CommentatorIndia

Buddhaghosa

The commentator whose reading became the Theravāda's own

10 works · 17,872 passages grounded

Lifespan
~370–~450
School
Theravada
Wikipedia

The mind

Early in the fifth century, the explanations that told a monk in Sri Lanka what the Buddha's discourses meant were written in Sinhala, the island's own language. The discourses themselves were in Pāli, the scriptural language of the Theravāda, the school of the elders. The commentaries had been built up over centuries at the Mahāvihāra, the great monastery of Anurādhapura, and a monk who knew no Sinhala could not use them. Buddhaghosa, an Indian monk who came to that monastery, put them into Pāli. In the opening verses of his commentary on the middle-length discourses he says what he did: he took away the Sinhala, set the substance in the language of the scriptures, dropped what was repeated, and kept to the teaching of the Mahāvihāra's elders. None of the Sinhala originals survives; scholars know them only from quotations in the Pāli commentaries.

The monastery had reason to want its reading fixed. The Abhayagiri, a second great monastery in the same city, had broken away in the first century BCE and is thought to have been more open to Mahāyāna teachings than the Mahāvihāra. Faxian, a Chinese pilgrim who stayed on the island early in the fifth century, counted five thousand monks at the Abhayagiri and three thousand at the Mahāvihāra. An older manual of the path also circulated, the Vimuttimagga of the teacher Upatissa, and the Indian scholar P. V. Bapat argued that Buddhaghosa wrote some paragraphs of his own with that book and the Abhayagiri in mind.

Of his life, his own books record little. Their closing verses name the elders who asked for each, and two add a memory of India: the elder who asked for the commentary on the numbered discourses had lived with him at Kāñcī, today's Kanchipuram in south India; the one who asked for the middle-length commentary, at a place called Mayūradūtapaṭṭana. The fuller story belongs to the tradition. The Cūḷavaṃsa, a Sri Lankan chronicle continued around the thirteenth century, tells that he was born a Brahmin near Bodh Gaya, where the Buddha attained awakening, mastered the Vedas, lost a debate to the monk Revata and joined the order. Revata sent him to the island. There, it says, the elders tested him with two verses before they would open their commentaries, and he answered with a whole book; deities hid it twice, he wrote it out again each time, and the three copies agreed. Historians date his arrival to the reign of King Mahānāma of Anurādhapura, in the first decades of the century. Scholars such as Oskar von Hinüber, a German Indologist, think he came from the south of India, and that the chronicle moved his birthplace closer to the places of the Buddha's life. His name means "voice of the Buddha".

The book in that story is The Path of Purification (Visuddhimagga). It takes one verse in which the Buddha says how a person untangles the tangle within and without, and builds the whole path from it in three parts: sīla, moral conduct; samādhi, concentration, trained on forty subjects of meditation; and paññā, understanding. The path climbs through seven stages of purification; the last five fall in the chapters on understanding. Its claim is that what a person takes for a self is a run of bodily and mental events, each arising from conditions and passing, and that seeing this clearly, stage by stage, is what sets the mind free.

His commentaries tell the occasion of each discourse, gloss its words one by one, and send the reader back to this book whenever meditation comes up. Maria Heim, a scholar of religion at Amherst College, argues that he treated the Buddha's words as beyond measure, so that explanation could always go further. The tradition credits him with commentaries on the Abhidhamma, the scriptures' analysis of mind and matter, and on parts of the Minor Collection; modern scholars accept the Visuddhimagga and the four commentaries on the main collections as his and debate the rest.

The Mahāvihāra won. King Parākramabāhu I, who ruled from 1153 to 1186, brought the island's monks under its leadership, and monks from Southeast Asia came to Sri Lanka for its ordination. Since at least the twelfth century, scholars hold, Buddhaghosa's readings have been the Theravāda's orthodox understanding of its scriptures. In the twentieth century the Visuddhimagga became a main source of the insight-meditation movement, and some modern monks, Bhikkhu Sujato and Thanissaro Bhikkhu among them, argue that its account of concentration departs from the discourses it explains.

Key concepts

What is a commentary, and what does Buddhaghosa's add to the discourses?

A commentary is a running explanation laid beside a scripture: it tells why a discourse was spoken, explains its words one by one and settles what a hard line means. Buddhaghosa built his from the older Sinhala explanations kept at the Mahāvihāra in Sri Lanka, set them into Pāli, the language of the scriptures, and dropped what was repeated. A monk reading them meets each discourse already explained.

