistige Führung des Menschen und der Menschheit)

    Steiner's second book on the figure of Christ, nine years after Christianity as Mystical Fact, and one that carries the account far deeper into esoteric claims.

    EN

LATE — ANTHROPOSOPHY & THE SOCIAL QUESTION

  1. 1919 The Threefold Commonwealth (Die Kernpunkte der sozialen Frage in den Lebensnotwendigkeiten der Gegenwart und Zukunft)

    Composed for the months after the German revolution, and Steiner's chief written statement on society; it reached English readers within a few years as The Threefold Commonwealth.

    DEEN
Begin a dialogue with Rudolf Steiner

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.