PhilosopherPersia

Avicenna

Thinker of borrowed being and the floating man

11 works · 1,708 passages grounded

Lifespan
~980–1037
School
Falsafa
Also known as
Ibn Sina
Wikipedia

The mind

By the account of his youth that he gave late in life to his pupil and secretary Abū ʿUbayd al-Jūzjānī, Avicenna read Aristotle's Metaphysics forty times as a young man in Bukhara, learned it by heart, and still could not see what the book was for. A short treatise by al-Fārābī, the tenth-century philosopher who had worked in Baghdad, explained Aristotle's aims to him at last. The same account says he mastered logic, mathematics and physics largely on his own, was let into the palace library of the Sāmānid ruler of Bukhara after treating him as a physician, and had finished his studies by eighteen. Dimitri Gutas, the historian who has studied that account most closely, reads it as a lesson as much as a memoir. It illustrates Avicenna's own theory of knowledge: a strong mind can reach the truth without a teacher, because it sees at once the middle term that makes an argument work. He called that gift ḥads, intuition.

What he built from there was a single system meant to explain everything, religion included. Its centre is a proof of God that starts not from motion, as Aristotle's did, but from the difference between what must exist and what merely can. Whatever merely can exist, Avicenna argued, owes its existence to something else, and the chain of causes ends in one being that owes it to nothing: the Necessary Existent (wājib al-wujūd), which is God. In everything but God, what a thing is does not include the fact that it is. His encyclopedia al-Shifāʾ (The Healing) closes on this metaphysics and ends with prophecy and religious law, giving Islam itself a philosophical account.

The theologians answered. Al-Ghazālī, the jurist and theologian, wrote his Incoherence of the Philosophers around 1095 and named three of Avicenna's teachings as unbelief: that the world has no beginning in time, that God knows particular things only in a universal way, and that souls do not return to bodies after death. Even so, later thought in the Islamic East was largely built in Avicenna's terms. Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī, a theologian, pressed hard against Remarks and Admonitions, Avicenna's last summary of philosophy, in a commentary on it, and Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī, an astronomer and philosopher, wrote another to defend it. In the seventeenth century the Persian philosopher Mullā Ṣadrā was still writing glosses on the metaphysics of al-Shifāʾ.

His account of the soul starts from a thought experiment. In Kitāb al-Nafs, the book on the soul in al-Shifāʾ, Avicenna asks the reader to imagine a man created in empty air, his eyes veiled, touching nothing. That man would still know that he exists without knowing that he has a body, so the self he knows is not the body. The rational soul, the book argues, thinks without any bodily organ and survives death. Translated into Latin in the twelfth century, the books on the soul and on metaphysics in al-Shifāʾ shaped the scholastics, Thomas Aquinas among them. In Cairo, Maimonides, the Jewish philosopher writing in Arabic, read him too, though he ranked al-Fārābī above him.

He wrote all this while serving rulers who kept changing. In 999 the Turkic Qarakhanids took Bukhara, and Avicenna, an official of the fallen Sāmānid state, left; in his own words, necessity led him to go. He served one court after another as physician and administrator, and in Hamadan became vizier to the Buyid emir Shams al-Dawla. After the emir's death the court suspected him of dealing with ʿAlāʾ al-Dawla, the ruler of Isfahan, and held him for four months in the castle of Fardajān. He spent his last years in ʿAlāʾ al-Dawla's service in Isfahan, and wrote for him a summary of philosophy in Persian; most of his books are in Arabic, the language of learning across the Islamic world. He began al-Shifāʾ in Hamadan at his students' request and finished it in Isfahan by about 1027. His Canon of Medicine (al-Qānūn fī al-ṭibb) taught medicine in European universities until the seventeenth century.

He died in 1037 of colic at Hamadan, on one of his patron's campaigns, and was buried there. Popular stories in the Persian- and Turkish-speaking world later made him a saint and a mystic, or a magician. Most reference works give 980 as the year of his birth. Gutas, who wrote the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy's entry on him, holds that this date is mistaken and that he was born some years earlier, in the 970s.

Key concepts

What is the 'floating man' meant to show?

That a person can be certain they exist without knowing they have a body. Avicenna pictures a man created at once and fully grown, eyes veiled, hanging in empty air with his limbs held apart, touching nothing. He would still affirm his own being while affirming no body at all. Since what is affirmed differs from what is not, the self he knows is something other than his body: the soul.

What is ḥads, the intuition some minds have?

It is the power to hit at once, untaught, on the middle term of a proof: the link that shows why a conclusion follows. All learning runs through such links, and teaching only passes on what some intuitive mind first found. People differ in how much they intuit and how fast, and Avicenna sees no fixed upper limit, so a rare mind might find nearly everything by itself.

What is the Active Intellect?

It is a mind that exists apart from any body and gives human minds their understanding. The senses and imagination supply images of particular things, and these only prepare the soul. The universal itself, the idea of 'human' rather than this or that human, comes from the Active Intellect. Avicenna compares it to the sun: as light lets the eye see colours, this intellect lets the mind grasp what the images only point to.

