Speech as the Leading of Souls
Can persuasion ever be an art rather than a bag of tricks? Only, Plato answers, when the speaker knows both the truth and the soul he is trying to lead.
Socrates first out-argues a cool speech against love, then recants in the palinode praising love as a divine madness and painting the soul as a charioteer whose wings regrow at the sight of beauty, remembering the Forms. From there the dialogue turns practical: real rhetoric is grounded in dialectic and knowledge of its listener, not manipulation. It closes with the myth of writing as pharmakon — remedy and poison at once — warning that written words, unable to answer back, only seem to teach. Derrida's famous reading returns to that passage.
- rhetoric
- persuasion
- truth
- love
- soul
- wisdom
- knowledge
- desire
- education
Enter a dialogue
- The orator Lysias says a young man should choose the suitor who does not love him, since lovers turn jealous. What does that cool advice get right?
- Men so ravished by the Muses’ songs forgot to eat until they died, and now sing on as cicadas. What does that say about devotion to a pursuit?
- Explaining away myths, like the wind-god abducting a girl, is clever, yet your Socrates has no time for it before knowing himself. Why does self-knowledge come first?
- Someone besotted by love loses their reason. Why does your Socrates, taking back his attack on love, call that madness a gift of the gods?