What are dhammas, the pieces body and mind break into?

Dhammas are the smallest events that analysis finds in body and mind, each known by a mark of its own: hardness for the earth element, the meeting of mind and object for contact, the pleasant or painful tone of an experience for feeling. A person or a tree is a name for many such events arising together. The dhammas are what is really there, and each lasts only a moment before the next arises.

What are the three marks every event carries?

Impermanence, suffering and the absence of a self are, for Buddhaghosa, true of every conditioned event without exception. A feeling, for instance, arises, changes and fades, so it is impermanent. Because it cannot be held, it cannot finally satisfy, which is what suffering means here. And because no one owns or controls it, it is not a self. Insight is seeing these three directly, not believing them.

What is rebirth-linking consciousness?

It is the first moment of mind in a new life, the link between one existence and the next. On Buddhaghosa's account the last moment of mind in a dying person ceases, and this new moment arises in its place, shaped by the deeds of the life before. Nothing travels from one to the other: the new moment is neither the same as the old nor wholly other, because it would not exist without it.

What are the four boundless states?

They are four attitudes trained until they reach every being without limit: loving-kindness, the wish that others be well; compassion, the wish that they be free of suffering; gladness at their good fortune; and equanimity, an even mind toward all. Buddhaghosa sets out each as a meditation with its own method and warns of the feeling that only imitates it, as clinging affection imitates kindness.

What is nibbāna for Buddhaghosa?

Nibbāna is the ending of craving, hatred and delusion, and with them of the round of rebirth. It is the one thing in his analysis that does not arise from conditions, so it neither begins nor passes away. Buddhaghosa denies that it is a mere nothing: it is real, he argues, and is known directly by the mind that has finished the path, though no conditioned thing can describe it.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

A Voice Not His Own

A commentator who claims to add nothing still decides what every line means. How far may explanation go before it becomes a new teaching, and whose authority does it then carry?

He presented his work as handing on, never inventing: the island's Sinhala commentaries set in the scriptures' own language, the repetitions dropped, the reading of the Mahāvihāra's elders kept. Yet his explanations gloss a discourse word by word, say why it was spoken and send the reader on to the path of meditation, so the Buddha's words arrive already read. He treated those words, a modern scholar argues, as beyond measure, so that explaining them could always go further. Fidelity and that open end pull against each other in every page.

  • teaching
  • interpretation
  • textual interpretation
  • scriptural interpretation
  • religious authority
  • language
  • classification
  • knowledge
  • Buddhist teaching

Rebirth With No One Reborn

Nothing passes from one life to the next, and yet the next life comes from this one. How deeds can bind a future when no self carries them across is the knot he keeps working.

Against anyone who sets a lasting self inside body and mind, he reads a person as a run of bodily and mental events, each arising from conditions and passing away. Death is one more such event, and the consciousness that opens the next life arises from it without anything crossing over, as an echo answers a sound or a seal leaves its print in wax. Because the later arises from the earlier, deeds bear fruit with no doer standing behind them, and responsibility outlives the self it was supposed to need.

  • rebirth
  • karma
  • non-self
  • aggregates
  • consciousness
  • death
  • causation
  • conditionality
  • dependent origination
  • intention
  • moral responsibility
  • time

Fires That Can Be Put Out

Anger, greed and pride arise in every untrained mind, and they feel like the self speaking. Can each be met by its own opposite until it stops arising at all?

Not suppression but replacement is what he asks of anger and desire, and he gives the replacements as exact procedures. Kindness is first wished to oneself, then to a friend, a stranger and an enemy, until the barriers between the four break down and it falls on all alike. Compassion, gladness at another's good fortune and an even mind follow the same road. Behind the method stands a claim: these states are habits of a mind with no owner, so none of them is fixed character.

  • defilements
  • anger
  • craving
  • attachment
  • conceit
  • desire
  • sensual desire
  • loving-kindness
  • compassion
  • equanimity
  • sense restraint
  • mental cultivation
  • non-attachment

Freedom Seen Clearly

What is a person freed into when the path is finished? His answer refuses both a heaven to be reached and a blank where someone used to be.

Freedom, for him, is neither a place nor a self perfected but the end of craving, and it is reached by seeing: impermanence, suffering and the absence of a self in every event of body and mind, seen until nothing hides them any longer. Calm prepares the seeing and cannot replace it. Against those who call nibbāna a mere nothing, he argues that it is real though nothing conditioned describes it. Between the ordinary person and the one who has finished lie stages, beginning with stream-entry, each marked by what it has let go.