What is the 'holy intellect' a prophet has?

It is intuition at its highest degree: a mind so ready that it receives the forms of things from the Active Intellect almost all at once, with no teacher. Avicenna places it at the top of the same scale on which every learner stands, so prophecy is not a different kind of knowing but the furthest reach of an ordinary human power, given to very few.

What does pleasure mean in Avicenna's philosophy?

Pleasure is the perception of something that suits the one perceiving it, grasped as good and as reached. Each power has its own: sweetness for taste, victory for anger, truth for the mind. The more complete and lasting the thing grasped, the greater the pleasure, so knowing lasting truths ranks highest. A sick man who dislikes sweet food shows only that something in him is wrong, not that sweetness is.

Themes of the Mind

Concepts that recur together across the corpus held here, gathered into themes and ordered by how much of this philosopher's writing each one occupies.

Existence on Loan

Why is there anything at all, and what keeps it there? Every existing thing, Avicenna answers, holds its being from something else, and only one being holds it from nothing.

Aristotle reached God by tracing motion back to a first mover. Avicenna dug beneath motion to existence itself. In everything but God, what a thing is does not include that it is, so whatever exists has its existence from a cause, and needs that cause at every moment, not only at the start. A world without a first day is therefore no less made. The chain ends in the Necessary Existent, simple and one, whose nature is to be, and existence itself, he holds, is pure good.

  • necessary existence
  • necessity
  • possibility
  • contingency
  • essence
  • existence
  • essence and existence
  • causation
  • dependence
  • infinite regress
  • divine simplicity
  • divine unity
  • emanation
  • creation
  • eternity
  • being

A Soul That Outlives Its Body

What is the 'I' each person is sure of before anything else? A soul that thinks without any bodily organ, Avicenna argues, and what rides on the answer is what survives death.

His starting point is a man created in empty air, eyes veiled, touching nothing, who would still affirm that he exists without affirming a body. From there Avicenna argues that the rational soul is not a power lodged in an organ. It comes into being with its body and needs it to begin learning, but thinking uses no bodily instrument, so the body's death cannot end it. Reason proves this much; the rising of the body, he says, is known from the religious law.

  • soul
  • rational soul
  • self-knowledge
  • self-awareness
  • immateriality
  • incorporeality
  • soul-body relation
  • soul and body
  • body
  • embodiment
  • afterlife
  • immortality
  • identity
  • human nature

Knowledge Given from Above

Where does an idea come from, if the senses only ever show particular things? The mind, on Avicenna's account, can prepare itself, but understanding is given to it.

Sense, imagination and estimation, the inner power by which an animal grasps a danger it cannot see, gather and sort images of particular things. None of them yields a universal. That comes from the Active Intellect, a mind beyond ours that does for thinking what the sun does for seeing. Logic trains the soul to receive, and teaching helps, yet every teacher's knowledge began in someone's intuition, ḥads: the sudden grasp of the middle term that makes a proof work, which some minds have without any teacher.

  • intellect
  • active intellect
  • abstraction
  • intelligible forms
  • knowledge
  • epistemology
  • demonstration
  • imagination
  • internal senses
  • perception
  • psychic faculties
  • universals
  • logic
  • inference

Truth for the Few, Images for the Many

Can one truth be told to a philosopher and a farmer alike? Not in the same words, Avicenna thought, and the prophet is the one person who can speak it to both.

On his account the prophet has every human power at its height: an intellect that grasps by intuition what others reach by proof, an imagination that turns truths into vivid images, and a soul strong enough to heal beyond its own body. He gives a law because no one lives alone. To the many he says that God is one and without equal and stops there, since telling them God is in no place would only unsettle their religion. Images move people sooner than proofs.

  • prophecy
  • law
  • political philosophy
  • providence
  • divine providence
  • prayer
  • dreams
  • imagination
  • rhetoric
  • poetry
  • imitation
  • language

Joy Beyond the Senses

What is a human life finally for? A pleasure most people never suspect, Avicenna replies: the mind's joy in knowing, and a love of perfection that runs through everything that exists.

Pleasure, for Avicenna, is perceiving what suits the one who perceives, so the higher the power, the greater its joy, and the mind's grasp of lasting truths outranks every pleasure of the senses. That most people feel nothing of it proves no more than a numbed tongue proves food tasteless. Every being loves its own perfection, God most of all, at once lover and beloved. A life well governed readies the soul for its happiness after death, and even simple souls who learned little find mercy and rest.

