A Science That Cannot Be Shown
How do you teach a method whose evidence happens only in private, between two people? The lectures answer by turning the audience's doubts into part of the lesson.
Medical students are used to seeing the specimen; psychoanalysis, Freud warns, can show them nothing, and their training will make them its opponents. What it offers instead is a conversation governed by one rule: say everything that comes to mind. That rule runs into resistance, the same force that keeps wishes out of awareness, pictured as a watchman between a crowded hall and a drawing room. And it produces transference, the patient's borrowed love and hate for the doctor, which became the instrument of cure once hypnosis had been abandoned.
- psychoanalysis
- methodology
- resistance
- transference
- psychotherapy
- interpretation
- unconscious motivation
Enter a dialogue
- You opened your first lecture by advising your audience not to come back. Why warn listeners off a subject you wanted them to learn?
- The unconscious, in your image, is a crowded hall beside the drawing room of consciousness, with a watchman between. Who is he once treatment begins?
- A patient who sincerely wants to be cured fights the treatment at every step. How can someone resist the very help they came for?
- Patients come to love or hate their doctor with a force nothing in the treatment explains. Where do such feelings come from, if not from the doctor?
- You began by treating patients under hypnosis and later gave it up. What did hypnosis hide that the new method brought into view?