The Statesman's Knowledge
What makes someone genuinely fit to rule? Expert knowledge, Plato answers — a knowing so real it could rightly govern even against the written law.
The Eleatic Stranger hunts the statesman by division, and along the way gives the myth of a cosmos that periodically reverses its spin and the image of statecraft as weaving the brave and gentle temperaments into one cloth. True political skill is expert knowledge; laws are only crude general rules, second-best stand-ins for a real knower's judgement. Yet where no such expert exists, strict obedience to law becomes safest, and the constitutions are ranked accordingly. Bridging the Sophist and the Laws, it tempers the Republic's confidence in rule set above law.
- political philosophy
- governance
- statesmanship
- expertise
- authority
- methodology
- classification
- leadership
- definition
- law
Enter a dialogue
- A doctor who left written instructions returns early and finds something else would now help the patient. Why should a city be more bound to written laws?
- A judge must apply a statute that plainly misfits the case before her. Your Stranger calls law an obstinate tyrant who allows no questions. Should she obey it?
- Your Eleatic Stranger lets a true expert rule even against written law. What stops a false expert, who persuades many, from claiming the same right?
- Your Stranger imagines an age when a god herded people and the earth fed them. Why does their happiness hang on what they did with endless leisure?
- Too much peace enslaves a city, too much war ruins it. What binds the bold and the gentle when your Eleatic Stranger weaves them into one cloth?