  • love
  • desire
  • perfection
  • pleasure
  • goodness
  • good and evil
  • final causation
  • teleology
  • virtue
  • virtue ethics
  • moral psychology
  • education
  • cosmic order

By the numbers

works held
11
passages traced
1,708
concepts traced
1,136
thematic clusters
5

Concepts that travel together

The wheel takes the leading concepts of these writings and shows how often they come up together. The wider the band between two, the more passages speak of both. Among them, most often together: “causation” and “metaphysics”.
Concept co-occurrence, strongest first 8 concepts, joined by 25 pairings. 85 pairings reach beyond these concepts and are not drawn.
ConceptPaired conceptShared passages
causationmetaphysics35
causationsoul28
definitionlogic27
metaphysicsuniversals26
intellectuniversals23
intellectsoul22
causationintellect21
logicuniversals21
perceptionsoul21
definitionuniversals18
intellectperception15
causationperception14
causationuniversals13
intellectmetaphysics11
causationdefinition10
perceptionuniversals8
definitionsoul7
logicmetaphysics7
causationlogic5
definitionmetaphysics4
metaphysicssoul4
souluniversals4
intellectlogic2
definitionperception1
logicperception1

The arc of a career

A cell's weight is that concept's share of the work's passages, so a column can be read downwards as well as a row across. Densest: logic in Remarks and Admonitions, 71.6%.

Density 0% 71.6%

Concept density per work, chronological 11 works, in the order they were written. 8 concept columns, ranked by total weight. 98 further concepts fall outside the columns shown.
WorkYearcausationlogicsoulmetaphysicsdefinitionintellectuniversalsperception
A Compendium on the Soul10.9%3.6%20%7.3%5.5%10.9%9.1%18.2%
Kitāb al-Siyāsa0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%
The Healing, Logic: Isagoge1.5%27.8%0%5.3%35.3%2.3%22.6%0%
Risāla fī maʿrifat al-nafs al-nāṭiqa wa-aḥwālihā0%0%13.3%0%0%20%0%6.7%
Kitāb al-Nafs17.7%0%20.8%0.5%1.6%14.6%3.1%27.6%
Commentary on the Poetics of Aristotle0%0%0%0%1.9%0%1.9%0%
Remarks and Admonitions4.5%71.6%0%3%16.4%0%4.5%0%
The Metaphysics of The Healing25.3%1.9%4%16%6.6%5.1%8.5%1.3%
al-Taʿlīqāt34.2%2.9%11.2%11.2%4.7%13.6%13%6.8%
al-Najāt19.3%11.6%8.9%7%5.2%6.4%4.6%4.6%
A Treatise on Love11.1%0%7.4%29.6%0%3.7%0%0%

Works held

Titles in your language, the original beneath in brackets; “lit.” marks our own translation where no English edition exists. Side chips show which full texts are held.

  1. A Compendium on the Soul (Kitāb fī al-nafs ʿalā sunnat al-ikhtiṣār)

    The earliest of his books, written for the Sāmānid court at Bukhara before any of the summaries of philosophy that made his name.

    EN
  2. A Treatise on Love (Risāla fī māhiyyat al-ʿishq)

    Written at the request of a jurist, Abū ʿAbd Allāh al-Maʿṣūmī, and set out in seven short sections.

    AR
  3. lit. The Salvation al-Najāt

    Between the vast al-Shifāʾ and the allusive Ishārāt in both length and manner, and the usual way into his logic.

    AR
  4. lit. The Notes al-Taʿlīqāt

    A classroom companion to his metaphysics: short notes on its key terms, read today beside al-Shifāʾ.

    AR
  5. Commentary on the Poetics of Aristotle (Fann al-Shiʿr)

    Filed under logic, as the Arabic tradition filed Aristotle's Poetics, it closes the nine logical books of al-Shifāʾ.

    AR
  6. lit. The Book of the Soul Kitāb al-Nafs

    The fullest of his many accounts of the soul, written as natural science, and the one Latin Europe read.

    AR
  7. lit. The Book of Governance Kitāb al-Siyāsa

    The household branch of practical philosophy, set out for a man, his family and his servants, in a short Arabic treatise.

    AR
  8. Remarks and Admonitions (al-Ishārāt wa-l-tanbīhāt)

    Shorter than al-Najāt and far shorter than al-Shifāʾ, though written after both, as a statement of his mature philosophy.

    AR
  9. lit. Treatise on Knowing the Rational Soul and Its States Risāla fī maʿrifat al-nafs al-nāṭiqa wa-aḥwālihā

    A short epistle in three chapters and an epilogue, one of several treatises on the soul that circulate under his name.

    AR
  10. The Healing, Logic: Isagoge (al-Madkhal)

    The first of the nine books of logic in al-Shifāʾ, and the place where the prologue to the whole encyclopedia stands.

    AR
  11. The Metaphysics of The Healing (al-Ilāhiyyāt)

    His fullest metaphysics, known to Latin readers as the Liber de philosophia prima; it closes al-Shifāʾ after the logic, the physics and the mathematics.

    AR
Begin a dialogue with Avicenna

— or wander to another mind

Set two minds against each other

Each of these is a question the two of them answer differently. Choose one and they argue it out, both drawing on the texts held here.