  • liberation
  • nibbana
  • nirvana
  • cessation
  • arahantship
  • insight
  • insight meditation
  • wisdom
  • four noble truths
  • impermanence
  • suffering
  • stream-entry
  • awakening
  • concentration
  • right view

By the numbers

works held
10
passages traced
17,872
concepts traced
4,090
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “karma” and “rebirth”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 28 pairings. 85 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
karmarebirth408
liberationmeditation247
meditationmindfulness246
abhidhammaclassification208
liberationrebirth172
consciousnessrebirth143
abhidhammaconsciousness123
consciousnessmeditation111
consciousnesskarma98
karmaliberation91
meditationrebirth89
karmameditation75
liberationmindfulness74
classificationconsciousness59
classificationmeditation40
classificationrebirth32
abhidhammakarma31
abhidhammameditation29
abhidhammarebirth27
consciousnessliberation27
consciousnessmindfulness22
classificationkarma20
classificationliberation13
mindfulnessrebirth10
classificationmindfulness9
abhidhammamindfulness7
abhidhammaliberation4
karmamindfulness4

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: abhidhamma in Pañcappakaraṇa-aṭṭhakathā, 31.8%.

Density 0% 31.8%

Concept density per work, chronological 10 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 76 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearmeditationliberationkarmarebirthabhidhammaconsciousnessclassificationmindfulness
The Expositor12%3%9.5%4.5%18.3%14.3%13.1%2.1%
Manorathapūraṇī11.9%11.4%9.5%7.9%0.4%1.3%0.5%3.1%
Pañcappakaraṇa-aṭṭhakathā5.4%6.8%6.6%9.3%31.8%8.6%16.1%0.4%
Papañcasūdanī12.5%9%6.6%5.7%0.3%1.9%1.3%5.4%
The Illustrator of Ultimate Meaning14.2%8.3%9.1%4.7%0%1.6%2.5%2.5%
Paramatthajotikā II7.6%12.6%5%6%0%0.3%0.9%3.2%
The Dispeller of Delusion14.8%5.4%10.3%9.1%7.1%10.3%8%7.9%
Sāratthappakāsinī10%11.4%6.3%6.7%0.1%2.5%1.3%5.9%
Sumaṅgalavilāsinī11.7%7.7%6.4%6%0.4%1.8%1.7%6.4%
The Path of Purification27.5%6.5%6%6.9%1%8.8%4.3%5.3%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. Manorathapūraṇī

    The last of his four commentaries on the collections of discourses: its closing verses name it the Manorathapūraṇī, "fulfiller of the wish", because it completed his wish to explain them all.

    PI
  2. Pañcappakaraṇa-aṭṭhakathā

    Five commentaries gathered as one work, ascribed to Buddhaghosa, completing the explanation of the Abhidhamma that the Aṭṭhasālinī and the Sammohavinodanī begin.

    PI
  3. Papañcasūdanī

    Written for a monk Buddhaghosa had once lived with in a port town, probably in South India, and the home of his reading of the mindfulness discourse.

    PI
  4. Paramatthajotikā II

    Ascribed to Buddhaghosa by tradition and doubted by modern scholars, a commentary that explains each discourse of the Suttanipāta by first asking what occasioned it.

    PI
  5. Sāratthappakāsinī

    Made for the elder Jotipāla, and home of the "dry insight" gloss on the Susīma discourse that is still argued over.

    PI
  6. Sumaṅgalavilāsinī

    Begins with history, the council that first recited the texts, before explaining the long discourses, the first collection in the canon's order.

    PI
  7. The Dispeller of Delusion (Sammohavinodanī)

    Explains the Vibhaṅga, the Abhidhamma's second book: the middle of the three commentaries ascribed to Buddhaghosa, between the Aṭṭhasālinī and the one on the five remaining books.

    PI
  8. The Expositor (Aṭṭhasālinī)

    The first of the three Abhidhamma commentaries ascribed to Buddhaghosa, said by a Sri Lankan chronicle to have been written in India, before he crossed to the island.

    PI
  9. The Illustrator of Ultimate Meaning (Paramatthajotikā I)

    The smaller of two commentaries sharing one name, both ascribed to Buddhaghosa: this one explains the nine recitations that open the Minor Collection.

    PI
  10. The Path of Purification (Visuddhimagga)

    His one treatise rather than a commentary: the book his commentaries on the long and middle-length discourses send the reader to whenever meditation comes up.

    PI
Begin a dialogue with Buddhaghosa

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.