The Search for Self-Command
What is the temperance a whole city praises — quietness, modesty, or a strange knowledge that knows itself? Every answer slips away.
At a wrestling-school the talk turns to sōphrosynē, self-command, and to the handsome Charmides and his guardian Critias — two men who would help fasten the Thirty Tyrants on Athens, as Plato knew when he wrote it. The definitions rise and fall, ending in the knotted idea of a knowledge of knowledge itself, and none survives. Two men who could not say what self-control is would prove in life to have none. It reads now both as a study of temperance and as Plato's quiet reckoning with the kinsmen who disgraced his city.
- epistemology
- virtue
- temperance
- wisdom
- science
- definition
- self-knowledge
- methodology
- practical wisdom
- modesty
- knowledge
- medicine
- happiness
Enter a dialogue
- Your Socrates says a headache leaf works only with a charm of fair words that plants self-control in the soul. How can words do that?
- Charmides first calls self-control quietness. Yet writing, wrestling and playing the lyre are done better quickly. Why does that sink the answer?
- Someone wants to master his own impulses but cannot say what self-command even is. Where should he begin?
- Self-control, says Critias, is knowing what one knows and does not know. Why could such a person still not tell a true doctor from a pretender?
- Charmides and Critias discuss self-control and later show none of it. Does knowing the definition even help a person live it?