What Makes an Act Holy
Pressed to define the piety he is so sure of, a confident prosecutor cannot say whether the gods love holy acts or their love is what makes them holy.
Bound for his own impiety trial, Socrates asks a seer certain enough to prosecute his own father to state what holiness is — and every attempt collapses. One question outlasts the rest: is an act holy because the gods love it, or loved because it is already holy? Recast as whether divine command makes an act good or merely tracks its goodness, it became the Euthyphro dilemma, still the sharpest objection to grounding morality in God's will. The dialogue ends, as Socratic inquiries do, in admitted ignorance.
- piety
- definition
- justice
- essence
- authority
- divine approval
- divine command
- epistemology
- religion
- causation
- irony
Enter a dialogue
- The seer Euthyphro says Zeus bound his own father Cronos, so prosecuting his father is holy. Why does your Socrates think a god's example settles nothing?
- If the gods quarrel over right and wrong, one act may be dear to Zeus and hateful to Cronos. Then how can what the gods love measure holiness?
- Suppose a person cannot tell whether what he does is truly pious or only his family's custom. How would you steady him?
- Euthyphro says your Socrates' arguments keep walking away like the creations of Daedalus, the legendary inventor. Why would he give anything to make them stay put?
- Euthyphro was certain enough to prosecute his own father. Why should such confidence about holiness count for so little?